Feb5 - When the Past becomes present &future - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

20

Views

2.5k

Users

7

Likes

39

Frequent Posters

Moumimon thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#11
well amazing analysis again rati jaan...🤗

i am in too hurry today..so may don't able to post in detail what i like or not...but wanna say yesterdays episode was much dramatic...yet as cast is doing fab job i am enjoying costume drama but yeh feeling so bad for such distortion big time...

well earlier too same CV's ruined so many Historical shows makes HistoricalTamasha...still i was expected that they will follow (50-60)% of history for this show...acctully fool me or we!! but big time they lost all plots...so here we have no job rather then watch out costume drama as no one gonna take headache about our history jaap..people think we are morons who talks about history...and seems who cares...😆

yeh in case of fictional story it's going good...fabulous performance by whole cast...BG's are fab...Chanakya, Ashoka, Dharma everyone's i loved BG's yrr...
❤️

well if i get time till evening will surely post about my view on epi in detail...
🤪

assa i forget to add i watched out old chanakya's 1-6 epi...and guess what seriously i loved that shows script..it's to point...and that young chankya done an awesome job..really really many many thanks for sharing the link of old chankaya...i am loving it to watch out...well here too will give you my feedback in detail later...
🤪

till then TC yrr🤗


navyasingh thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#12
a wonderful analysis of the episode rati...
what are these people showing?😕
king bindusara had many wifes and he did'nt care about dharma...

but i loved the dialouges and screenplay..😊
pallavi as ashoka's mother is doing a great job👏

_richa
Kaana thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#13
Rati, I would agree to the dramatization bit. But I love the kid! Man, he kills me!!!

A quick thought in Dharma character-
Given that she is projected as dharmic and a Brahmin lady of those days, meaning who knows dharma well for both the reasons, her behavior to Chanakya, a revered Brahmana then, is not in line in my opinion. She could have put her case firmly, but ideally more politely and respectfully. Also her reaction to Bindusar's deathbed state when revealed by Chanakya, leaves one with an impression that she has lost her love for him. Though there was an immediate reaction, the overpowering emotion and reaction to leave the place than shed few drops for her dying husband has left me wondering.
vibrantvibes thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#14
nice post dear😊
I missed episode why they have started this kinda fictional track in first week only😡 I don't know about his childhood but bindu doesn't know about his son Ashok is completely looking unreal,as if it's not dharma-ashok but shakuntala-bharat story we are watching😲
this PH😡😡😡 research karate hain ya nahi kuch🤢
Intrepida thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: navyasingh

a wonderful analysis of the episode rati...

what are these people showing?😕
king bindusara had many wifes and he did'nt care about dharma...

but i loved the dialouges and screenplay..😊
pallavi as ashoka's mother is doing a great job👏

_richa


thanks Richa!

yea i have no idea what they want to show!
but yes dialogue and actors are great!
Intrepida thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: dsm123

nice post dear😊

I missed episode why they have started this kinda fictional track in first week only😡 I don't know about his childhood but bindu doesn't know about his son Ashok is completely looking unreal,as if it's not dharma-ashok but shakuntala-bharat story we are watching😲
this PH😡😡😡 research karate hain ya nahi kuch🤢


thanks Dhanashree! 😃
yea its fictional and too dramatic, already having second thoughts bout this!
yes its shakuntala lol!
Intrepida thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: Moumimon

well amazing analysis again rati jaan...🤗

i am in too hurry today..so may don't able to post in detail what i like or not...but wanna say yesterdays episode was much dramatic...yet as cast is doing fab job i am enjoying costume drama but yeh feeling so bad for such distortion big time...

well earlier too same CV's ruined so many Historical shows makes HistoricalTamasha...still i was expected that they will follow (50-60)% of history for this show...acctully fool me or we!! but big time they lost all plots...so here we have no job rather then watch out costume drama as no one gonna take headache about our history jaap..people think we are morons who talks about history...and seems who cares...😆

yeh in case of fictional story it's going good...fabulous performance by whole cast...BG's are fab...Chanakya, Ashoka, Dharma everyone's i loved BG's yrr...
❤️

well if i get time till evening will surely post about my view on epi in detail...
🤪

assa i forget to add i watched out old chanakya's 1-6 epi...and guess what seriously i loved that shows script..it's to point...and that young chankya done an awesome job..really really many many thanks for sharing the link of old chankaya...i am loving it to watch out...well here too will give you my feedback in detail later...
🤪

till then TC yrr🤗



Thanks moumi jaan!! 🤗

sooo dramatic, i was like wait what am i watching! yes i hate the distortions!
i love the music, the actors but yeh history nahi hai!!!

