Changes and more!! (SwaRon post)

Legilimens. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#1

Okay, so a scene was given today. Or at least Ameeta tried to give a scene today. Yes. Appreciated. Really appreciated... We don't know whether she gave out of compulsion or because of realizing that SwaRon have to move ahead.. I guess the second one makes me happy although it's utopian so I'll go with the second option!

I came online and the first thing I see happy faces everywhere saying awww Swayam was so caring Swayam was sooo concerned etc, but I'm someone who believes in substance, REAL substance... And being a science student, I have that tendency to go in depth of a situation, not only me, everyone wants to. Because in terms of characterization and realistic scenes illogical stuff won't work!

What I expected in the least from today's scene was reason. A reason to every action. Why this happened, why that happened etc.

1) Is THAT what you call intimacy? My definition of intimacy is something different and for god's sake Swayam and Ruhi scene was much more "intimate" than this pathetic llhh which didn't even make sense. Okay yeah, it was cute, it was kind of intense, but it didn't make sense. Neither was it intimate. Swayam said tum bohot achi lag rahi ho, and he has probably given her a compliment after ages and did not even say khoobsurat??? Which he ALWAYS uses?? Huh? My definition of romance , of intimacy is wayyy larger than this crapfest . Yes, that was crap, it lacked SwaRonish essence I don't know why. It would have been normal for any couple -_- So yeah, even SwaRon eye locks are different.. This scene didn't have the SwaRonish feel and for me it's a fault on the writers and the director's part. Sorry, but it didn't make even the slightest sense according to me.

2) Sharon's asthma. Fine, she had an attack. It's cool! But later on Swayam mentioned that she has attacks during the time of stress... How is it possible? She was stressed even when Swayam was unwell, she was stressed even when Ruhi had challenged her, she was stressed even when Ruhi threatened to leak her hacking secret out... And her emotions didn't look like stress at all.. Instead she seemed confident... Still she had an attack??? She was confident like 10 seconds before and 10 seconds later she starts suffocating, which I have to admit Vrushika Mehta did BRILLIANTLY. But again, her attack didn't make sense at such a point of time. Had it been in the midst of some intense argument, I'd loved it... And yeah, I'm really really happy that the CVs are making use of Sharon's asthma which was not used in the past few months... So I guess that's the only good thing.

3) Swayam!!! Yesss like others even I loved when he said no to Ruhi for staying with Sharon... It was amazing, it was swayamish... ^_^ And like all others this got a smile to my face... My main concern is WHY wasn't there a monologue? I know the scene isn't over yet but I think there'd be NO monologue tomorrow either because letting SwaRon fans down is the CVs best time pass!!

4) Swayam again. Caring Swayam always carried Sharon's asthma pump with him. Where was it today? Now I don't need lame excuses like maybe he didn't carry because she didn't have asthma because both of us know that these kinds of attacks can't be predicted or prevented! And even Swayam does... He carried it ALWAYS... Why didn't he carry it today??? Wasn't that out of his caring image???

All in all, I'm disappointed today. Now my only hope is tomorrow's SwaRon scene. Let's hope it doesn't lead to a disappointment.

P.S I'm not cribbing. Taking out flaws will help in making future SwaRon scenes better. I hope you understand and work on it. I'll appreciate you if you impress me and draw flak from your work when needed.


Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

1.3k

Users

13

Likes

33

Frequent Posters

--Anaya-- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
agree with all the points. god cvs are doing so much carelessness in writing SwaRon. High time they start writing SwaRon authentically. God that crap of ruhi Swayam was done in a close way but this pathetic llhh is termed as intimacy??? ridiculous.

And yes Swayam should be carrying an inhaler as he knows she does gets attacks while under stress. And situations like attacks cant be predicted. We have known Swayam carrying an inhaler with him. Why was it not shown that way? we always expect Swayam to be there as his protector and cautious than general in asthma case. No monologues is also annoying now.

The only good point cvs thought of bringing aasthma track but shuruwaath mein hi ithne loopholes.
UndefinedBeauty thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
I absolutely agree with all of you points. It's all good if you see it superficially but looking at it closely will give many flaws.
First of all the "intimate" scene was nowhere close to being one. Swayam-Ruhi were shown more close than this one-arm distance and LLHH.
Also,Sharon's attack made no sense...If it was an intense shouting match between Sharon and Ruhi then the attack would have made sense. But this seemed so out of the blue.

