KAMINEY REVIEWS- POST HERE. - Page 15

Created

Last reply

Replies

407

Views

35.1k

Users

77

Likes

694

Frequent Posters

Monu-SunNaa thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
Ah, the movie is GREAT! 😃 Kaminey is a movie you'd like to go watch again though gangster flicks are not my thing, but Kaminey is an exception, editing is tight so no unnecessary dragging, the direction is so good, especially liked the end sequence when Charlie stakes the guiter/cocaine to save Guddu and Sweety, and the bad guys Chief Thode & co running for their life. The background score was cool & edgy. Fantastic acting by Shahid, and Priyanka was impressive too, good light comic timing in the scene where Sweety tells Guddu that she is preggers with Guddu's child. Sweety is just adorable character. To cut the story short, the movie is very good, well worth the 7.50 I paid, 😉I recommend to watch the film on big screen, where you can visually appreciate some of the high paced sequences. I loved the character of Mikchael>>>nutter!, shame about his end. Lastly, Priyanka-Shahid's chemistry is amazing, they lived up to the hype surrounding their chem.
I wish VB has included the Pehli baar Mohabbat ki hain song seq in the the final cut of the film.
Edited by -Yas- - 16 years ago
starchase thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
^^ agree to well worth the 6. 40 being payed( got a student discount😆). very happy :)
Edited by salma434 - 16 years ago
gilmores thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 16 years ago

Masand's movie review: Kaminey, imaginative and original

Cast:

Shahid Kapur, Priyanka Chopra, Amole Gupte, Chandan Roy Sanyal, Tenzing Nima, Shiv Subramanium

Director: Vishal Bharadwaj

When was the last time you came out of a film wishing you could go back in and watch it again immediately so the excitement in your stomach stays longer?

Vishal Bharadwaj's Kaminey is a film you'll either love or passionately despise.

It's an unpredictable crime drama that combines violence and dark humor in a manner that's reminiscent of the films of Quentin Tarantino, Guy Ritchie and the Coen Brothers. And yet Kaminey is so original and inventive in the manner in which it takes Bollywood's favorite formula - twin brothers - and turns it on its head.

Shahid Kapur is cast as both twins, each saddled with a speech impediment. Charlie, the small-time gangster has a lisp, he pronounces every 's' as 'f'; meanwhile Guddu is a timid NGO worker who stammers when he speaks.

There's no love lost between the boys, who haven't seen each other for three years, so we follow their tracks separately, until suddenly their lives collide.

Charlie has chanced upon a guitar that contains cocaine worth 10 crore rupees. His life is made, he thinks.

Guddu, on the other hand, has got his girlfriend pregnant, and as luck would have it, turns out she's the sister of a local gangster-politician.

Take that as a cue for much mayhem which involves encounters with dreaded drug-lords, corrupt cops and the quirkiest set of henchmen any Hindi film has ever produced.

The real strength of Kaminey is its writing. The non-linear screenplay is filled with unfamiliar twists and confusing turns that are likely to baffle you along the way; yet they're all neatly tied up and culminate in a thrilling climax which is violent and comical in equal parts.

The film's dialogue is top-notch; writer-director Vishal Bharadwaj finds a way to make the lines humorous without ever seeming to ask for a laugh.

Take the scene in which Guddu squarely blames his girlfriend for getting pregnant, and she retaliates with an outburst, demanding to know if she'd raped him then.

Or the scene in which a cop Lobo coaxes Guddu to give a police statement in song, because that's the only way to get the kid to communicate without a stutter.

Kaminey boasts the best performance you will see by an ensemble cast in a long time, and that includes even the bit players.

Of the central cast, Amole Gupte is fantastic as the demented Jai Maharashtra-spouting gangster-politician Bhope, and Chandan Roy Sanyal hits all the right notes as the coke-addicted Mikhail.

Also delivering impressive turns are Tenzing Nima as the charismatic drug-smuggler Tashi and Shiv Subramanium as the vulnerable corrupt cop Lobo.

Shahid Kapur rises to the challenge of creating two entirely different characters out of Charlie and Guddu, and delivers a credible performance as each.

Breaking out of his chocolate-boy image, he gives evidence of his potential when trusted with well-written roles.

