Request to Bollywood_mad to reopen thread

Dear Moderator,

Can't understand why the following thread was closed:

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=442588&T PN=3

The thread had very good discussion ongoing about the movie Don2 and more in an analytical manner rather than a candyfloss manner. If you had to close it, you could have instead shifted it to Film Previews and Reviews Section rather than abruptly closing it. This is a request to reopen the thread otherwise it would appear biased and unfair on your part to have abruptly closed it while so many other threads on movie discussions are ongoing.

We are the public which make these movie stars and have every right to diss them if we find that the movie does not measure up to mark.

Regards

RajanS1234

Hi,
I am not the mod, but I am the coolbie for this section, and the reason your thread was closed, because there is a sticky post in the film review and preview section where you are suppose to post our review for don. And bollywood section is only for news, not for reviews. So I think you can either pm the mod for this section and request them to shift the post to film reviews and previews and reopen it...or you can just post your review in the sticky topic and start a new discussion there. Hope this was able to help you

~Rashi~

Ok I just finished reading all the posts in that thread, and one of the reaason it was closed, because your not suppose to post a review of the movie in this thread and i mentioned that already in the above post, and the second reason is that actor/director bashing is not allowed on IF as some fans might get offended...so i think it more because of the bashing that the thread got closed
but if you still think that these reasons arent justified to close the thread then contanct the mods for this section

~Rashi~

Ok guys I have just pmed the GM and will see what she thinks about this matter and will let you know if the closing of the thread was justified or not and if it wasnt then we will get it reopened

~Rashi~

dazzlingdesi, thank you for your intervention. The reason the thread was closed was because the viewbie took objection to the criticism of SRK. Now may I point out that the criticism was about the movie and actor's performance not a bashing (as termed by the viewbie) at a personal level. This is meant to be a public forum where people should have the freedom to express their opionion about actors, and movies in the respective context of course.

I agree with Buffie that one can't always shower false prasies on actors and actresses esp. when we pay hard earned money to go and watch their movies. Actors are defined as stars by the public without which they would be non-existent.

Hence please request the viewbie who closed the thread to reopen it so that we can have a continuing discussion. If SRKs perfromance in Don was bad, it is our public right to trash his performance. We should not be deprived of it.

One reason I closed it was maybe due to some bashing but mostly as this should be posted here;

Click here!!

-Chandni 😊 , thanks for justifying Rashi 😊

To Buffie,

I could not have moved it because a topic has already bee opened for Don, if any problems you can PM a mod, I have no problem. 😊

Thanks for understandning

-Chandni 😊

To Bollywood_mad, if there is a discussion ongoing elesewhere, can you not merge the thread over there instead of just closing it. THere are so many other threads in this sction which are having discussions on Don and other movies, so why only this thread was closed. If it was neccessary to close this thread the you can obviously shift it and merge it with the relevant thread in the Filmi Discussion section.

Thanks

I do not know how to do this but I will ask Khushi Di to thanks for claryifing!! 😊