Raja Sen's Report card for 2012 heroines - Page 3

Originally posted by: koiza.k

Kareena got an A hotmess- kat and vidya are the only ones to get A+

Originally posted by: -ksh-

Why is Cherry not mentioned?

its rude to grade legends ksh- respect raja for this! :D

Originally posted by: HotMess

Since this is about box office and not talent, I think PC's grade is understandable. But I'd stll give her at least a B+. Barfi was great, it did well, but TMK was equally bad and she got nothing out of Agneepath.

Kareena getting A+.. don't know about that. I'd give her just an A, I think. I liked Raja's comments about Asin/Sonakshi.. "Like Asin, she's a heroine looked on as big-movie filler." These girls need to stop doing flower-vase roles if they really want to prove their potential.

PC had 3 releases: Agneepath, Barfi, and Teri Meri Kahaani: 2 big hits...1 dud. ...so that's A, A, F...it balances at least to a B+, A-. ...but then, did Asin and Sonakshi get anything out of their releases either? 😆

Kareena actually has no clean hit for the year out of her 4 releases. So really, if this is a BO list, her grade should be the lowest out of all of them. Talaash and EMAET are NOT clean hits. If Anushka despite a hit is B-, then Kareena should be nothing higher than a C, BO wise. ...but since she's been given an A+, he's definitely including other things. 😆

Raja Sen makes it obvious day by day. 😆

*for the record Kareena is anyday better than Anushka, Sonakshi, Asin, Katrina...but I fail to see how she got the A+ on a box office list.

Originally posted by: HotMess

Since this is about box office and not talent, I think PC's grade is understandable. But I'd stll give her at least a B+. Barfi was great, it did well, but TMK was equally bad and she got nothing out of Agneepath.

Kareena getting A+.. don't know about that. I'd give her just an A, I think. I liked Raja's comments about Asin/Sonakshi.. "Like Asin, she's a heroine looked on as big-movie filler." These girls need to stop doing flower-vase roles if they really want to prove their potential.

Originally posted by: -ksh-

Why is Cherry not mentioned?

Originally posted by: chocolover89

PC had 3 releases: Agneepath, Barfi, and Teri Meri Kahaani: 2 big hits...1 dud. ...so that's A, A, F...it balances at least to a B+, A-. ...but then, did Asin and Sonakshi get anything out of their releases? 😆

Kareena actually has no clean hit for the year out of her 4 releases. So really, if this is a BO list, her grade should be the lowest out of all of them. Talaash and EMAET are NOT clean hits. If Anushka despite a hit is B-, then Kareena should be nothing higher than a C, BO wise.

Raja Sen makes it obvious day by day. 😆

Agree here with blue ice- PC even had a fantastic year in terms of box office man- how are we ignoring 2 100 crore plus movies? its only a bonus that her performance was widely appreciated in these as well - she had both box office and critical acclaim this year- very rare for actresses only PC and Vidya had it this year! so B grade makes no sense AT ALL!

Originally posted by: chocolover89

Btw are you sure Raja Sen made this list? How did he give Deepika an A? That surely must have taken a lot out of him. 😆

Oh Raja Sen. He just made it more obvious that he is biased towards certain actresses.

Originally posted by: -Radhe-

BO Collection wise if he is analyzing, Asin gave 2 back 2 back 100 cr movies with Housefull2. Bol Bachchan which is well above than Vidya's Kahaani or even TDP.

Does anyone care for his choices? 😆

I do! vidya ki aukaat hi kya asin ke samne :D