THE GREAT IF RE-RUN THREAD - 1 - Page 79

Created

Last reply

Replies

1k

Views

72k

Users

46

Likes

981

Frequent Posters

astonish thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
🤗 Father's revenge
My favorite favorite case... must have watched it a hundred times and still feel like watching it again and again

Perfection, that's what i loved in that case... ofcourse by Daya sir 😍
every face expression... every act... and especially the way he is always... doing something with his hands...putting his face down...the guilty feeling... portrayed flawlessly
visrom thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
Continuing Father's revenge while having breakfast. 😆
The place where the guy comes to collect the bag is the same place where Abhijeet goes beserk in AKA - 5 or 6 and tries to kill a guy.
ACP first just mentioned to Daya that he should not have fired so fast. That was fine, but in the hospital ACP actually scolds him as if he had committed a crime. This was a bit unfair. ACP was more worried about the boy. In his view a civilian's life is more important than a cop's life, but anyone in Daya's position would have done the same thing. Also notice Abhijeet's reaction when Daya got scolded. If possible rewind the scene several times, see each person's expression separately. Abhijeet doesn't know what to say. 😆 On one hand Daya had saved his life and on the other hand ACP is scolding Daya for it.
Arif Zakaria is such a good actor. How well he has portrayed the role of a distressed father. He says 'agar aapka beta hota toh aapko pata chalta'. At that time, ACP gives Daya a stare. Daya feels bad and looks down...very very sad expression. Abhijeet gives Arif an 'angry stare'.
After that...🤣 the other trio raid a house and the guy shows the place where he parks the motorcycle. Abhijeet says 'yeh hai motorcyle, is khaali zameen ko motorcycle bolta hai, hain???'🤣 OMG...who is the dialogue writer????
Then the CID team goes to LWI factory and finds the spot where the boy was tied. Abhijeet catches the watchman and asks him 'baccha kahan hai' with a fiery expression. It was awesome. Here it is...
The last scene sweet and very very touching. When you see the episode as a whole, you understand how bad Daya was feeling about the whole incident. He wanted to be the one to find Karan. In the end, Daya sees Karan and just leaps over him to prevent the stones from falling over him. Daya gets hurt in the process, but Karan is saved.
Abhijeet was feeling bad too, though he couldn't say anything in front of ACP. He was feeling bad about the resgination letter which Daya submitted and ACP scolding Daya for it. Abhijeet might have felt 'yeh sab meri wajah se hua, na Daya mujhe bachane aata aur na use ACP sir daant sunni padti'.
Just imagine our duo if the boy had not been found. Daya would have been suspended (for shooting Sattu) and Abhijeet would have had to live with the fact that Daya was suspended just because he tried to save his life. That 'hey Daya, resign karega' had a lot of of hidden meaning. Many unspoken words between our duo. Lovely episode. Any day I would give it a 5/5 and will never tire of seeing this one.
Special appreciation to the story writer and the dialogue writer. They were awesome. 👏 Daya was at his best...that expression as he looks down when ACP scolds is very touching. ACP was a his best too. He was scolding Daya, but not shouting at the top of his voice like he does now. His words had so much of impact.
This episode had some action in the quarry, running over stones, blasts happening all over the place...this would have qualified as a Dhoom episode. Wish the Dhoom series had stories like this in the background instead of some of the meaningless episodes made just to show some OTT action without any real purpose.
Edited by visrom - 14 years ago
debasree04 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
Wow Visrom lovely review...
Daya sir has no other option to shoot otherwise it is sure that the person shoot Abhijit sir...when in the hospital ACP sir scold him saying "Usne goli chalaya...agar goli nehin marta (like that)"...how he said that...I mean it is quite sure he shoot Abhijit sir...maybe the priority is more towards the rescue of that child than his junior's life...it is very much awkward situation for Abhijit sir...
For me it's really a wonderful episode...I never feel bored with this kind of episode...& last scene just awesome...dialogues r too good...
astonish thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
I donno if it is the decision of the director or the story writer... but the way an owl is shown in the beginning just to say that "CID is keeping an eye on someone during night like an owl" was just awesome. 👏

One thing that used to amaze me the most in CID in golden days was...whenever the shooting is in Jungle, they either show a spider web and a dangerous looking spider.. or a strange looking insect... or a snake... there used to be something shown which would aptly depict the current situation in the case



Swapn jhare phool se, meet chubhe shool se
lut gaye shringaar sabhi, baag ke babool se
aur ham khade khade, bahaar dekhate rahe
kaaravaan guzar gayaa, gubaar dekhate rahe


