Who would have played TINA (KKHH) to perfection? - Page 3

Till the film hits the screens, any and every actor is replaceable. It is true that Tina was a simple character to play and anyone with acting skills could've pulled her off. HOWEVER, it boils down to how much an audience connects to the ultimate portrayal. It is hard to imagine anyone other than Rani as Tina because she lent her own colour to a character who KJo (rightfully so, in his defence) felt she doesn't suit. To pull off the college diva with oodles of sex-appeal when you aren't the conventionally gorgeous one is a tough job and Rani overcame that obstacle beautifully. Not once did she feel out-of-place in the role.

Aish/Twinkle might look the part but i don't see them doing what Rani did. Tina would've been a different character had anyone else played her. In that sense, Rani became Tina and ultimately THAT's a successful acting stint!