Question about relevancy

Hey guys...esp dev team,
I have a question about how relevant a topic should be to be discussed in a certain forum at IF. I just read one of the posts hypothetically saying that if Neha replaces Janvi, it'll be funny....b/c she's acted with Iqbal and Vivan separately, it'll be funny. Not that the person said it was going to happen or she wished it did, but hypothetically just speaking her mind.. I didnt see anything wrong with that b/c we ARE discussing the show and people somehow related to each other. If not here, where on IF should this topic have been brought up...or not brought up at all even if u wanna discuss it?
I don't mean to offend anyone..this is just a question for my own knowledge b/c I dint understand why that topic was closed.
Feel free to close this topic after answering it for me :)
Thanks!!

i think cuz like a lot of topics were made about it already i guess, n i dunno...like i guess in the beginging every1 was like janvi isnt pretty enough n stuff so i guess every1 is a lil touchy about it now.

i didnt care, i luv iqbal n neha together. but i liek janvi in CHA too 😳

Yes, cuz than it will lead to all discussions cuz than Shabd(Vivan)- Mahi(Neha) fans at one end and Angad(IQ)- Kripa(Neha) fans at one end, which wont be good would it? And it will be how good they are and how bad they are and who looks good with who...

Lot of topics were made already on that issue here, during the initial days.

And usually we have clashes among members with such topics here thats why we close them. 😊

arey yaar ...1000 topics were made of neha entering CHA and i guess many ppl were juss fed up answering the same question every now n then!

Originally posted by: *Shifali*

Yes, cuz than it will lead to all discussions cuz than Shabd(Vivan)- Mahi(Neha) fans at one end and Angad(IQ)- Kripa(Neha) fans at one end, which wont be good would it? And it will be how good they are and how bad they are and who looks good with who...

hmm..that makes sense. I haven't been around too long to see previous topics about this..but I have noticed fans getting very defensive about their particular faves on many other forums.
Thanks for explaining e/one. :)