Take 0:Satyanashing 18[IO] - Page 10

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

106.6k

Users

22

Likes

4.1k

Frequent Posters

Newbiesoapfan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#91

Originally posted by: psarada


The story has always been Rudra centric Tulip even from the beginning. But now they have watered down the character of Rudra when he let paro go on the trip to birpur. What exactly was he going to prove if paro did contact her mamisa. That the fact that paro was the niece of the lady, well okay apart from that what could he get or achieve by this? Absolutely nothing. Because where does it prove that paro having a mami in birpur connects her to the arms smuggling thing. Rather if they have shown rudra doing an independent investigation, it would have held some ground. That is why I said Aman is working for me because he did get an genuine doubt that paro may be innocent in the whole ordeal.

Yesterday they had such a nice scene where they could have shown paro lamenting her loss when she sees her red lengha peeking out of the cupboard. She could have touched the fabric and could have lamented the loss of her married life even before it began, and rudra could have shown being guilty - that would have been really good. But nope the creatives gave in a forced rasiya ve where in rudra tears of paro's shirt.

There was this one movie which was by Ahithyan - Prem Lekha(it was dubbed from tamil only with Ajith as the hero where the hero and heroine meet over letters and fall in love but meet in the last frame of the movie). When the movie was made it seems the distributors told the director that this movie would be a flop because the hero and heroine don't meet at all so having Ajith and no chemistry is going to turn this movie to a flop. But then this movie was the biggest blockbuster and ran to full houses in Tamil/Telugu and was remade in many languages. Just shows that sometimes sticking by your beliefs gives you better results.


Sarada - you probably missed the episode or skipped these scenes while watching... the same mani disowned Paro in front of the Thakur and Thakur told Rudra that Paro was not of his village... so it wasn't her baraat that left ... so the idea is to catch the thakur on one lie and then trip him up...

That's an age old trick in criminal stories... you trip up on a lie and then its fair game that you can lie again... I guess you would have watched enough criminal series to guess this...

I miss the Kadhal Kottai reference...
Newbiesoapfan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#92
J -- hope you see this! The CVs are surely reading your Take 5s!!
Chachi sa's dialog today -ghale mein kharash - there naam hai kya!!

Hail J ai Jagadambe Trisula!😉
-Maggie- thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#93
Just caught today's RR episode..

I really enjoyed it! It was taut with action, drama and left me wanting more!

Loved how Rudra's dad claimed Paro as his own! I have not seen many serials where the in-laws actually stand up for their Bahus, so this was refreshing. Rudra's father was in full Protector mode which was really good to see. The actor did an amazing job in these scenes.

I agree with many of the posts citing the illogical and under-developed plot points. I also wish to know more about Paro and her character. But, I am hoping that will be developed further. I do find her character and Mithalia (?spelling) to be the weaker characters in terms of development. Let's hope they give Paro some fire and life!

I can't wait to see Rudra's WT* moment tomorrow! I will also wait for the day when he defends
Paro's honor with as much (and hopefully more 😳 ) fire than his father.

Edited by -Maggie- - 11 years ago
-Maggie- thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#94


This post has garnered some attention:

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=3908825

Am working my way through it.
tulip21 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#95
To Make things clear from side...
I dont want to Paro to sit and cry but i want her feel lost and has a fear of being with the BSD officer who has killed her husband and spoiled her dreams...She should not out there to help him with the jar if there is hate and fear she will be avoiding any sought of help from her side...I have no problems with her smile but she sleeping aaram se when he is around is not working for me...she should have crumbled herself to a corner...

@Ash i get your point of catching Thakur but Paro returned back to keep safe her village people...once back she is behaving like a good girl in a unwanted place...

I dont want her to mourn as Widow or sit and weep and also not behaving like the bahu of the house...

