How can we even compare kamli with crazy kia re? - Page 2

Originally posted by: JodhaBai

lol

Now we've come to the point where Kat fans are upset so we're calling Ash not a good dancer or where's the dancing in Crazy Kiya Re.

Hilarious

Just face that Kat is not a dancer. She's doing aerobics. Big deal. People think she looks hot. That's all she needs to get by.

Originally posted by: Crystal__

^I doubt it, no offense.

aishwariya never was passionate towards fitness, she didn't have it in her.

to do such dance forms you first of all need a well toned body, cause doing those roop scenes are not something you can just do like that.

you need to first get well toned and build muscles and first then can you train the scenes.

no denying aish is a fantastic classical dancer but she has never impressed in western numbers and also she couldn't pull of a Kamli because she never had the dedication to achieve such a body.

Hmmm... this can be quite difficult to justify.. unless ash has said somewhere that she has no dedication to achieve a toned body or build muscle to do such stunts, there is no basis for your statement. Ash is a professional and so is Kat. They will do whatever it takes im sure, to fulfil the director's vision. I dont think we should put an actor down or say he or she has no dedication when the opportunity has not even been offered to him or her.

Originally posted by: galacticb

Hmmm... this can be quite difficult to justify.. unless ash has said somewhere that she has no dedication to achieve a toned body or build muscle to do such stunts, there is no basis for your statement. Ash is a professional and so is Kat. They will do whatever it takes im sure, to fulfil the director's vision. I dont think we should put an actor down or say he or she has no dedication when the opportunity has not even been offered to him or her.

Do you need to see more D3 clips to show you that Kat isn't a dancer?

Originally posted by: JodhaBai

Do you need to see more D3 clips to show you that Kat isn't a dancer?

Look at the way she's moving. If you think she looks like a dancer than okay.

And again if you think Ash can't do western dance and if D2 didn't prove that to you then check out Robot. Or Ishq Kamini.

Ash never had an athletes body. She doesn't lift weights as far as I know. She did yoga for D2.

Kat has an athletes body. She can do all the aerobics she wants but dont call it dancing.

Originally posted by: galacticb

When crazy kiya re came out in 2006, it was stg new for the indian audience. Now kamli is also going to introduce stg new to the indian audience, modern / western dance mixed w some acrobatics... although isha sharvani has done acrobatics mixed with a classical form. And I agree that people prefer crazy kiya re more bcos of nostalgia. But i dont think its fair of ppl to say that ash wont b able to do the moves done by kat in the song. Ash is 40 yrs old!!!! If she was younger, Im sure she would have been able to do what is required of her in a role just like what kat is doing. Kat fans tend to be condescending and nasty towards ash and vice versa. Both sides need to chill and agree to disagree.

Having said that, I still prefer ash's crazy kiya re but maybe my opinion might change once the full video song of kamli is out. 😊

Originally posted by: JodhaBai

lol

Now we've come to the point where Kat fans are upset so we're calling Ash not a good dancer or where's the dancing in Crazy Kiya Re.

Hilarious

Just face that Kat is not a dancer. She's doing aerobics. Big deal. People think she looks hot. That's all she needs to get by.

lol ok I'm not a fan of Kat's acting but I must say dance in kamli is 10 times better than aish's krazy kiya re dance👏crazy kiya re is famous nly because of catchy lyrics aish was just average there.. any xyz actress can do crazy kiya re moves..

thanks Bullseye!

Originally posted by: Crystal__

^I doubt it, no offense.

aishwariya never was passionate towards fitness, she didn't have it in her.

to do such dance forms you first of all need a well toned body, cause doing those roop scenes are not something you can just do like that.

you need to first get well toned and build muscles and first then can you train the scenes.

no denying aish is a fantastic classical dancer but she has never impressed in western numbers and also she couldn't pull of a Kamli because she never had the dedication to achieve such a body.