who is copying who?:[

bento

@bento

Voyager

15

Posted: 13 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: benhur
as it is most indian crime shows copy their story from old X-files or CSI cases aired on american television so nothing really strange about it

The only story ever copied from CSI was

36

2007 Sep 07

THE CASE OF INSPECTOR DAYA'S ABDUCTION

was from CSI

24 Grave Danger, Part 1 - Season 5 Aired on May 19, 2005

4

Reply

Quote

BeastInCarnage

@BeastInCarnage

Rocker

26

Posted: 13 years ago

#12

I don't think there is any true crime story writer in present days in Television or Movies industries. Most shows are either copied from old shows or from other country's show.

They can make shows on base of foreign crime novels or stories, but alas there is no such good director present for making that.

1

Reply

Quote

benhur

@benhur

Explorer

8

Posted: 13 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: adgadgadg

not necessary
if u see criminal minds u must have noticed them copying some of our classic cases

my point was that almost all crime shows are copied or inspired from some other show... i mean after all its either about revenge, money, property, love, etc... basic emotions and needs which inspire most crime... so not surprising that everything seems similar to something else...

1

Reply

Quote

mallikaBalu

@mallikaBalu

Dazzler

21

Posted: 13 years ago

#14

I agree with assassinator.

There is a big dearth of proper crime writers for both hte big screen and small screen. One needs to pay a good writer and respect the copyright issues by the production houses. This does not happen to a large extent in India.

No I am not getting negative. There are many shows in the west shown on PBS or local channels that are good well written crime shows. Many can't be shown here as they are in water tight copyright material.

In India, crime writing as a genre requires a lot of prerequisites. Many writers don't match up to these criterion. So the result is what we are seeing on all the so called popular crime shows.😊

1

Reply

Quote

Roopal Gupta

@..Roopal..

Trailblazer

41

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: bento

The only story ever copied from CSI was
36 2007 Sep 07 THE CASE OF INSPECTOR DAYA'S ABDUCTION

was from CSI

24 Grave Danger, Part 1 - Season 5 Aired on May 19, 2005

i agree

i have watched that epi of CSI too

Reply

Quote

Real Hoon Main Samjha Kya

@Alpha_Aakash

Trailblazer

42

+ 6

Posted: 13 years ago

#16

And wat was funny is that during Arjuns 10 pm repeat..Both shows had same type off scene going on..where in Arjun he is trying to see The video footage of marraige..and similarly in CID ACP was checking Marriage video footage...lolz wat a timing man!!!...

Reply

Quote

Mini

@iMini

Sparkler

33

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#17

exactly!
and ppl assume it to be a mere coincidence:[

2

Reply

Quote

benhur

@benhur

Explorer

8

Posted: 13 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: adgadgadg
exactly!
and ppl assume it to be a mere coincidence:[

kuch toh gadbad hai daya kuch toh gadbad hai ... pata lagao yeh hua to hua kaise... script ka ek ek kona dhoond nikalo... yeh mujrim chootna nahi chahiye 🤣

3

Reply

Quote