Aishwarya or Madhuri.Who is the better actress? - Page 2

Madhuri Dixit gets my vote.

Although, both these queens starred together in Devdas and Ash held her own. Madhuri got the better of her in the dancing, but Aishwarya due to her role being more central got most of the attention and accolades.

Overall, Madhuri is far more versatile. Ashu-ma is untouchable with good directors, but can be wasted at times. Madz used to seem invincible to me, but then I watched Gulaab Gang and Bucket List :(

Originally posted by: hotchoco

Ash herself was one of the bland girls when she first came in. She just had her looks but no acting talent or experience. She got a little better with time but was never really good as a whole. That's why she couldn't sustain a career at an older age the way Tabu, Rani, and even Kajol have.

Wow, if Aishwarya is bland then I wonder what the current girls are. Rani and Kajol also have producer husbands who create 98% of their work after marriage.

Anyways this is a useless conversation, just looking at all these names makes me depressed....we went from Rani-Ash-Kajol....to Ananya-Janhvi-Shanaya types. The standards have dropped. Aishwarya's worst performance will be equivalent to Janhvi/Ananya's best. That's where we are at!

Originally posted by: Shaitan-Haiwan

we went from Rani-Ash-Kajol....to Ananya-Janhvi-Shanaya types. The standards have dropped. Aishwarya's worst performance will be equivalent to Janhvi/Ananya's best. That's where we are at!

They've done like two movies so far. Ananya was fine in her movies and Jhanvi was horrible in the first one but she was good in Gunjan Saxena. If you give them 20 years to improve the way Ash got 20 years, then the comparison would be worthy.

You are just letting your nostalgia overtake you where everything old was good because your favorite Ash was part of it and now everything is bad because Ash is no longer working. 🤣

Originally posted by: hotchoco

They've done like two movies so far. Ananya was fine in her movies and Jhanvi was horrible in the first one but she was good in Gunjan Saxena. If you give them 20 years to improve the way Ash got 20 years, then the comparison would be worthy.

You are just letting your nostalgia overtake you where everything old was good because your favorite Ash was part of it and now everything is bad because Ash is no longer working. 🤣

Nope its not that. I've enjoyed a lot of work lately. I think current actors are a lot better than the actresses - all actresses who have come after Alia are horrible and in my opinion not worthy.

Even when Deepika started she was bad, but she still had star quality and sex appeal - and potential. Its not my fault upcoming nepo queens look like pre-teens with no talent

Madz’s smile is nice n trained dancer . Is aish trained dancer ? If not Aish danced well at par with Madz . I didn’t find madz any exception in acting . Acting both are ok , not bad .in movies cuts will be there but on stage live it’s difficult . both done decent job on stage live .

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aZdU6PfPXYI

Originally posted by: Nonpareil

Madz’s smile is nice n trained dancer . Is aish trained dancer ? If not Aish danced well at par with Madz . I didn’t find madz any exception in acting . Acting both are ok , not bad .in movies cuts will be there but on stage live it’s difficult . both done decent job on stage live .

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aZdU6PfPXYI

Aish’s entry scene was better than Madz entire performance here. 🙃

Originally posted by: FingerFetish

Aish’s entry scene was better than Madz entire performance here. 🙃

Ya aish’s entry was better 😳

Originally posted by: Nonpareil

Ya aish’s entry was better 😳

That’s cuz there’s no chest thumping or sexy expressions, which is what Madhuri is known for. Whether people want to believe it or not it’s true.

Forget Ash, I think even Karishma is better and outdid Madhuri in DTPH dance-off

Originally posted by: Shaitan-Haiwan

That’s cuz there’s no chest thumping or sexy expressions, which is what Madhuri is known for. Whether people want to believe it or not it’s true.

Forget Ash, I think even Karishma is better and outdid Madhuri in DTPH dance-off

Ya in movie Karishma out did madz in dance off . madz is not good in western dance styles . Any stage performance of them both like madz-aish one. .madz, aish were called stars than actresses .

Sridevi is superstar who emotes well than this both .

They’re both just average. Overacting karne lagti hain dono.