My Heart Is Beating... - Page 2

Originally posted by: Porcupine

No way, she looks 11 years old. Check her physical body and height in the song. She was a minor in the movie in hew teens. Can't say exact age.

Originally posted by: Rekha_ji

"check her physical body" ????Or we can check Google for her DOB The girl was 11 years old.

Many don't have accurate DOB.

Eventually make your own guesses.

Can u guys tell me one thing ? I , by mistake have blocked someone . But that was by mistake , so how can I unblock it now ???

Originally posted by: Porcupine

Many don't have accurate DOB.

Eventually make your own guesses.

But your idea of ignoring this and going with "let's check the boob size of an 11 year old and suggest that she's 17 based on that" is where I'll gladly draw the line and refrain from going any further in this conversation.

Love this song... I don't remember any recent film as such with families belonging to Catholic background in BW... it's been a long time.

Originally posted by: Porcupine

No way, she looks 11 years old. Check her physical body and height in the song. She was a minor in the movie in hew teens. Can't say exact age.

I know that stars have misrepresented their birthdates.

But girls can start menstruating and developing breasts as early as eight. I remember crying profusely when I was in the fourth standard and my mom said it was time to shop for a starter bra. None of my classmates would wear bras for a few more years.

Please don't check a young girl's physical body and height. Not only is it creepy, but it also damages the body image and self-esteem of girls who already feel different and disconnected from their peers.

Originally posted by: Rekha_ji

Even if it may be true that some stars hide their real age... it is quite clearly documented in Sridevi's case, since she was a child star from since she was a baby.

But your idea of ignoring this and going with "let's check the boob size of an 11 year old and suggest that she's 17 based on that" is where I'll gladly draw the line and refrain from going any further in this conversation.

You know better. I can't say her exact age. She is a minor in that. To me she still doesn't look 11 especially looking at her thighs and waist.

Originally posted by: return_to_hades

I know that stars have misrepresented their birthdates.

But girls can start menstruating and developing breasts as early as eight. I remember crying profusely when I was in the fourth standard and my mom said it was time to shop for a starter bra. None of my classmates would wear bras for a few more years.

Please don't check a young girl's physical body and height. Not only is it creepy, but it also damages the body image and self-esteem of girls who already feel different and disconnected from their peers.

Looking at her height, thighs and waist, she doesn't look like 11. Breasts can be padded. So I am not looking at that.

For those who need proof:

Sridevi in 1969 movie Kumara Sambhavam. She was 5 at the time and looks 5 as most people will agree. If anything, she looks younger.

Sridevi in 1971 movie Poombatta. She was 8 years old at the time and looks 8.

Sridevi in Mallamma Katha from 1973. She was 10, and I think we can all agree she doesn't look more than 10.

Sridevi in 1975 film Julie

The release dates of the above movies are a matter of public record. So clearly, puberty hit sometime between 1973 and 1975.

Originally posted by: Porcupine

Looking at her height, thighs and waist, she doesn't look like 11. Breasts can be padded. So I am not looking at that.

Girls hit puberty anywhere from 8 to mid teens. If an 8-year-old starts hormonal changes, she will have the figure expected from a grown woman before she even hits her teens. EDITED TO ADD: Mayo Clinic only calls it precocious puberty if it hits before age 8. So apparently, puberty at that young age is considered normal.

Also, even acc to the law, it doesn't matter how old children *look.* It's their actual age that matters when determining the creepiness of other people's behavior. Granted, this is an online forum, and we're discussing a public figure. But it really causes body image issues for young girls. Not sure what gender you are, but I'd request you to please not judge children by their body parts.