Originally posted by: Luna46
I never said that DP doesn't have star power. Of course she has, and she was a top actress at one point of time. But the way she's hyped as the biggest superstar to ever walk on earth is irritating.
You are also conveniently ignoring that after Devdas, SLB didn't make any commercial movie until Ram Leela. Ramleela worked because the movie clicked with the audience so the biggest credit goes to the director .DP can't make a movie Hit on her own, otherwise why Tamasha didn't work? It also had RK-DP pairing, which you are saying contributed to YJHD success.
YJHD success belongs mostly to Ranbir, as he was on a career high after Barfi, and he benefitted most from its success as Besharam also took huge opening.
And are you actually giving credit to DP for OSO success, which was DPs debut movie.😆
okay you mean you have issue with her being called the biggest super star, than I agree. She isn't one. Not in the level of Madhuri and she still isn't the jaan of Launde Lapade.
Ram Leela opened big with a 48 crores opening weekend, I don't think we can credit that to a director who was making his comeback after giving duds like Sawaariya and Guzarish.
Tamasha also opened well, but it was such a tatti movie, wouldn't have been hit even if it had peak SRK.
YJHD was obviously more Ranbir driven but the hype due to him and Deepika reuniting after the break up was huge, hence it was his biggest opening at that time.
I am not crediting her for OSO, but just that it came under a trivia regarding SRK. But it is true, SRK's last hits have been with her, and public value them as on screen couple.
Anyways if your issue with with Deepika fans over hyping her in IF, than I cant say much 😆... You guys keep fighting, I read your post as discrediting her for any of her success, hence made a counter.
0