omg, you did!!! yes its to the point!! young chanakya was soo good, he is so persuasive!!! the mitti scene, the part where the minister's sons break free from the cage and when Chanakya tells his mother that his father is not dead- those are some powerful scenes!! even the minister shaktar does an awesome job! keep me updated on your thoughts as you continue watching!

you also TC!! 🤗
Intrepida thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: Kaana

Rati, I would agree to the dramatization bit. But I love the kid! Man, he kills me!!!

A quick thought in Dharma character-
Given that she is projected as dharmic and a Brahmin lady of those days, meaning who knows dharma well for both the reasons, her behavior to Chanakya, a revered Brahmana then, is not in line in my opinion. She could have put her case firmly, but ideally more politely and respectfully. Also her reaction to Bindusar's deathbed state when revealed by Chanakya, leaves one with an impression that she has lost her love for him. Though there was an immediate reaction, the overpowering emotion and reaction to leave the place than shed few drops for her dying husband has left me wondering.


the kid is great, but the distortions are not sitting well with me!
I think Dharma is reallly hurt by her past and facing it is not easy for her, she doesnt want her son to live thru the same betrayal she did! And her love for her son is greater than that of her husband afterall in her mind, he betrayed her, and her son is her reason to live in this world otherwise the trauma that she suffered, she would have died in that burning hut if it werent for the fact that she had a reason to live- her son!
Moumimon thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Intrepida


Thanks moumi jaan!! 🤗

sooo dramatic, i was like wait what am i watching! yes i hate the distortions!
i love the music, the actors but yeh history nahi hai!!!

omg, you did!!! yes its to the point!! young chanakya was soo good, he is so persuasive!!! the mitti scene, the part where the minister's sons break free from the cage and when Chanakya tells his mother that his father is not dead- those are some powerful scenes!! even the minister shaktar does an awesome job! keep me updated on your thoughts as you continue watching!

you also TC!! 🤗



about mitti scene of young chankya was full on attitude that was so amazing one..

bold@ actually i was get stunned by that scene such a powerful and touchy scene it was flawless...dia of Channakya there is more then awesome and after watching that scene i was like what a scriupt it is...how he put forced "TeraPati TeraPati" i was just stunned...that was a marvelous scene...

and mahamantri shatkar@ he done his job amazingly he also get an fabulous script...the very first scene of him in that court was out standing... how he was told that we need robber to rapine people...it was such authentic performance...

well really old Chankya is well scripted and its just cut to point...a scene where young Chanakya get the knowledge of gold from one in the path of Takshila is really touchy... uncounted scene i liked from the show till now...more to go i guess...

well how Chanakya asks for chand from his mother is fantabulous one...it was something in real...the feeling was so powerful so natural so impactful...

Intrepida thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: Moumimon



about mitti scene of young chankya was full on attitude that was so amazing one..

bold@ actually i was get stunned by that scene such a powerful and touchy scene it was flawless...dia of Channakya there is more then awesome and after watching that scene i was like what a scriupt it is...how he put forced "TeraPati TeraPati" i was just stunned...that was a marvelous scene...

and mahamantri shatkar@ he done his job amazingly he also get an fabulous script...the very first scene of him in that court was out standing... how he was told that we need robber to rapine people...it was such authentic performance...

well really old Chankya is well scripted and its just cut to point...a scene where young Chanakya get the knowledge of gold from one in the path of Takshila is really touchy... uncounted scene i liked from the show till now...more to go i guess...

well how Chanakya asks for chand from his mother is fantabulous one...it was something in real...the feeling was so powerful so natural so impactful...


that mitti scene is one of my favourites!
yes that tera pati scene left me stunned but it was a proud moment!
mahamantri delivers a powerful performance!
yea definitely the old chanakya is to the point, and thats what great about it! and do share your views as you continue to watch it!! Its so nice to be able to discuss Chanakya with someone!!
🤗

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".