KARISMA's second INNINGS..will she be LUCKY?! - Page 3

Originally posted by: nkapoor

^^^oh ok so Biwi No.1 was not a hit because of her?? Raja Hindustani was not a hit because of her? Jeet was not a hit because of her? did she not star in movies like Fiza and Zubeidda where she was the main lead? I can also say that all madhuri hits were hits because of Anil Kapoor, Salman, Aamir and Srk! u watch today's comedy movies how much role do the female leads have?? U can maybe say that sridevi has given hits like Chaalbaaz and stuff, but I am sorry Madhuri is not that amazing! Karisma is a major contributer to the hits given by salman and govinda! when she left almost all their movies flopped except for Partner!

Originally posted by: Meena1

oh man, another person who thought her DTPH was very over-rated.. hahaha.. Madhuri looked weird in that movie.. i hated her hair and those funny outfits she wore in it.. i guess i was just bored of seeing her at that point..😆

Originally posted by: smartie_pants

i previously said i dunt wanna stretch it further but, too bad..to heck with that

a) oh ok so Biwi No.1 was not a hit because of her?? Raja Hindustani was not a hit because of her? Jeet was not a hit because of her?

Were they hits ONLY because of her? and NOTHING else?

b) did she not star in movies like Fiza and Zubeidda where she was the main lead?

Were those films commercially successful??

c) I can also say that all madhuri hits were hits because of Anil Kapoor, Salman, Aamir and Srk!

Raja had sanjay kapoor and it was a hit. And hes the most floppity flop actor u could possibly find. And like i mentioned, anil kapoor was technically the "heroine" in Beta who just came in for the songs and for crying scenes...It survived solely on the basis of madhuris charisma, her dhak dhak number namely...and her dances...

e)Karisma is a major contributer to the hits given by salman and govinda! when she left almost all their movies flopped except for Partner!

Am i denying her contribution??? NO...am i denying her ability to do comedy or to act..NO...im denying the magnitude of her star power as compared to that of madhuri and sridevi...that she commercially dosent hold court like they do...

f) No need to get defensive...

Originally posted by: Gobsmacked

yup her boobs were sticking out through out the movie in those extremely tight salwars.

Originally posted by: nkapoor

I am sorry, at her time Karisma did hold the no.1 status, and no amount of arguement is going to change that! also for ur kind info Karisma did deliver a superhit movie called Anari with a south actor who absolutely had no star power in Bollywood, so there!

Originally posted by: nkapoor

I am sorry, at her time Karisma did hold the no.1 status, and no amount of arguement is going to change that! also for ur kind info Karisma did deliver a superhit movie called Anari with a south actor who absolutely had no star power in Bollywood, so there!

Originally posted by: smartie_pants

oh man...she wore transparent ones and Yash chopra made her dance in the rain to make it even worse!!!

Must say...she was not in the best shape at that time either...Spandex was a baaad idea.