Originally posted by: TMKOC_MY
Navratri is not for celebration, the garba and dance part which is associated with it, is.
Any celebration is attached to festivals so that youngsters can participate in the main puja without any drama, be it Diwali, Holi, Navratri. True essence of festivals is to thank God and connect with him/her spiritually.
One can not focus on spirituality if his/her mind is drawn towards sex
Also the tweet is highlighting the hypocrisy that no one preach to go vegan on Eid, or be pollution free on Christmas but will come with something derogatory or insulting or gyan on Hindu festivals.
Also comparison of Holi( dhulandi) with navratri doesn't make sense to me as Holi ( the puja part happens on the previous day and is the major part of festival as per customs not the playing part)
Again these are all my opinions and I have all the right to call upon hypocrisy of a public figure.
"Navratri is not for celebration, the garba and dance part which is associated with it, is.
Any celebration is attached to festivals so that youngsters can participate in the main puja without any drama, be it Diwali, Holi, Navratri."
You are not going to decide whether it is for celebration or for Puja. Puja part is for theists. Even the theists themselves don't agree who to worship. They worship according to their beliefs. Any celebration that is attached to a festival is NOW a part of festival. If you don't think that is a part of that festival or that is the correct supposed festival because Puja is somehow the true essence, that is upto your belief. Even a simple quote from Wikipedia is enough to state how the ways differ:
Navratri is celebrated in different ways throughout India.[30] Some fast, others feast. Some revere the same Mother Goddess but different aspects of her, while others revere avatars of Vishnu, particularly of Rama.[13] The Chaitra Navaratri culminates in Rama Navami on the ninth day,[31] and the Sharada Navaratri culminates in Durga Puja and Dussehra.[13]
"True essence of festivals is to thank God and connect with him/her spiritually. One can not focus on spirituality if his/her mind is drawn towards sex"
I would need evidence for this otherwise it is just you trying to impose your (possibly pseudo-scientific) beliefs to make it into a code of conduct. Two points here: many people can control their thoughts pretty well regarding sex, and even if they cannot, many people don't care about spirituality/connecting to God. That doesn't mean the festival is not for them. Looks you missed the original point of my post about non-religious or non-Hindus.
"Also comparison of Holi( dhulandi) with navratri doesn't make sense to me as Holi ( the puja part happens on the previous day and is the major part of festival as per customs not the playing part)"
Well this is you trying to nitpick and I knew this was coming. So how much time difference is allowed. 1 day is enough, no flirting on Puja day and then being naughty next day is okay? What about 12 hrs? Is there something divine happening in 1 day that makes it okay on doing it next day. My house has Puja on both the days and yeah one of them is a bigger but still you see.
"Again these are all my opinions and I have all the right to call upon hypocrisy of a public figure."
Better be opinions and pretty dogmatic ones at that. You can call out the original post for the hypocrisy. I assume you will fine if there was no hypocrisy- i.e., they make the same post for all other festivals like Eid etc. I would be happy with that too. That is a positive news for me.
12