Caught the movie finally and LOVED it.
I was expecting something boring and trashy, but the movie was pure cinematic genius. Ranbir was not at the best phase of his career, but he rocked it. Kat was OK, but her role didn't require that much acting and she was fine for it.
Things which I thought were pros:
1. Filmed gorgeously
2. Lovely songs-- well-pictured and melodious
3. Memorable madcap moments
4. Ambitious storytelling
5.Ranbir's acting
Cons:
1. Too many ingredients spoil the broth is the only one I could think of. There were just too many underlying messages and subtext.
2. Could have been edited better
3. Was sold as a film for children (that's what I thought initially and didn't watch in the theatre) whereas actually it is more for adults
Why do you think it flopped when Barfi was such a big hit? Both movies are in the same genre.
15