Confused is Nandini fictional or did she exist!? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

35

Views

10.2k

Users

14

Likes

40

Frequent Posters

702755 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#21
She existed. But chandragupta had no affections for her and she married him after nanda' s defeat. And durdhara was his first cousin not Dana daughter. Chandragupta never gave her respect of chief queen even after death of durdhara.
.
Edited by Roxelana - 8 years ago
swriter thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: Roxelana

She existed. But chandragupta had no affections for her and she married him after nanda' s defeat. And durdhara was his first cousin not Dana daughter. Chandragupta never gave her respect of chief queen even after death of durdhara.

.



No buddy durdhara was daughter of nanda and first wife of Chandra Gupta Maurya .
U know some document of shri Lanka which described about ashoka talked about
Chandra Gupta Maurya ' s marriage with his cousin but it didn't mention her name.
Second this document is not also historical current.
Because it has many fault according to date time and facts.
😃
702755 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: swriter



No buddy durdhara was daughter of nanda and first wife of Chandra Gupta Maurya .
U know some document of shri Lanka which described about ashoka talked about
Chandra Gupta Maurya ' s marriage with his cousin but it didn't mention her name.
Second this document is not also historical current.
Because it has many fault according to date time and facts.
😃

. No she was not. Parishishta parva mention dhana's daughter falling for cgm while cgm not liking her much. Chanakya forced him to marry her. Mudrarakshasa also mentioned Nanda daughter as wanting revenge and cold blood between them . Old chanakya also showed this and it was based on mudrarakshasa but former work is more reliable. Durdhara was his chief consort while Nanda daughter could never get that position.
swriter thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: Roxelana

. No she was not. Parishishta parva mention dhana's daughter falling for cgm while cgm not liking her much. Chanakya forced him to marry her. Mudrarakshasa also mentioned Nanda daughter as wanting revenge and cold blood between them . Old chanakya also showed this and it was based on mudrarakshasa but former work is more reliable. Durdhara was his chief consort while Nanda daughter could never get that position.



I m only saying what I have read.
First no body clear about Chandra Gupta Maurya's personal life.
Till DAT I only got find that mother of bindusaar was daughter of nanda.
And her name was durdhara.
So I said it you . 😊
dellzcreationz thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#25
Durdhara was CGM cousin then how can she be Nandini .I feel Nandini may be a another wife of CGM which was not given importance and in the history it's only given importance to Durdhara and Helena .So may be Ekta may be focusing on the untold story of who was Nandini how will she will become CGM wife and his love story with her inspite of she being his second wife or so .
myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#26
Dhuradhara was Chandras mom muras elder brother daughter.

She was not dhananandas daughter

Chandra married dhananand daughter as chankya wanted him to get support and legitimacy to rule magadh (as he is not a royal)

Her name no one knows is what?

Her name not recorded in any book of those times

Only Dhuradhara and Helena name recorded in history as CGm wife's

Dhuradhara and Helena had kids from CGM but nothing given about this dhananand daughter or kids from her

You can say that she was not that impt in CGM life else they would have mentioned something in books written in that time about CGM(jain and bhuddist books or greek traveller books).
Edited by myviewprem - 8 years ago
702755 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: myviewprem

Dhuradhara was Chandras mom muras elder brother daughter.

She was not dhananandas daughter

Chandra married dhananand daughter as chankya wanted him to get support and legitimacy to rule magadh (as he is not a royal)

Her name no one knows is what?

Her name not recorded in any book of those times

Only Dhuradhara and Helena name recorded in history as CGm wife's

Dhuradhara and Helena had kids from CGM but nothing given about this dhananand daughter or kids from her

You can say that she was not that impt in CGM life else they would have mentioned something in books written in that time about CGM(jain and bhuddist books or greek traveller books).

. In mudrarakshasa it is written that cgm despised her which goes parallel with Jain chronicles that cgm was indifferent towards her. The reason I did not read so I don't know. I think ekta chose this cold blood fact and changed it into a fictional love story. I really hate how Indian tv portray helen. Her dressing , accent everything is wrong. She looks typically greek which she was not. She was brought up in Syria so obviously she cannot be a total greek.
Marathi_Mulgi thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: myviewprem

Dhuradhara was Chandras mom muras elder brother daughter.

She was not dhananandas daughter

Chandra married dhananand daughter as chankya wanted him to get support and legitimacy to rule magadh (as he is not a royal)

Her name no one knows is what?

Her name not recorded in any book of those times

Only Dhuradhara and Helena name recorded in history as CGm wife's

Dhuradhara and Helena had kids from CGM but nothing given about this dhananand daughter or kids from her

You can say that she was not that impt in CGM life else they would have mentioned something in books written in that time about CGM(jain and bhuddist books or greek traveller books).

in old chanakya serial by chandraprakash dwivedi dhanand daughter shown as kalyani and chanakya wanted cgm to marry with her coz of magadha and as she is rk instead of dhurandara😕
swriter thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: myviewprem

Dhuradhara was Chandras mom muras elder brother daughter.

She was not dhananandas daughter

Chandra married dhananand daughter as chankya wanted him to get support and legitimacy to rule magadh (as he is not a royal)

Her name no one knows is what?

Her name not recorded in any book of those times

Only Dhuradhara and Helena name recorded in history as CGm wife's

Dhuradhara and Helena had kids from CGM but nothing given about this dhananand daughter or kids from her

You can say that she was not that impt in CGM life else they would have mentioned something in books written in that time about CGM(jain and bhuddist books or greek traveller books).



Heyyy dear u have changed your statement
It is different one from your other answer.
😉
maaneet_forever thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#30
I haven't watched single epi (because ekta always destroy history and I thought nandani is totally fictional) but I am big fan of Rajat so I am here.
First of all it is a very informative discussion thread.
So as per above post nandani is not fictional and durdhara was not dhananad daughter which I was not aware of.So having a second though that I should start watching it or not.

Happy Diwali

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".