What was so special about YJHD? - Page 5

Originally posted by: dhartiamber

you have got to be smoking something if you think the movie worked for any of the actors RK is giving flop pe flop and DP cant make finding fanny even a average and bwahahaha at Kalki and ARK yeah big superstars they are lols

Music + chemistry between leads + for my bestie's sake cuz she used to be a big Ranbir buff those days and dragged me to watch it 😆

The story was very plain and straightforward

Originally posted by: GundayVedant

Besides Khan no one can carry a souless films on their arms

But

do you think if there was Varun instead of RK or Priyaka instead of DP - The film would have done the same business?

Fact that RK - DP were coming back first time onscreen after their high profile breakup made people notice the film... then the trailers, dialogue promos, SONGS , look - everything worked in its favour will culminated in film being success! One 'factor' can never make a film a success nor a failure

I don't know the answer either. I didn't like the film personally.

Originally posted by: zara321

The story was very plain and straightforward

i was waiting thourhgout the whole movie for something dramatic to happen to make it more interesting but it didnt happen

The songs r a big reason why the movie did so well, every song was a hit and big credit to pritam for making such a great album

scenery was beautiful, but one of the biggest problems i had was with the characters bunny and naina, how they fell in love? why they fell in love? I just didnt get it, the friendships were shown much better than the love story

and the final scene was underwhelming, he just walked through casually through the door into her house as if nothing has happened lol

but i guess it appealed to the younger audience, it was a frothy love story, and coz rk-dp were coming back onscreen

I thought it was a fabulous movie! There was romance but not a fairytale one. Both of them pursued their dreams and did not let their attractions for each other get in the way. It is hard to digest a story which is realistic compared to all those OTT fairytale DDLJ kinda romance in most of the movies. The evolving relationship between 4 friends, over a span of 8 years...

Originally posted by: dhartiamber

it was so shitty the movie is not worth to sit for 1 time its so predictable the whole credit of success goes to Pritam in this. the music was hit the power of hit music can make a crap work. Aashiquie 2 also worked for music even Roy had a good opening for music.

Exactly!

Though i remmember how after Katrina,Sonam was the 2nd choice.I'm glad Sonam wasn't in this crap.😆

There was a reason this movie was a blockbuster. Bunny and Naina were SIZZLING and oh so cute. Both Biru and Deepika were at their peak and it was just such an amazing movie! The music was really good too.

Originally posted by: Sharpener

Also, if music were to make a movie a hit, then every Emran Hashmi movie would be a blockbuster