Is Salman now a bigger star then Aamir & Srk ?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Poll

Frequent Posters

Sultan

@I_M_SultaN

Master

+ 11

Posted: 11 years ago

#51

Originally posted by: blue-ice

Maroony...u can't bring HAHK in this thread...Tanya is talking about the last 5 years only...and if u want to bring a 20 year old movie...lets compare everything in the 20 year old careers...not just one movie out of the blue...u want to see the biggest star...lets start by counting the HIT/FLOP ratio in the last 25 years...

srk> salman > amir overall 😆

Edited by HooLiGaN - 11 years ago

Quote

slumgod..

@slumgod..

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

#52

Originally posted by: Franco

Who's discussing tickets sold

And I'm sure a lot of deol family members bought the Gadar tickets 😆

Its just a discussion on a record that you guys say salman is always chasing the others for . Even Salman himself says he's chasing and it's good for him

But I'm just saying he had that record . Before anybody else named khan no less

It's good he's chasing the new one . I'm sure he passes it . I'll be happy as I was as a 3 year old when HAHK passed sholay

But let's not rewrite history here and say he's always been chasing

I'm just using the history to clear up the facts

Not living in the past . Just making sure no one forgets it

😉

Then who is discussing about what Salman has done 20 years ago. There are many types of records in Bollywood and we are certainly not talking about what HAHK has done 20 years ago. Did HAHK crossed 100 crores or 200 crores?

Anyway, topic is " IS ( not WAS) Salman NOW bigger star than Amir or SRK?"

Edited by slumgod.. - 11 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

870349

Suspended

Posted: 11 years ago

#53

Sorry guys I made a error and did not read the last five years thing

But to recap the last five years

2010- salman had the top movie

2011- salman had the top movie

2012 - salman had the top movie

2013- Aamir had the top movie

2014- salman has the top movie so far

Does that about cover it 😉

Quote

mix_of_emotions

@mix_of_emotions

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 11 years ago

#54

anyways continuously giving blockbusters since last 5 yrs salman is definately biggest star.

and the crowd salman can pull on his own is hugee compared to srk aamir.

regaring d3 thng usse bhi koi na koi beat kar hi dega records are made to break.

but the consistent hits salman provided its obvious salman has upper hand since last 5 yrs

Quote

Sultan

@I_M_SultaN

Master

+ 11

Posted: 11 years ago

#55

Originally posted by: Franco
Sorry guys I made a error and did not read the last five years thing

But to recap the last five years

2010- salman had the top movie

2011- salman had the top movie 2 movies 1 bodyguard 2 ready

2012 - salman had the top movie again 2 movies ett and dabangg two beat the other 2 khans 😛

2013- Aamir had the top movie no release in 2013

2014- salman has the top movie so far 😛 2 movies in top 2 as per taran bhaiya 😆 otherwise 2 movies in top 2

Does that about cover it 😉

😆 corrected

Edited by HooLiGaN - 11 years ago

Quote

Wicked

@SomeOldUser

Sparkler

+ 8

Posted: 11 years ago

#56

He can never beat SRK, and yes, I say that as as unbiased audience member. I despise SRK to the core, I just can't stand him on screen. But when it comes to Salman and SRK - Salman stands no chance whatsoever! SRK is miles ahead of his contemporaries in every way possible.

And I say that as a humble, loyal Aamir Khan fan!

Quote

664269

Suspended

Posted: 11 years ago

#57

bigger star than srk but not aamir

Quote

Wicked

@SomeOldUser

Sparkler

+ 8

Posted: 11 years ago

#58

Originally posted by: Franco
Sorry guys I made a error and did not read the last five years thing

But to recap the last five years

2010- salman had the top movie

2011- salman had the top movie

2012 - salman had the top movie

2013- Aamir had the top movie

2014- salman has the top movie so far

Does that about cover it 😉

He might have had a top movie - but are his roles really remembered?

When was the last time you remembered his role in Bodyguard or Wanted or whatever as his benchmark role? Chulbul Pandey, perhaps. But even then, Chulbul Pandey was a masala role - no character or substance. Jo chal gaya so chal gaya - wohi waali baat hui.

SRK's role in Don, Chak De India, MNIK, etc. are worth remembering. The same applies to Aamir Khan's roles in TZP and 3 Idiots.

Quote

blue-ice.

@blue-ice.

Achiever

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#59

Originally posted by: The-Voice
He can never beat SRK, and yes, I say that as as unbiased audience member. I despise SRK to the core, I just can't stand him on screen. But when it comes to Salman and SRK - Salman stands no chance whatsoever! SRK is miles ahead of his contemporaries in every way possible.

And I say that as a humble, loyal Aamir Khan fan!

🥳

Quote

Sultan

@I_M_SultaN

Master

+ 11

Posted: 11 years ago

#60

Originally posted by: The-Voice

He might have had a top movie - but are his roles really remembered?

When was the last time you remembered his role in Bodyguard or Wanted or whatever as his benchmark role? Chulbul Pandey, perhaps. But even then, Chulbul Pandey was a masala role - no character or substance. Jo chal gaya so chal gaya - wohi waali baat hui.

SRK's role in Don, Chak De India, MNIK, etc. are worth remembering. The same applies to Aamir Khan's roles in TZP and 3 Idiots.

his prem and radhe will be remembered not others tho which he is doing now bro 😛