Rockstar vs. LAK: Worst One - Page 5

Rockstar's music has that everlasting quality, it stays with u (atleast for me), initially I only liked Phir se udd chala, but Tum ho, Aur ho, jo bhi main, kun faya kun slow grew on me I still get goosebumps listening to Aur ho .. though I agree Sadda Haq is overrated, the lyrics were really good.

Originally posted by: Dexterkilaila

Are you Eraser? Only she would talk so fondly of Rockstar. 😆


OT: Both bored me. Difficult to choose which is worse. Both very pretentious films.

Originally posted by: NailClipper

And why should we adjust our ears according to your taste? Everyone is talking about his/her preference. Learn to accept others opinion. Not all are gonna say the thing you feel is right.

It's quite crazy, I mean most ppl have only negative things to say about both films and yet Imtiaz Ali and his films are so hyped. I don't get it. He needs to come up with better scripts/screenplay.

I loved Ranbir's acting in Rockstar, he was amazing.. But the film almost bored me to death.. Throughout the film I wondered, like, why is this film so hyped? Had no patience to even finish it.

LAK had good songs, Yeh Dooriyan still gives me goosebumps.. and Chor Bazaari was superb.

So Rockstar is worse.

Originally posted by: CeaselessBanter

I can still be tolerant and acceptable of others taste and consider something crap. Beiber is still crap, no matter the millions of records he has sold and will not stand the test of time is my opinion Yes, harsh but It is what it is.

I can point to the reviews and awards Rockstar won vs LAK. But that would defeat the purpose of this discussion. Music is what one feels, not what one is convinced to feel and if LAK appeals to you and Rockstar does not, that is what is superior to you. And I can still be shocked that LAK appeals to people over Rockstar,. That is the beauty of an opinion. 😉. Goes both ways.

And why are you shoving Beiber to us? Who was advocating Beiber here?

To you Rockstar was Beethoven. Your opinion. To me Rockstar was K.L. Saigal (And that's not a compliment). My opinion.

We said LAK's songs (Not all) were comparatively better, we'd prefer listening Ajj Din Chadeya and Yeh Dooriyan than Rockstar's songs. At least we didn't insult Mozart/Schubert by calling some mediocre songs similar to Mozart/Schubert's work.

@ bold: Should I be shocked seeing your panties in a twist because three anons didn't like your Beethoven's work?

You love Rockstar's music fine but no need to shove your "superior" music tastes onto us. We're just fine with our mediocre tastes thank you.

Originally posted by: rewaa

I actually liked Rockstar .It was a passionate love story .

LAK was a royal mess ..A real pain to endure that movie ..

Great, I thought I was the only soul who liked rockstar 😆
LAK was torture!

Rockstar was kind of artsy and sorta unconventional,I usually like such films. But I didnt like Rockstar. It didnt make sense to me at all. Nargis was a bad choice. As much as I like her off-screen segments,I cannot bear her in films. Rockstar has scope for becoming much better,but there were several loose ends. And logic missing.

Originally posted by: NailClipper

And why are you shoving Beiber to us? Who was advocating Beiber here?

To you Rockstar was Beethoven. Your opinion. To me Rockstar was K.L. Saigal (And that's not a compliment). My opinion.

We said LAK's songs (Not all) were comparatively better, we'd prefer listening Ajj Din Chadeya and Yeh Dooriyan than Rockstar's songs. At least we didn't insult Mozart/Schubert by calling some mediocre songs similar to Mozart/Schubert's work.

@ bold: Should I be shocked seeing your panties in a twist because three anons didn't like your Beethoven's work?