CID Re-Run (Discussions & Videos) - V

First Previous

Page

115

Next Last

Frequent Posters

m_kal2011

@m_kal2011

Rocker

Posted: 15 years ago

#111

Originally posted by: visrom

Daya's parents passed away when Daya and his slblings were young.

So there were 3 kids...2 boys aged 9 and 7 and one girl aged 5 who landed in Mamta Foundation.

Daya graduated from there. It all fits in.

I also think same.

Edited by m_kal2011 - 15 years ago

Quote

m_kal2011

@m_kal2011

Rocker

Posted: 15 years ago

#112

Originally posted by: visrom
Though I don't remember having seen him, some people who have seen Missing Bullet say that he was remembering his dad. I assumed that Daya was about 7-8 years old when his parents passed away, so he is old enough to remember his dad.

The shakal yaad nahin hai dialogue was a blunder like the blunder in Sr Ins Abhijeet about memory loss being a naatak. Don't pay attention to that one dialogue. The rest of the story is ok.

This is lack of continuity.
But the dialogue "shakaal yaad nahin hain" was in "the gift" where there is a distant relative of Daya.
Am I right or I am confusing?

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

visrom

@visrom

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 15 years ago

#113

What surprises me is that our trio inspite of having played the characters for 12 years blindly say the dialogues that are given to them. Someone who has got into the skin of a character should be able to decide what a character can say and what he cannot.

I don't know. I am not in their shoes. I cannot speak for them, but I have read an actor's autobiography where he had written about how he had to convince a director that the character would never behave like that. The director was made to rewrite the entire script because of this.

Quote

prabha.

@prabha.

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#114

Originally posted by: visrom
The shakal yaad nahin hai dialogue was a blunder like the blunder in Sr Ins Abhijeet about memory loss being a naatak. Don't pay attention to that one dialogue. The rest of the story is ok.

O Come on @Viz its all a blunder there is not head or tail to the story. When I look at a story I am going to look at all the references, why should I skip the dialog for like FW does for its convenience. The background of officers are changed at random to fit in some emotional drama and that has been the case all the time.

Nothing explains Rajiv to Nakul, Constantly changing names of Freddie's wife, changing pics of Abhi Sir's mom. Its all a mess.

@ m_kal2011 See my post above.

Edited by prabha. - 15 years ago

Quote

m_kal2011

@m_kal2011

Rocker

Posted: 15 years ago

#115

Originally posted by: visrom
What surprises me is that our trio inspite of having played the characters for 12 years blindly say the dialogues that are given to them. Someone who has got into the skin of a character should be able to decide what a character can say and what he cannot.
I don't know. I am not in their shoes. I cannot speak for them, but I have read an actor's autobiography where he had written about how he had to convince a director that the character would never behave like that. The director was made to rewrite the entire script because of this.

That surprises me too.
I once asked that can't the actors do anything(regarding the poor quality). I feel they are best to judge the difference. T don't know what's the problem. Are they really helpless?
(the same question I asked in my last poll)

Quote

prabha.

@prabha.

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#116

I am sure if there was anything actors could do, they would have done. its thanks to them that the charatcers have been consistent due to their performances, they are doing what is in their hands.

Originally posted by: visrom
a blunder like the blunder in Sr Ins Abhijeet about memory loss being a naatak.

By the way from what I know this was brought to the dialog writer's notice and amzingly he does not feel its a blunder. He feels it is a justified response. Supposedly its the CID Officer in Daya Sir who is saying all this. He does not seem to know Daya Sir as much as we do then. SO you see that is how FW thinks.

Edited by prabha. - 15 years ago

Quote

visrom

@visrom

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 15 years ago

#117

Originally posted by: prabha.

O Come on Viz its all a blunder there is not head or tail to the story. When I look at a story I am going to look at all the references, why should I leave the dialog. The background of officers are changed at random to fit in some emotional drama and that have been the case all the time.

Nothing explains Rajiv to Nakul, Constantly changing names of Freddie's wife, changing pics of Abhi Sir's mom. Its all a mess.

It's tough, but if I assume Daya is an orphan, it will look like the character in Injured Witness or Missing Bullet or Target CID was not Daya.

If I assume he is not an orphan, then that interrogation scene in the Mamta Foundation episode becomes meaningless...oh, I loved that scene. Lovely chemistry between our duo, showed the tough side and the soft side of Abhijeet. I can't foget this too.

I am looking through these blunders. I am able to enjoy some episodes this way.

Quote

prabha.

@prabha.

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#118

Originally posted by: visrom
I am looking through these blunders. I am able to enjoy some episodes this way.

Yaar that even I do, but that does not mean that these are not blunders, they are. FW are careless, thats it.

Edited by prabha. - 15 years ago

Quote

m_kal2011

@m_kal2011

Rocker

Posted: 15 years ago

#119

In the past FW was careless, but now..... blind girl reading books in library etc. etc....... now what to tell them?
Ok, I am leaving now, will join you later.

Edited by m_kal2011 - 15 years ago

Quote

prabha.

@prabha.

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#120

Earlier they were careless now they are ridiculous. And I did check that book she was reading in the recording, it did not seem like it was in brail to me, I saw printed letters on it. She too was not touching the pages to feel the letters. Utter Nonsense.

Edited by prabha. - 15 years ago

Quote

1 ... 10 11 12 13 14 ... 115

CID Re-Run (Discussions & Videos) - V - Page 12

Related Topics

Explore Topics