Springing a delightful surprise in a smaller part is Priyanka Chopra as the feisty Sweety, who sprinkles her lines with a smattering of fluent Marathi and emerges one of the film's most lovable characters.

For an audience numbed by predictable Bollywood potboilers week after week, Kaminey might take some time to settle into; go in with an open mind and enjoy the ride.

With unchoreographed action scenes and dances, and long portions with no background score at all, it's a wildly imaginative, original offering from a fearless filmmaker who doesn't insult your intelligence.

I'm going with four out of five for director Vishal Bharadwaj's Kaminey; amidst all the bloodshed and bullets, this film has a full beating heart. As Charlie would say: It's a MUFT-WATCH.

Rating: 4 / 5 (Very Good)

OMG OMG OMG 🥳🥳🥳 I can't wait till I see this tomorrow!!! I'm SOOOOO going now...since my dad's fav critic gave it a 4/5!!!!!!!!! YES...I'm SOO excitedddd...shahid here I come!! lols
Monu-SunNaa thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
^^
I forgot my NUS at home, so has to fork out the whole ticket fare. 😆 I went to the early evening show of Kaminey, and even so the cinema hall was good as full, only a few seats left. I hope the film does well here in the UK. 😃
Edited by -Yas- - 16 years ago
starchase thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: -Yas-

^^
I forgot my NUS at home, so has to fork out the whole ticket fare. 😆 I went to the early evening show of Kaminey, and even so the cinema hall was good as full, only a few seats left. I hope the film does well here in the UK. 😃

😆. i always have mine at hand. it is of sum good use 😆. i went to the evenin show. the cinema hall was around 75% full. got there early to grab the back row😆. i tink this film will do great aorund the world 😃
mz.jess thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
Reviews seem good, and such good words for shahid!
Im def going to watch this one for him!
Monu-SunNaa thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
Film Review

This swine is worth it

By Minty Tejpal
Posted On Saturday, August 15, 2009 at 02:31:06 AM


When you go to watch Kaminey, which surely you must, make sure you are well on time. For Kaminey is that rare Bollywood film in which you cannot miss even a minute, for you risk losing the entire bloody plot. Buy your popcorn, empty your bladders, switch off your mobile phones, and kindly switch on your brain. You are about to get on to a rollercoaster cinematic ride that will leave your heart pounding, your senses breathless and your morality shaken. For Kaminey speaks a fresh new international cinematic language, very dark and film noir, mean and sharp, yet firmly rooted in Mumbai, quite like its director, who I happen to know well. Please be informed, lest you think I have a vested interest, that I worked with Vishal Bhardwaj on The Blue Umbrella, whose script I also co-wrote.

True to its title, Kaminey is a film about ruthless bas****s, except that the treatment is pure thoroughbred, establishing Vishal Bhardwaj as the most complete auteur in Bollywood today. Vishal is a writer, music composer and director, and in Kaminey he whips all three skills into a gritty crescendo, churning out a mean broth that leaves you with a chilling high. Vishal's earlier films have always had a bias for edgy, negative protagonists, which is how most real people I know are, as opposed to the goody goody, saccharine sweet types we usually see on screen. The duplicitous twins Chunni/Munni and witch Shabana Azmi in Makdee, the unforgettable Irrfan mian and Pankaj Abbaji Kapoor in Maqbool, the crooked shopkeeper, Pankaj Kapoor again, in The Blue Umbrella, the beguiling bahubali Saif Ali Khan as Langda Tyagi in Omkara, and now, well, each and every character in Kaminey.

Starting with Shahid Kapoor, the boy has finally grown up. After doing endless candy floss roles in a series of forgettable films, Shahid essays a challenging double role, with grit and finesse. In the character of Charlie, the small time horse racing bookie with a lisp and a deadly dream, Shahid puts in a powerhouse performance filled with a reckless, smoldering intensity, like that of a lover scorned in real life. Most remarkably, he manages to look and sound very different as his estranged twin brother, Guddu, the shy do-gooder with a hesitant stammer, who is about to get sucked into Charlie's life, a whirlpool of drugs, deceit and death. The Khans better make some space, for yet another blockbuster Kapoor just announced his presence.

