Is HR the only star kid that deserved superstardom? - Page 3

Originally posted by: harshu.sundas

Bhai the irony is when sodumb fans find Hrithik overrated 😭

Originally posted by: flipfl0p

He is not "Star" kid. Roshan was a not tag like Bacchan or Kapoor.

But his dad made "Koi Mil Gaya" for him, which lifted him out of his flops.

Originally posted by: AvadaKedavra

Well, obviously I am not 100% sure. I mostly base my opinions on what I see, read and hear (just like other people on this forum do).

And if they were then it was not as blatantly obvious as it is with Alia.

Originally posted by: .Jane..

But weren't Salim-Javed considered superstars in their own right? Even though scriptwriters, I believe they commanded a lot of respect and were highly influential. Salman made it in the industry in his own right but he can be considered a starkid in that sense, no?

Originally posted by: atominis

Yes but a writer's son doesn't carry the hype that an actor's son does. Especially in mind of audience.

Many commoners still don't know Salman is son of that Salim who wrote Sholay. Infact only now people realised they were 2 different persons. Earlier those who did not follow film news, didn't even know Salim Javed was not 1 person but a team of 2.

Actors have instant recall. Not writers or fight masters though they might get better chances by industry insiders.

Originally posted by: IAmLuvBolly

That's actually true. While he has had success with other banners and directors he is mostly known or became a star, or superstar if you will, from movies his dad made for him. If you take all of Rakesh Roshan's movies out of his filmography, where would he be today with K3G, D2, JA, ZNMD, and then a Guzaarish, Mission Kashmir, MPKDH, Yaadein etc?

Originally posted by: harshu.sundas

Bhai the irony is when sodumb fans find Hrithik overrated 😭

Originally posted by: .Jane..

@bold: Really? Wow!😲

As for the rest, yea, that makes sense. I was just curious. Thanks! :)

Originally posted by: IAmLuvBolly

No.

He's not really a star kid per say as his father was never a star. He was a flop actor who resorted to directing producing because his acting career didn't of anywhere. So in that regard Hrithik is in the same boat as Aamir and Salman.

I think his acting is over rated. I think while he has a very beautiful face something about his features seem too perfect and unnatural too me so overall I don't find him as attractive or handsome as a lot of others. He's a great dancer but once again his dancing is too perfect. You don't get the feeling for the fun and essence of the song because you are too busy watching his fluid body. Overall I enjoy Shahid's dances in JWM much more than Hrithik's in D2.

He seems to be hard working and deserves his success. But I don't think he's the only one who deserves it, or that he necessarily deserves it more than other industry kids. I'm sure India is full of handsome talents wonderful dancers. Fact is Hrithik like many others before him, and many others after him, got his chances and his major launch because of his family.

Originally posted by: harshu.sundas

Bhai the irony is when sodumb fans find Hrithik overrated 😭