Taare Zamen Par star-REFUSES Screen Award - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

92

Views

7.3k

Users

49

Likes

3

Frequent Posters

lovanika thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#51

Originally posted by: bollywoodcrazed

He's just a child, he was nominated in the correct category.

This is the debate yaar....he is a child but does acting has a age as barrier.

If he is the main actor of a movie WHY can't he get nominated as a best actor....

Acting is acting and his acting was not of a child actor but better than many actors nominated in the Best actor category...

joie de vivre thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#52

Originally posted by: TallyHo

you actually predicted that?😆

But I agree ...this is taking things a bit too far...

artists should have the humility to accept the accolades that come their way with grace...this attitude to prove a point will just push you away from the people who admire you!

Thats why I like SRK in this respect...he always acknowledges love/ adulation/ acknowledgement in any form...

the other day on TV I saw him walking down for some function and some girls were standing on the side showering flower petals on him...he actually stopped and acknowledged them and said thank u before moving on...👏

Thats the reason why Aamir will never have a following like SRK...because the latter rules the hearts of people!😃

Aamir is too wrapped up in his own self...so probabaly he doesnt even deserve that kind of love and affection!😡

I beg to differ slightly...The reason Aamir Khan doesn't quite enjoy the success of SRK is because of his choice of films....Whilst SRK does a Swades or a Chak De for every five 'masala' movies(the ratio being 1:5), Aamir's ratio is quite the opposite...Lets consider the films they have done in this millenium..Lagaan, Dil Chahta Hai, Mangal Pandey, RDB, Fanaa and Taare Zameen Par....Juxtaposing SRK's filmography.... Mohabbatein, Asoka, K3G, Devdas, Chalte Chalte, Kal Ho na Ho, Main Hoon Na, Veer Zaara, Swades, Paheli,KANK, Don, Chak De, OSO.....SRK does more number of films and commercial films at that, whereas Aamir's only hard-core potboiler was Fanaa(which was a bigger hit than KANK and Don in 2006)...Thank God we have an actor like Aamir Khan who's got his priorities right and has the foresight to support films like Rang De Basanti(which was refused by loads of actors like SRK and Hrithik) and Taare Zameen Par, or else all that we'd be left with would be mindless Akshay Kumar comedies and done to death SRK hamming...

Back to topic, Didn't loads of you people agree that Darsheel deserves the "NATIONAL AWARD" just a few days back??😉...So why this volte-face now, lags?...When Akshay Kumar refused to collect the award for the best actor in a comic role(because he believed that he is the hero of the given comedy in question and should therefore have been nominated in the best actor category), such a brouhaha wasn't whipped up.... I didn't see that decision having affected his popularity either ...Akshay is the biggest star as of today with every film of his doing mightily well, so I don't see how refusing awards diminishes the popularity of an actor😕..And as a matter of fact, Screen Awards is NOT audience choice, it's adjudicated by the special jury...

Darsheel Safary is quite a precocious kid ...One should have read the recent interview he did for Mid Day, they way he judged actresses like Rani, Kareena and Ash...It's very much possible the kid refused the award of his own accord, especially when he is touted to deserve the National award...Refusing awards is not Aamir's forte anyway, he sure doesn't attend award functions thereby disparaging and debunking them, but has never publicly "refused" them, has he?...

Edited by joie de vivre - 17 years ago
lovanika thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#53

Originally posted by: joie de vivre

I beg to differ slightly...The reason Aamir Khan doesn't quite enjoy the success of SRK is because of his choice of films....Whilst SRK does a Swades or a Chak De for every five 'masala' movies(the ratio being 1:5), Aamir's ratio is quite the opposite...Lets consider the films they have done in this millenium..Lagaan, Dil Chahta Hai, Mangal Pandey, RDB, Fanaa and Taare Zameen Par....Juxtaposing SRK's filmography.... Mohabbatein, Asoka, K3G, Devdas, Chalte Chalte, Kal Ho na Ho, Main Hoon Na, Veer Zaara, Swades, Paheli,KANK, Don, Chak De, OSO.....SRK does more number of films and commercial films at that, whereas Aamir's only hard-core potboiler was Fanaa(which was a bigger hit than KANK and Don in 2006)...Thank God we have an actor like Aamir Khan who's got his priorities right and has the foresight to support films like Rang De Basanti(which was refused by loads of actors like SRK and Hrithik) and Taare Zameen Par, or else all that we'd be left with would be mindless Akshay Kumar comedies and done to death SRK hamming...

