Originally posted by: MahanalayakKarn
Actually most of the younger gen don't know Rupa who I think was a better actress. Pooja IS the face of Panchali until someone else comes along.
Aham was eclipsed by her and SRJ. Part of it was the writers' mistake. They were so busy trying to justify Karna they completely lost the essence of the original character. TBH, they did the same horror with Krishna. Nuance seems to have been beyond their capabilities.
Aham was actually a better choice for Arjun IMO. He had that internalizing quality which Arjun had. Plus, he'd have looked better with Pooja. Shaheer was too chocolatey to be believable as a warrior. Plus, he couldn't act to save his life.
I think they do know who Rupa is. I have seen both the versions. Rupa's voice was annoying and Draupadi didn't get much importance in BRC like Draupadi was the major highlight in SPMB. Pooja has taken over Roopa for sure but between SRJ & Nitish it's neck to neck but SRJ has the advantage of his charming smile.
I agree. I didn't like how they made Karna into a crybaby at times and his character didn't even get a solo promo throughout, or during introduction of characters. He was handed second fiddle treatment and hardly got any screentime. He was shown to be lost at background so many times. Even side characters got more prominence than him. That's why Aham's performance gets totally neglected on SM. Although I have seen people remembering Karna more than Aham's performance but in case of SRJ & Pooja they get equal appreciation for their respective performances. Aham wasn't given any stand-out scenes like SRJ & Pooja were given to shine and highlight their acting.
I think Aham was perfect fit as Karna. He has that golden-ish brightness and shine on his face and body & eyes too. I wish they focussed more on his grey shades. Aham would've killed it like he's done in Manmarziyaan. And Aham/Pooja have been my dream pair since MB days. I so wish someone casts them together in an intense lovestory. They never shared screenspace together throughout the series but without ever doing that, their verbap spat brought so much fire and intensity on-screen. I'm sure if they come together as a solo pair they'd be lit and bring the house down.
As for Shaheer, he isn't believable in a single role he's done so far. I never understood the hype around his so-called chemistry with Pooja. Shaheer always seemed like a younger sibling to Pooja on or offscreen. 😆 She had far better chemistry with SRJ but her solo stans dislike Aham cause he played Karna & puts him down both as an actor and looker.
Edited by Unfair_Salman - 5 years ago
4