Madhubala vs Aishwarya Rai : More beautiful? - Page 4

Originally posted by: Shaitan-Haiwan

I always liked Ash but I became a big fan of her around Shabd/Dhoom-2. That wasn’t in the 90’s.

So since you became her big fan with Dhoom 2, does that mean everyone got notice of Aish during that time only, usse pehle toh 90s ke baccho ko pata hi nahi tha Aish kaun hai. Kiya baklol baat kar rahe ho.

Originally posted by: RegressiveThug

So since you became her big fan with Dhoom 2, does that mean everyone got notice of Aish during that time only, usse pehle toh 90s ke baccho ko pata hi nahi tha Aish kaun hai. Kiya baklol baat kar rahe ho.

Wasn’t everyone in love with Madhuri in the 90’s? Ab achanak se you’re saying Madhubala was 90’s beauty queen - according to this forum sabki nazar Madhuri se jati hi nahi

Originally posted by: RegressiveThug

I am.going to give my opinion, based on just my own experiences and this isn't about being correct or incorrect. These are just my opinion.

Aish had better structured face than Madhubala, no doubt about it. Madhubala has a big and uneven pakora nose, Aish doesn't have any such inperfection

But I dunno why, I find Aish very unwarm(is that a word?). Her smile doesn't spark that joy, it always seems so feeka.

On the other hand, Madhubala has such a gorgeous smile, she can light a whole house. Yes exaggerated comment, but Madhubala has a beautiful smile, she is a pretty woman obviously, please on eyes, but that smile and expressions are her best features. A picture of Madhubala may lose to the picture of Aish for me, but a video of Aish will never win to the video of Madhubala for me. Madhubala in full glory is the most beautiful actress ever IMO.

So true man. I bet a smiling picture of Madhubala can beat Aishwarya's. Technically Aishwarya might get more points but Madhubala's overall charm is unmatchable.

My vote equated the count to 35 each. Let's see who will win.

Originally posted by: TMKOC_MY

My vote equated the count to 35 each. Let's see who will win.

This forum is not a barometer of anything - current gen doesn’t even care or think that Madhubala is good looking

Aishwarya is known all around the world for her looks. Forget Aishwarya even Sharmila Tagore, Hema Malini, Madhuri are better than this overrated Madhu

Originally posted by: Shaitan-Haiwan

Wasn’t everyone in love with Madhuri in the 90’s? Ab achanak se you’re saying Madhubala was 90’s beauty queen - according to this forum sabki nazar Madhuri se jati hi nahi

I think you have issues regarding reading.

Your first argument was that anyone of us have hardly seen Madhubala, and just saying it because our elders told us about it. When I told you that isn't true because we had ample exposure to Madhubala from our own naked eyes, you came up with argument that its our childhood nostalgia bias, which I again refuted by saying Aish was also highly popular when we were kids than you're saying you became Aish's fan during mid 2000s, so she wasn't active in 90s.

Sorry but you're just stretching the discussion and diverting it because your original point made no sense. Most of us here have said Aish has a better looking face, but we don't prefer her. So why you have problem with that, when we are agreeing with the point your Aish has better features, it's just that Madhubala is more endearing for us. Either you want everyone to hail your queen or you just don't like Madhubala.

Originally posted by: Shaitan-Haiwan

This forum is not a barometer of anything - current gen doesn’t even care or think that Madhubala is good looking

Aishwarya is known all around the world for her looks. Forget Aishwarya even Sharmila Tagore, Hema Malini, Madhuri are better than this overrated Madhu

Yeah but a poll is a poll and winning it means there are more number of people who chose that option.

Originally posted by: RegressiveThug

I think you have issues regarding reading.

Your first argument was that anyone of us have hardly seen Madhubala, and just saying it because our elders told us about it. When I told you that isn't true because we had ample exposure to Madhubala from our own naked eyes, you came up with argument that its our childhood nostalgia bias, which I again refuted by saying Aish was also highly popular when we were kids than you're saying you became Aish's fan during mid 2000s, so she wasn't active in 90s.

Sorry but you're just stretching the discussion and diverting it because your original point made no sense. Most of us here have said Aish has a better looking face, but we don't prefer her. So why you have problem with that, when we are agreeing with the point your Aish has better features, it's just that Madhubala is more endearing for us. Either you want everyone to hail your queen or you just don't like Madhubala.

Nothing can conclude this discussion better than this "Achha Ji mai Hari chalo maan jao na, hu mai sabse pyari, mera dil jalao na" :P

Originally posted by: TMKOC_MY

Nothing can conclude this discussion better than this "Achha Ji mai Hari chalo maan jao na, hu mai sabse pyari, mera dil jalao na" :P

LOL.

Aish fans are loco anyways, Sridevi, Urmila, Sharmila Tagore, Madhuri and Hema Malini better looking than Madhubala. Kal bolenge Tapsee, Bhoomi, Kriti Sanon, Alia Bhatt, Kareena Kapoor, Karishma Kapoor, Anushka Sharma, Lara Dutta, Bipasha Basu, Sara, Ananya, Parineeti and even Suhana Khan are better looking Madhubala.

Aishwarya.

Madhubala has been lucky that during her times media was not that active..n so she will win all such polls becoz we hardly know about her.I have never seen a single int.of hers.Aish will loose becoz of we know too much about her life.Much of our liking is affected bcoz of our analysis on how they are in real life.And I say this becoz most of us admit Ash is prettier but she is plastic.

That said Madhubala is beautiful too.❤️