The writing here messed up immediately jumping into rasiyave and announcing them as couple...When she heared that she should have felt bad felt like a very bad happened to her instead she stood there confused and lost...so i want the creative team to utilize the good actors they have...
tulip21 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#96
Had great hopes for ThP and it is not going well...Paakhi kept out of all lies again and again and she being so sweet is stretching the story no where...With a promo out for truth to be unfold this is too much to handle...first 15 days and now 7 days to send paakhi is being repetitive and boring...looking forward for paakhi to know the truth
PSharada thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#97

Originally posted by: Newbiesoapfan




Sarada - you probably missed the episode or skipped these scenes while watching... the same mani disowned Paro in front of the Thakur and Thakur told Rudra that Paro was not of his village... so it wasn't her baraat that left ... so the idea is to catch the thakur on one lie and then trip him up...

That's an age old trick in criminal stories... you trip up on a lie and then its fair game that you can lie again... I guess you would have watched enough criminal series to guess this...

I miss the Kadhal Kottai reference...


@Bold:- The reason I said about Kadhal Kottai reference was that there is no need to get both the characters in just to have the chemistry going. Both Ashish and Sanaya are good actors and even keeping them apart the creatives could have weaved a good enough story. I doubt mamisa would have accepted paro even when paro would have gone alone, that much rudra should have understood. The creatives could have weaved the story of Rudra and paro both individually trying to figure out what the truth is and meeting somewhere in the middle but I feel due to the pressure of chemistry, they got paro back into the Ranawat Haveli which could have been avoided. Maybe TRPs being this low this track was jumped so soon but yes it is giving a very open ended feeling.

Edited by psarada - 11 years ago
PSharada thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#98

Originally posted by: tulip21

Had great hopes for ThP and it is not going well...Paakhi kept out of all lies again and again and she being so sweet is stretching the story no where...With a promo out for truth to be unfold this is too much to handle...first 15 days and now 7 days to send paakhi is being repetitive and boring...looking forward for paakhi to know the truth


Don't tell me about it. I had so much hopes on paakhi getting to the truth this monday but damn it is again a 7 day challenge. If the show is hit, I think makers can't escape the stretching of the show when the channels pressurized them. But since the tag line is still playing I think the truth would be out soon. I watch the episodes on record and this saves me the headache of a boring episode. If the episode is blah as per the WU, I just delete it without any hesitation.
Edited by psarada - 11 years ago
PSharada thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#99

Originally posted by: tulip21

To Make things clear from side...

I dont want to Paro to sit and cry but i want her feel lost and has a fear of being with the BSD officer who has killed her husband and spoiled her dreams...She should not out there to help him with the jar if there is hate and fear she will be avoiding any sought of help from her side...I have no problems with her smile but she sleeping aaram se when he is around is not working for me...she should have crumbled herself to a corner...

@Ash i get your point of catching Thakur but Paro returned back to keep safe her village people...once back she is behaving like a good girl in a unwanted place...

I dont want her to mourn as Widow or sit and weep and also not behaving like the bahu of the house...

The writing here messed up immediately jumping into rasiyave and announcing them as couple...When she heared that she should have felt bad felt like a very bad happened to her instead she stood there confused and lost...so i want the creative team to utilize the good actors they have...


@tulip:- You and I are on the same reference point. I completely agree with you. Agreed that the marriage was in name sake but for a girl who dreamed of a married life for so long, the loss of her husband should have been traumatic but that is not happening. I doubt paro is angry on Rudra too because she is ready to make rotis for him. That doesn't go well with the character.

@bold- You explained the same point that I did with the Kadal Kottai reference. There was no reason to jump in and announce them as a couple.
PSharada thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: -Maggie-



This post has garnered some attention:

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=3908825

Am working my way through it.


I went through the post. I think people are misunderstanding the whole 'paro not acting a widow' thing. LIke tulip and I said, it is not so much about paro wearing the old white or black stuff to show that she is a widow but the grief and the angst that is missing. For a person who lost everything showing paro so okay with rudra the person who killed her husband is not working for me at least. If they so wanted to have paro have the feelings for rudra they could have gone the 'Witness' movie way where paro too knows the truth of the arms dealing. But cvs telling that paro is unknown to the whole thing and then she being okay wearing bright clothes and not even remembering her husband is little too hard to understand and accept.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".