This reviewer has stated the same reason of actors coming out as trying too hard...But u know,cant fault the cast for that,...As in many reviews critics have mentioned, actors are doing a fine job,but their half-baked characters are failing them...Sid's and Aamna's characters were bizzarely written while RD's is the only one atleast half decently fleshed out by the writer...its the result of faulty screen play and director being confused himself about the character's emotions and reactions...The cast would've been more convincing if the execution was better
Review: Ek Villain (2014)

Ek Villain sticks out like a sour thumb of all the films I've seen so far this year. The contrived thriller is predictable from the word go. Mohit Suri spends two hours taking you back and forth, in a scarcely gratifying execution. I sat there amazed at the idiocy of the plot. What a waste of actors in a story that's lame, and sometimes unintentionally hilarious. The 70ish dialoguebaazi is cliched and tediously repellent; characters that make even some of those in television soaps look good (like our mafia don Remo Fernandes). What was the director smoking?
Shraddha Kapoor is a pleasant surprise. She's likeable as the bubbly, do-gooder Aisha. It was tough to concentrate as the smolderingly good-looking Sidharth Malhotra spoke when I interviewed him last week. It's as hard looking away when he's on screen. His scant dialogues made it easier. I could un-guiltily stare away. [And gush and swoon as he went shirtless (twice ;-)] For a two-film actor, this was a decent performance, but despite my gooey love for him, he seemed to be trying too hard. His best is yet to come and he won't be long! Ritesh Deshmukh is good playing the unforgiving baddie. If only he had better lines. His backstory is silly, dialogues sillier, and his wife? Never mind!
The only resurrecting grace is Aisha and Guru's (Sidharth) love story that weaves in enough mush and romance to keep you going, with ever so listenable music.
2