Chandra Nandini 31-33:Extended finale;Nos.46-47pg 120;No.48 pg 128 - Page 14

Created

Last reply

Replies

1k

Views

72k

Users

50

Likes

4.5k

Frequent Posters

old_charm thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: sashashyam


Well, my dear Manasi, as you might have seen from my response above to Sandhya's comments on my post, I was shocked and deeply disturbed by the behaviour of the rebooted Mura and Chandra.

>>well i have aunty...😊

planned move by mura & chanakya...sounds good but i doubt (actually sure its nothing like that...😛) because its there version of Rajmata - divine one , who still considers avantika her friend...🤢


I only hope the first is a planned move by Mura and Chanakya, and that the latter is a one off reaction by Chandra to the sight of a woman in tears, and the memories of his abused foster mother that this stirs up.

>> i didn't liked that , all i can say is its their obsession & their way of showing connection between leads .

Shyamala Aunty



sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
My dear Saana,

I was fascinated by such a refreshingly original set of comments from you. I am marking the parts I specially enjoyed in blue, and my supplementary remarks as well.

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: apolloartemis

Hi Aunty! Thought I should answer you here instead of at the old thread. I'm flattered you remember me- I've been away from here more than a year I think. And my real name is Saana!

Coming to the episodes, I think there are a lot of gems, mostly thanks to RT's acting, a lot of people are talking about the brutality of the executions and Chandra's actions and all I have to say is this: this is a man who grew up in an era very very different from ours, in circumstances we cannot hope to really understand. In a short period of time he has undergone multiple revelations that would shake anyone, and has used those revelations to put a personal edge to his anger.


I do not think it is a lot of people, my dear, for I saw just 2 threads on these lines. But yes, there is a persistent tendency, in this and in other contexts, to transpose contemporary mindsets into a 4th century BC tale.

I think in terms of anger, Chandra has two modes- a slow burn, who lends itself to a sadistic amusement- as evident by the glee RT exhibited as he was executing Nand and his sons, a slow grim grin that overtakes his features showing his pleasure in not only taking revenge, but grinding his enemies who have hurt him, his guru, and his family to the dust. And a fast burn mode, which he seems to be experiencing with Nandini- in which his anger is like s flash fire. Once the revenge is done no hatred is left in its wake. This is evident by his actions in todays episode in which he offers her water and cried for her, despite his insistence that this was not so to Dudhara.

Now this is what I meant by a refreshingly original point of view. I agree with you, and I love this take of yours.

I'm discomfited by the second, and hope he wont give in too quickly to Nandini. I'm not a fan of the character or the actress, especially her tenor and voice moderation, which do not lend themselves to royal dignity and a trial upon my ears at time. Her demeanor is understandable to a point, but when I compare it to Mura's or even the other royal ladies turned dasi's, her hysterical shrieking that Chandra should kill her falls short of the mark of her, admittedly sporadic character sketch. I am tempted to say the reason he woke is not that her peed reached him mentally, but her wailing reached him audibly!

Oh yes, he hears it, for she is wailing loudly enough to raise the whole palace! And your 'discomfited" pleased me a lot, for it is not a frequently used word, being the kind of thing I use myself. It is a perfect fit for what you wanted to convey.

Now on to my favorite- Helena! I loved her throughout the episodes. Her grim grin as Chandra called her name and tossed Malay to her, the softening and myriad of expressions and Malay spoke to her, the glance at Chandra and his skeptic expression before asking, as his wife, to fulfill her wish, and the subtle glee in her voice as she told Chandra to kill Malay. I loved them all. I also liked the interplay between her and Chandra in that moment.it was as if there was a vibration in the air. and their expressions read that that vibration reached only them, no one else.

I did not go into this scene as the post was long enough as it was and I was too tired by then. But even if I had taken it up, I could not have done it as well as you have. The last part, that I have put in bold now, is amazingly observant and perceptive.👏

You said is best- Helena is as she is. She grew up in Alexander's army, and the slogan- want take have and burn the rest, is very much evident in her. Also evident is the fissure that will cause her to try to destroy all who stand between her and Chandra.

As she tells Nandini in today's episode- what is hers is hers alone, and she will not ask, only take or snatch. She does not love Chandra as she loved Malay, and I doubt she ever will. But as Chandra has connected to her, she has connected to Chandra. Marry him for revenge she did, but this is also the Helena who asserted to Dudhara that her right to Chandra was paramount. I wonder that she does know of the fact that he spends the nights with her Sautan! The subtle interplay as Chandra introduced her, than Dudhara, the fact that she also knelt and touched Mura's feet... here is a woman who intends to rule the roost and knows the lay of the land as well!

