Rockstr nd LAK can't compare to d Classic JWM: KKK - Page 25

Originally posted by: pathaka

http://faridoonshahryar.blogspot.com.au/2011/11/imtiaz-ali-on-rockstar-criticism-and.html

http://www.etc.in/bollywood-business/andaz-apna-apna-hera-pheri-are-cult-films1.html

Faridoon shayar and Komal nahta - legit trade analysts and film journos...

Originally posted by: pathaka

http://faridoonshahryar.blogspot.com.au/2011/11/imtiaz-ali-on-rockstar-criticism-and.html

http://www.etc.in/bollywood-business/andaz-apna-apna-hera-pheri-are-cult-films1.html

Faridoon shayar and Komal nahta - legit trade analysts and film journos...

Originally posted by: pathaka

http://faridoonshahryar.blogspot.com.au/2011/11/imtiaz-ali-on-rockstar-criticism-and.html

http://www.etc.in/bollywood-business/andaz-apna-apna-hera-pheri-are-cult-films1.html

Faridoon shayar and Komal nahta - legit trade analysts and film journos...

http://www.cinemaconfessions.com/2012/08/the-list-10-greatest-hindi-films.html

[UEL]http://tribune.com.pk/story/296341/film-review-rockstar-the-star-rocks/[/URL]

Geet in JWM is nothing as compare to what Bebo did as Dolly in Omkara... don't know y always JWM is brought ahead of all her performances...

JWM a classic? what a joke LMAO.

Originally posted by: Dexterkilaila

I agree with you about JWM.

As far as SNT is concerned, I think relatively unknown faces worked against SNT and the fact that it wasn't loud in any which way. But I do think years down the line, it will make a mark. I mean Andaz Apna Apna was a straight up debacle, people did not like or understand it. But years later it did turn out to be one of the most popular films in the DVD circuit and the most talked about on the internet. So who knows...SNT might get its due someday as well.

Yeah, unknown faces, lack of promotions, the songs didn't become huge like JWM's did either..SNT's done very well on the DVD circuit and most folks who've seen it do like it...it might get there someday. Its a real pity that Imtiaz thinks it's his worst film. 😕 But his sensibilities hardly make any sense to me anymore so I guess I'm not surprised. 😆

Everyone who's seen MFK really liked it. But the name is a huge turn off + unknown faces. One of my BFF's was making fun of the film's name & I told her it's actually a good movie so she should give it a try since she loves rom-coms & she thought I'd totally lost my marbles. 😆 Must bug her to actually watch it one of these days.

Bottom Line: Classic or no classic, Rockstar and LAK were worse than JWM.

MFK was directed by the same woman who directed Hip hip hurray and the Mahi way series right?

JWM was way better than Rockstar/LAK. But i woudn't call it a classic.

Originally posted by: pathaka

MFK was directed by the same woman who directed Hip hip hurray and the Mahi way series right?

i havent seen it but i like both the above two shows...HHH more than Mahi way...

in today's times, id say 3 idiots, JWM and Dev D are legit enough to be considered cult films...

if all goes right with it, i THINK go goa gone might become a cult too...who knos...😆