And Swayam's monologue is something that the CVs go out of the way to avoid. As for the pump not being with Swayam, it was very disappointing to see that.
cutelove thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
nowadays swaron scene though there bt really lacks dat basic essence n dis result comesout wen writers dnt put it on perfectly..had dwy been focussed over swayams character n swaron such basic elements need to be reminded every now n den..fr monologue it has become ritual dat cvs will try to avoid it no matter wt ..
bt its need of d hour...swayams very elemental qualities r put on stake..his nt carrying inhaler s something major .i really want cvs to.look into.dis matter.
kapoormenka thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Bangon post Mihi. I completely agree with you. Basically both the scenes were written half heartedly it was just Vrushan's acting that made Scenes good else everything was lacking. They gave asthma scene for the sake of it to show Sharon's asthma in front of Ruhi that's it. The main feel was absent in the scene.
Analysis thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
No asthma attack , when swayam was lying on the hospital's bed
Not even during she was blaming herself at hospital and at her home 👏

Bt nw , Ruhi needs to know she has asthma prob, CVs penned down without sense 😡

Swayam always hide her asthma prob even from rey, even when she gets hyper, he tried to ctrl her many times and didn't let rey to know abt it ,bt now he told her secret to Ruhi 👏

HE knows sharon has problems with ruhi, she warned him abt ruhi n still he did that 👏

WOW CVs 🤪

N abt not carrying the pump, may be cvs trying to show, swayam ne khud sharon ko khud se kitna dur kar dia, uski care karna chod dia ,
swayam to bhut hurt hone wala hai 😭
JensenVruShan thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
Vrushan are both brilliant actors but sadly they can't do a damn thing about dialogues or script.
There is absolutely no sense in what they are showing for SS or for D3 as a whole.
They only showed Asthma coz Ruhi has to find out and use it against Sharon otherwise it doesn't exist.

I agree the way it was shown was just rubbish so many more major things have happened with Sharon but those didn't trigger her condition but some stupid dialogue from psycho Ruhi gets her all hyper
and the biggest blunder was how casually Swayam is sharing Sharon biggest weakness with this nobody character, Swayam is gonna suffer badly for this.
About Swayam not having a pump on him like before , I dont know how to react to that

Thumbs down to CV, she truly is brainless 👎🏼
Legilimens. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Jensenrocks

Vrushan are both brilliant actors but sadly they can't do a damn thing about dialogues or script.

There is absolutely no sense in what they are showing for SS or for D3 as a whole.
They only showed Asthma coz Ruhi has to find out and use it against Sharon otherwise it doesn't exist.

I agree the way it was shown was just rubbish so many more major things have happened with Sharon but those didn't trigger her condition but some stupid dialogue from psycho Ruhi gets her all hyper
and the biggest blunder was how casually Swayam is sharing Sharon biggest weakness with this nobody character, Swayam is gonna suffer badly for this.
About Swayam not having a pump on him like before , I dont know how to react to that

Thumbs down to CV, she truly is brainless 👎🏼


I agree! I wish VruShan could do something about the horrendous script!!! And Sharon's asthma was supposed to remain secretive.. 😕 WHY does Ruhi have to know about it?😕 Totally baseless.
tannuluv thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
so basically,
if cvs want a REASON for next track they can show any kind of lame things that comes in their mind...asthma attack is biggest example..
they write scenes without understanding the importance of that track in a love story...swayam not carrying asthma pump another example...
Careless towards individual characteristic of one particular character...swayam p.o.v missing...
N after writing such an important track they give 2 min screen space...

So basically new cvs of d3 are careless, brainless, creative-less, n full of biased behavior...
beintehha... thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
Yesterdays epi was a👎🏼 with a very lame script...sharon ko achanak se kese attack aaya? pehle bhi ruhi ne bahut kuch kaha hai sharon ko tab kuch nai hua..moreover swayam not having inhaler nd swayam says to ruhi abt her asthama...agar ruhi ko sharon ke asthma ke bareme batana tha then their r many ways to show..which would have been looked little realistic
Moreover swayam telling ruhi not to tell gang about her asthma becoz gang vl get tensed...he dint thought abt sharon dat she dont wanna share abt asthma

Related Topics

Channel V Dil Dosti Dance thumbnail

Posted by: Mystic_Muse · 4 months ago

Hello, I don't know what came into i pen it down. Hope you like it. COVER BY @EXOTICDISASTER It was supposed to be just another evening at...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".