I do not think she knows that Chandra shares his bedroom with Durdhara now as a matter of course. I do not know how she would react when she finds out, but the funny thing is that she has nothing to bother about on that score. I am sure Chandra and Durdhara have a nice, comfortable, platonic relationship going, that is all. It is the only psychologically feasible option for both of them.

I'm looking forward to her reaction to Chandra marrying Nandini, as well as her changing equation with Chankya as she realizes that he is the reason Nandini will become her Sautan instead of her dais, as well as the fact that Chandra is spending the nights with Dudhara.

She is a fascinating female in the Greek tradition, fierce, untamed and terrible, like Medea, whom I had mentioned earlier in my Helen 2.0 post, and Clytemnestra, whom I have not. But they are already beginning to wreck her as a character, witness her overt insolence towards Mura. If Chandra had heard that exchange, Helena would have copped it good and proper. I really wish Mura had read her the riot act for that. It might have done Helena some good.

P.S: I thought it was interesting that his mind went to Helena first for his heir. Perhaps I read too much into it, but what to do? We all have out crosses to bear!

I think that was because he has mentally crossed out Durdhara in this context, and that then leaves only Helena

Autumn_Rose thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Actually, Sri, I rather like that pseudo-Macedonian lady. She talks sense to Helena, and seems to be remarkably perceptive. That nafrat vs mohabbat line of hers reminded me of what Maham used to tell Adham. And she is spot on in what she tells Helena about this marriage idea.

I think it will be fun if Chanakya is kept on his toes by this lady. He is getting mentally lazy. I would not be surprised if, as I had mentioned on Devki's thread, some of the supposedly dead 7 sons had also got up and walked off!😆 He will then come tomorrow to Chandra and say Humse ek aur bhool ho gayee!😡

Shyamala Akka


She looked so weird. . . At first I thought it's Resham 🤣

And mura screaming prem prem sounded Hamida Banoish to me.
sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
No, no, Alakh, she does not have anything like Resham's ultra prominent eyes. She looks like she needed a good orthodontist, however! I suppose they would not have been available in the 4 th century BC.

It is not only that prem, hriday etc that sounded like Hamida Bano. It was Mura's whole attitude towards Nandini and the Nandites. It was unbelievable. I was completely deceived by that icy, sidelong look she cast at Avantika as she walked past her. Ugh..

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: Autumn_Rose


She looked so weird. . . At first I thought it's Resham 🤣

And mura screaming prem prem sounded Hamida Banoish to me.

sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
A very valid point, my dear Amina, that no one else, including myself, had flagged.👏

I hope not too! Ek Dhan to haath se choot gaya, kam se kam is dhan ko to kaskar pakad lena chahiya tha. I am sure they would have carted it all off, for that was what Chanakya was targetting. I think it was in the excitement of collaring all this dhan that he forgot to make sure that Nand was really dead!😆

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: amina1

Aunty woh dhan ka kiya huwa he left nand half dead but hope he took the dhan or woh bhi demag se nikal gaya hope not

amina1 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: sashashyam

A very valid point, my dear Amina, that no one else, including myself, had flagged.👏

I hope not too! Ek Dhan to haath se choot gaya, kam se kam is dhan ko to kaskar pakad lena chahiya tha. I am sure they would have carted it all off, for that was what Chanakya was targetting. I think it was in the excitement of collaring all this dhan that he forgot to make sure that Nand was really dead!😆

Shyamala Aunty

😉 Aunty yeh dekh kar to nand ko mar hi jana tha but alas hes alive now im watching this only for entertainment value and nothing else 😆 or maybe seeing nand just thought jan hai to jahan hai
Edited by amina1 - 8 years ago
apolloartemis thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
Aunty many thanks for your lovely reply to my post! My blushes at your compliments!

I'm going to wait for the next thread to really talk about the last two episodes but I will say my heart has sunk in tandem with yours and I foresee myself quitting this show before long if they continue on this track!

I suppose my biggest problem is that I can see nothing special about Nandini and this soul deep connection between her and Chandra unfortunately appears more and more a farce! Out of this cast only Rajat and Tanu are really knocking it out of the park and that is only when the script gives them room to breath and add nuance! Otherwise its an unintentional kabuki drama, all high melodrama and wailing to the heavens!

Mura really let me down, and I do not foresee any future upside! Is it too much to hope for some of those unguarded moments between Chandra and Helena and Chandra and Dudhara that we got only a glimpse of? Or are we to see only a weeping, angry, or lecturing Nandini, with her stock of three expressions? Alas for Raja and Tanu and alac for us viewers!