The bureau scene after the 1st hospital scene... Daya sir standing one stand leaning to the wall... putting his face down... no tears in Daya sir's eyes... but surely will bring tears in the viewers eyes...
And the 1st and last time.. i was totally 😡 at ACP sir...was when daya sir gives his resignation...and he says his resignation letter dialog
and the last scene... it was a part of behrupiya Daya sir's memory scenes
Edited by astonish - 14 years ago
NandiniRaizadaa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
Watching father's revenge for the second time. I had not noticed previously. The episode does start with an owl. I wonder whose idea it was. Very impactful

The bag taking scene is very dark but it does its purpose. It creates intrigue and suspense

Yes I also saw that scene , Abhijeet was totally in his control. He could have easily shot him. Daya had to shoot him to save Abhijeet , he had no choice. It was dark, he could not have accurately aimed, and there was no time to aim anyways. If Daya had not shot that person would have,

And his Abhijeet, tum theek to ho was so full of concern


ACP considere duty first but your officer's safety is also as important.

Ye Abhijeet was truly scared, And later his expressions were as if he had nothing to say
He was totally at a loss of words. ACP was too harsh

Later when Daya saves the boy, that scene was wow

Yes a 5/5 rating and special mention of the excellent direction, dialogues,



Bhavanab thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
My Backlog is literally HUGE !!! Wonder when I'll get time ... Will see from backward !!! Have a nice long list to complete !!
astonish thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
When Daya sir gives his resignation... ACP sir turns towards abhi sir and tells his dialogs looking at him... wonderful job by abhi sir there...

His expressions were perfect... he culdnt give an "yes i agree" look to ACP sir...neither can he tell to
ACP sir that daya sir fell into this trouble because of him... nor can he go to daya sir and help him out... He just Silently... looks at ACP sir... and waits for him to complete his sentence.

At the same time look at Asha... initially she gives a look of... "ohh no... don't... ACP sir will get angrier" and then once ACP gets angry...she alternatively looks at ACP sir and daya sir ... and looking at daya sir.. she feels so bad for daya sir.
NandiniRaizadaa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
The case of the last show


The forgotten second episode of this week



Well this is is a good episode too. Duo investigating together, A rare sight. The case starts with the murder of a famous actor. There are three suspects. The motives of all three are clearly stated. A clear cut investigation follows. Though coincidences are a little more in this case.
Especially the blind man. A bit difficult to digest,

I liked the way they used the taxi unions. They dont do that anymore

Also I liked the dilogue aur Mumbai ki Aabadi Austrailia ise zyada hai by the ACP. I remember that dialogue well and tend to use it quiet often if someone mentions an impossible situation to me. Nice to recall the episode

Well I was not very satisfied by the final outcome, I was expecting something else.

Side actors were good and direction, screenplay etc all were good

Edited by nandiniraizada - 14 years ago
NandiniRaizadaa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
I will try and post some caps from this case today evening
Edited by nandiniraizada - 14 years ago
Drilabh_Suhaani thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
The thing is- if daya had shot only once or atleast at leg, nothing wud have happened. yes acp did over react. and yes this time abhi and asha and freddy-sudhakar were silent. but i wish they did defend him. abhi wud have asked acp (the way he did in traitors in cid) boldly whether he wud have preferrred him being shot. well... quite an episode, and one of those cases which are uncharacteristic of the characters. acp the cool headed calm leader suddenly over reacting... he did not over react in killer lake-staged murder cases... he did not scream at daya in mysterious matrionials wen a man was shot while fleeing and initially it was thought daya had shot him. well, there are some episodes which i just cant digest, such as case of frame up (showing abhijeet's over reaction), case of giant wheel (unnecessary aggression towardsa man with vertigo- i myself have vertigo and hydrophobia- i wud have killed, litterally violently killed anyone who wud treat me like that.), case of father's revenge etc...
Edited by suhaani.cid - 14 years ago

Related Topics

CID thumbnail

Posted by: Minionite · 9 months ago

Opening TRP is out. 1.4 is pretty good. https://x.com/GossipsTv/status/1872335699959263257

https://x.com/GossipsTv/status/1872335699959263257
Expand ▼
CID thumbnail

Posted by: Nikita_99503 · 9 months ago

Hello everyone!!! Welcome to the CID BTS, Social Media updates and spoilers thread. Kindly share all updates regarding the show here in this...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".