Back to topic, Didn't loads of you people agree that Darsheel deserves the "NATIONAL AWARD" just a few days back??😉...So why this volte-face now, lags?...When Akshay Kumar refused to collect the award for the best actor in a comic role(because he believed that he is the hero of the given comedy in question and should therefore have been nominated in the best actor category), such a brouhaha wasn't whipped up.... I didn't see that decision having affected his popularity either ...Akshay is the biggest star as of today with every film of his doing mightily well, so I don't see how refusing awards diminishes the popularity of an actor😕..And as a matter of fact, Screen Awards is NOT audience choice, it's adjudicated by the special jury...

Darsheel Safary is quite a precocious kid ...One should have read the recent interview he did for Mid Day, they way he judged actresses like Rani, Kareena and Ash...It's very much possible the kid refused the award of his own accord, especially when he is touted to deserve the National award...Refusing awards is not Aamir's forte anyway, he sure doesn't attend award functions thereby disparaging and debunking them, but has never publicly "refused" them, has he?...

The only thing I can say after erading your reply is THANKS for saying that.

I am sic of hearing people saying the movies done by SR are just great while all others are wasting theri time in Bollywood.

What they forget to understand is SRK is surviving on these kind of people only. He does films that makes him famous and ..RICH. But

Amir Proved how great actor he is and creativity is waht he is looking for. Thats the reson why for his first production and first Firection he choose a subject like TZP....Hats off to him.

This Huh Ha about Darsheel's comment is only because few people want SRK to win all teh awards for Chak De (which was an OK movie) and OSO (which was just not even a thing to comment on).....

Tani91 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 17 years ago
#54

Originally posted by: joie de vivre

I beg to differ slightly...The reason Aamir Khan doesn't quite enjoy the success of SRK is because of his choice of films....Whilst SRK does a Swades or a Chak De for every five 'masala' movies(the ratio being 1:5), Aamir's ratio is quite the opposite...Lets consider the films they have done in this millenium..Lagaan, Dil Chahta Hai, Mangal Pandey, RDB, Fanaa and Taare Zameen Par....Juxtaposing SRK's filmography.... Mohabbatein, Asoka, K3G, Devdas, Chalte Chalte, Kal Ho na Ho, Main Hoon Na, Veer Zaara, Swades, Paheli,KANK, Don, Chak De, OSO.....SRK does more number of films and commercial films at that, whereas Aamir's only hard-core potboiler was Fanaa(which was a bigger hit than KANK and Don in 2006)...Thank God we have an actor like Aamir Khan who's got his priorities right and has the foresight to support films like Rang De Basanti(which was refused by loads of actors like SRK and Hrithik) and Taare Zameen Par, or else all that we'd be left with would be mindless Akshay Kumar comedies and done to death SRK hamming...

Back to topic, Didn't loads of you people agree that Darsheel deserves the "NATIONAL AWARD" just a few days back??😉...So why this volte-face now, lags?...When Akshay Kumar refused to collect the award for the best actor in a comic role(because he believed that he is the hero of the given comedy in question and should therefore have been nominated in the best actor category), such a brouhaha wasn't whipped up.... I didn't see that decision having affected his popularity either ...Akshay is the biggest star as of today with every film of his doing mightily well, so I don't see how refusing awards diminishes the popularity of an actor😕..And as a matter of fact, Screen Awards is NOT audience choice, it's adjudicated by the special jury...