Priyanka Chopra has deservedly emerged as one of the top female stars in this country, and in Kaminey she once again shows you why. Playing the role of Sweety, a simple Maharashtrian girl in love with Guddu who also happens to be the dreaded Bhope bhau's sister, Priyanka is sassy, sparkling and incandescent in every scene. In a film which is full of the choicest bas****s belonging to the male species, Sweety is spicy and chaalu enough to leave her own special chhaap. Most refreshingly, it's great to see a non- vamp woman character first lead the way in bed, then con her way into marriage and finally grab a stengun and attack her own vile brother. Whoa, way to go, girl.

Like a classic caper film, Kaminey is a sharp, slickly plotted yarn filled with shady characters, furious action, corrupt cops, destructive coincidences, dead bodies and double crossing deviants. The story is quite basic, but the telling of it is very in ventive. The dialogue writing is razor sharp, the music beautifully scored with old hit songs weaved in cleverly, the production design and action sequences are well detailed, the cinematography gives the film a Hollywood look, but its in the editing wherein lies the real triumph of Kaminey. Kaminey socks you with two disparate stories set in the span of 24 hours, with no build up or background whatsoever. Wham, bam, thank you damn. If you are smart enough to understand it that is good, else there's always Vashu Bhagnani playing in a theater close by. Kaminey doesn't compromise in its telling, not for a minute, so the audience had better keep up. Amazingly, the sharp edit holds the madly plotted action together.

Finally, every character in Kaminey acts brilliantly and leaves a distinct, individual impression, which is simply amazing, considering most of them are first timers. Just as Nasseeruddin Shah and Om Puri were reason alone to remember Maqbool, and Konkona Sen Sharma reason enough to relish Omkara, similarly Bhope Bhau, Mikhail, Tashi, Lobo and Lele are each haraami enough to make Kaminey memorable. Of them, Amol Gupte and Chandan Sanyal are outstanding. Kaminey is not the typical commercial family film, but that's fine, because I am not sure if the classic Indian family exists any more, except in television sets. A majority of India is teeming with a restless youth, yearning for something different. Well, this is it. Tarantino gave Hollywood Pulp Fiction, and now Vishal Bhardwaj gives Bollywood Kaminey. It's the new standard of cutting edge cinema, and it rocks all the way. Dhan te nan. Damn, just can't get the tune out of my head.

https://www.mumbaimirror.com/article/30/20090815200908150231065469124d7a7/This-swine-is-worth-it.html
Edited by -Yas- - 16 years ago
Sharad K. rocks thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: -Yas-

Ah, the movie is GREAT! 😃 Kaminey is a movie you'd like to go watch again though gangster flicks are not my thing, but Kaminey is an exception, editing is tight so no unnecessary dragging, the direction is so good, especially liked the end sequence when Charlie stakes the guiter/cocaine to save Guddu and Sweety, and the bad guys Chief Thode & co running for their life. The background score was cool & edgy. Fantastic acting by Shahid, and Priyanka was impressive too, good light comic timing in the scene where Sweety tells Guddu that she is preggers with Guddu's child. Sweety is just adorable character. To cut the story short, the movie is very good, well worth the 7.50 I paid, 😉I recommend to watch the film on big screen, where you can visually appreciate some of the high paced sequences. I loved the character of Mikchael>>>nutter!, shame about his end. Lastly, Priyanka-Shahid's chemistry is amazing, they lived up to the hype surrounding their chem.

I wish VB has included the Pehli baar Mohabbat ki hain song seq in the the final cut of the film.

He cut the song!!! NO!!!
naadanmasakalli thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
Dhan-e-tanna Shahid HaS ARRIVED with a bang- Kaminay Review
Ok let me start this review with saying that it's the Best film of this year so far even better then New york .so my top films for this YEAR as of yet now are Kaminay and Newyork.

So as many of us know that Shahid is playing double role in this film as Charlie and guddu the twin brothers; each having a speech defect. one stammers while other lisps.Charlie is a horse race bookie cum a small gangster while guddu is a sweet innocent harmless boy who works for an NGO and is in Love with his girlfriend sweety ( priyanka chopra) who's sister of a local gangster politician called Bhope bhau ( amole gupta).Amole Gupte does not want his sister Sweety to settle down with Guddu, who is a non-Maharashtrian. He can not stand the sight of her sister playing love game with a non-Maharashtrian .