In less dire news, I would like to thank you again for taking the time to review my comment. I know your hands give you trouble and I salute your tenacity and spirit in overcoming the pain and taking the time to write those replies.
shailusri1983 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
Aunty this was another major point I seem to have missed in my previous posts. I understood Helena's revenge till this point. Similarly if she had wanted to get Chandra married to Nandini as a political move and argued in its favor for the sake of practicality and security, I would have understood and appreciated her. But what exactly was she trying to achieve by making her a queen of Chandra and making Nandini her life long handmaiden. Hadn't she already ground her rival to the dust? Where was the need to elevate Nandini equal in status to herself by making her a queen of Chandra and call this stupid measure as a revenge?

Nobody would have problems with her ill treating or disrespecting a Dasi or prisoner of war. But many would find it difficult to accept her treatment of another queen in the same manner. It would be a gross disrespect of the royal etiquette and code of conduct. It would be an affront to the king himself if one of his queens was insulted. Whatever his personal relationship status with any of his queens, he wouldn't want these spats to come to public knowledge as it would set a bad precedent. Why bring her Sautan herself?

I was glad that the lady who plays Helena's mother drives some sense into her. She points out how there is a very thin dividing line between hatred and love. Helena doesn't even have love on her side to keep Chandra tied or attached to her. She might never know when this relationship of need, necessity, and revenge could sink into indifference on both sides, or even worse when hers would graduate to love and his might remain on the same level or degenerate even further.

I suppose this lady is so full of Malayketu that she fails to think of any of these eventualities. She is living in another La-La land of revenge that she fails to notice her real world issues. Does she even know Chandra consummated his marriage with Durdhara but not her for whatever reasons? Would she be alright with this that she was passed over and Durdhara was preferred to take forward the lineage?

Helena's mother seems to be a pretty dangerous and Machiavellian lady. She is definitely a character to watch out and will certainly keep Chanakya occupied in future diffusing her dangerous schemes. She seems to have a very intelligent way with words. Moreover she seems to be intelligent in a dangerous way.

She says at the very begining of her conversation with Helena that she had recognized her handiwork in the happenings. She mentions that she got to know this from Megasthenes. It would have been more logical if she had said that Selucus informed her about these things. This Megathanes chap never popped in and out of the show before this.

Chandra, Chanakya and Helena were fighting wars and battles all this while and always on the run and sitting around bonfires in forest war camps. It would be too odd for Chandra to be receiving and entertaining diplomatic missions and foreign emissaries in such dire circumstances.

Is there a necessity to din to us the point 'Look, we've done our research on CGM properly! One odd chap from Greece called Megasthanes visited India. Look we've mentioned him in our series. Look how historical we are!' The passing reference actually looked ludicrous in it that it was impossible in the existing circumstances. If they really wanted Megasthanes in the story they could bring him on later on in the story.
Edited by shailusri1983 - 8 years ago
jayaks02 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: apolloartemis

Aunty many thanks for your lovely reply to my post! My blushes at your compliments!

I'm going to wait for the next thread to really talk about the last two episodes but I will say my heart has sunk in tandem with yours and I foresee myself quitting this show before long if they continue on this track!

I suppose my biggest problem is that I can see nothing special about Nandini and this soul deep connection between her and Chandra unfortunately appears more and more a farce! Out of this cast only Rajat and Tanu are really knocking it out of the park and that is only when the script gives them room to breath and add nuance! Otherwise its an unintentional kabuki drama, all high melodrama and wailing to the heavens!

Mura really let me down, and I do not foresee any future upside! Is it too much to hope for some of those unguarded moments between Chandra and Helena and Chandra and Dudhara that we got only a glimpse of? Or are we to see only a weeping, angry, or lecturing Nandini, with her stock of three expressions? Alas for Raja and Tanu and alac for us viewers!

In less dire news, I would like to thank you again for taking the time to review my comment. I know your hands give you trouble and I salute your tenacity and spirit in overcoming the pain and taking the time to write those replies.



Exactly !!! You said it.

It is such a farce similar to JA Amar Prem that suddenly catches Akbar and makes him realize he has a DIL. So very unconvincing it was then and even more so now.

Would have been better if they had taken a liking to each other in the forest or some such meetings where both did not disclose the real identities. Would have different that way.

When Mura addressed Avantika, she was sitting all through !!!!! 🤣 Ridiculous and she says she wants to take the friendship forward after 20 years. 😆
jayaks02 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
Dhananand was let off to convert to Buddhism or go to forest with his 2 wives. He was not killed by CGM. There is a theory like this. In this context, I liked Prem's post.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".