Darsheel Safary is quite a precocious kid ...One should have read the recent interview he did for Mid Day, they way he judged actresses like Rani, Kareena and Ash...It's very much possible the kid refused the award of his own accord, especially when he is touted to deserve the National award...Refusing awards is not Aamir's forte anyway, he sure doesn't attend award functions thereby disparaging and debunking them, but has never publicly "refused" them, has he?...

👏COMPLETELY agree with you there....I mean this kids DESERVES this award..and so what if he doesnt want it...maybe he's just happy that he got the recognition he deserved👏
tasha_tasha thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#55

Originally posted by: *Eva*

^^You're right. Darsheel is becoming like Aamir now. Yea, I agree he was excellent in his role but SRK truly deserved the award! Darsheel should at least be happy that he got an award!



maybe i missed sumthing bt wasnt the kid's arguement abt the category in which he was nominated rather than the award he got? in any case why shud he jst be happy with what he got if he thinks he deserved sumthing bigger? if he thought he deserved bigger he has he right to say it...its not like he's being arrogant..he's jt being true to himself n shudn be criticized for doing so
*Eva* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#56

Originally posted by: tasha_tasha



maybe i missed sumthing bt wasnt the kid's arguement abt the category in which he was nominated rather than the award he got? in any case why shud he jst be happy with what he got if he thinks he deserved sumthing bigger? if he thought he deserved bigger he has he right to say it...its not like he's being arrogant..he's jt being true to himself n shudn be criticized for doing so


Well, I really don't think he should've REFUSED the award. Everyone should be happy of what they have. Its okay to dream but refusing....
loveanime thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#57
Ok this is not about about what category he was nominated in. People are more taken aback by the boldness of his statement. I think we expect children to show some humility not spit out what is in their mind. I am not saying he is wrong, but I think his point would have been better understood if he had accepted the award and then more humbly made an sincere request.

But the reality is, whether SRK is the best or not I dont know, but many times he has beaten Aamir for this award when many felt Aamir was the better actor, but SRK wins of his popularity. Bias or not it is for people to judge, but when Aamir cant bring SRK down how can child no matter how good he is.

In the Academy Awards in the US there is no child category, even children get nominated in the same category. But that rarely happens and they rarely beat the pros.

We should not fight over what he said, but consider that he has a point behind his statement. It is just the way he said it that is all.
PinkPixie thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#58
i dont know if this guy refused the award for reall but if he did , i think he did right .. sort of like a protest .. ithink a lot of us dont agree with how the narrow concept of these awards .

we dont have any right to call him arrogant for refusing it . .. none of us will smilingly acceot something we dont beleive in .. why shud we force that upon this kid or amir khan or whoever else whos not excited or thinks highly abt the biased nature of these things
TallyHo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#59

* deleted*😛

Edited by TallyHo - 17 years ago
193980 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#60

Ash, Isi baat par do-chaar lines ho jaaye. 😊

Edited by Maya_M - 17 years ago

Related Topics

Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 3 months ago

https://x.com/BOWorldwide/status/1929804925120249959 https://x.com/BOWorldwide/status/1929859863384879378

https://x.com/BOWorldwide/status/1929804925120249959
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: priya185 · 2 months ago

Aneet Padda refuses selfie to a fan https://www.instagram.com/reel/DMdXzdBSdSA/?igsh=MTYzNTB2NXJjZmd4dw==

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: priya185 · 3 months ago

Sitaare zameen par reviews and box office Review below https://www.instagram.com/reel/DKtb65Hx9tE/?igsh=bmdvamVka3B2MW16 Member reviews Page 23...

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: priya185 · 1 months ago

Aamir Khan meets a fan watching Sitaare Zameen Par https://www.instagram.com/reel/DNfX_ozyEXF/?igsh=MWE3bXVpNXptc3dqZw==

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: Maroonporsche · 1 months ago

https://variety.com/2025/film/news/aamir-khan-sitaare-zameen-par-youtube-instead-streamers-1236472866/

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".