On the other hand, Charlie has stolen some cocaine from the custody of corrupt cops, Lobe and Lele; and searching for buyers with the help of his friend mikhail to get rich quickly. In this effort, he makes enemy of both crooked cops and drug lords. Though Charlie and Guddu can not stand each other but by a strange twist of fate get involved in each other lives during a rainy night. due to the fact taht they r twins and a misunderstanding guddue reaches police station while Charlie gets with politician, Guddu ends up facing gangsters and crooked cop. To end this confusion, the twin brothers—Charlie and Guddu must meet.Thereafter Charlie and Guddu face the big bad world of drug, mafia, guns etc. Their life becomes a struggle against gangsters, corrupt politicians and corrupt cops. How they overcome all these difficulties and what happens afterwards forms rest of the story.

Now coming to the performances i guess saying that this is the Career turning role for shahid Won't be wrong. He is the show stealer without a single doubt.He did full justice to both the roles and made them so real and beleiveable. I am so happy that vishal showed his faith on shahid and casted him and shahid didn't let him down Boy oh Boy Shahid has finally arrived with this and He should dominate all awards next year for his amazing performance. He proved his genes and also that if given in right hands he can very well be the next No 1 Star. Personally am so happy that finally with this he's gonna get his due which was long overdue. Me Loved this dude in his lovey dovey characters too but this has to be something just too good.i still can't choose if i likk charlie better or guddu . if guddu is sweet then charlie is Sexy or how he would say it Fexy :D.

Priyanka chopra is Fab in her role . let me tell you am not a priyanka fan but she was amazing loved her as sweety. again a brilliant performance personally i liked her more in this than fashion but that's just my opinion. she was more realistic in this and her chemistry with shahid is awesome.

the rest of the cast is perfect too.

Now coming to the real hero of the film which no doubt has to be Vishal. his direction is SUPERB. Storytelling is just way different and amazing. He has successfully managed to bring Hollywood style of narration to bollywood with this different, dark, and violent film.Though Vishal takes time (around twenty minutes) to establish his characters, which is necessary in my opinion,but once this period is over, the viewer is transported into the world of 'Kaminey' completely. His one liner in the film score point and keep the viewers glued to their seats till the end. The music is already a hit and Brilliant. personally i am in love with the entire album which rarely happens. my fav tracks has to be dhan tana and kaminay . the lyrics and vishal's voice is so touching . it makes u think round of applause for that.

Best scenes
Honestly i can't choose because the whole film is Perfect; but if i really really have to choose one i'll choose the scene where guddu tells sweety about his past and also the scenes between the twin brothers towards the end and also the train scene oh Btw did i mention the scene where charlie saves guddu? what brilliant acting by shahid as both guddu and charlie it makes u very emotional.

Problems: there r infact no problems with the film except that i think vishal should have added Pehli baar mohabbat in the film itself then to show it with end credits that's the only thing i didn't liked about it .


I'll rate it a 4.5/5 it's highly recommended to everyone me probably will watch it again over the weekend it's just so good u feel like watching it again.
RiyaK09 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
Raja Sen's Twitter:

Whoa I hear people are driving from Bombay to Nasik and Vapi to watch Kaminey. Dhan te nan Impreffive dedication!

Related Topics

Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: Elvis12 · 4 months ago

https://youtu.be/AKF2whlGnr4?si=E1A4YKtjsoPGt333

https://youtu.be/AKF2whlGnr4?si=E1A4YKtjsoPGt333
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: priya185 · 2 months ago

Baramula reviews (netflix show) with Manav Kaul...

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 2 months ago

Thamma Screening Today Reviews might be out soon https://x.com/filmfare/status/1979562615383982364...

https://x.com/filmfare/status/1979562615383982364
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 2 months ago

https://youtu.be/ifV6o-uvAfI...

https://youtu.be/ifV6o-uvAfI
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 3 months ago

https://x.com/taran_adarsh/status/1968593840941813931

https://x.com/taran_adarsh/status/1968593840941813931
Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".