Originally posted by: shinningstar
my answer no
when ali started provoking gautam :-
sam - said don't go so low but then when ali spoke to her saying its task she kept quiet and went and sat near upen. plus she took rahul away who tried to help gautam a bit .agreed she was feeling bad and refused to insult gautam but she cud have told ali much more strongly to shut it instead chose to go inside the house .when fake suitcase prank was on sam told pritam its empty don't leave ,she didn't tell gautam,obviously he will be hurt. he knows her from what 6 yrs.
rahul- he told gautam ignore kar and then when sam took him away he went leaving ali to target gautam would he have left if it was dimpy instead of gautam? NO! . wud he have not provoked pritam if it was dimpy instead of gautam! you have your answers whether he "supported" or not.
mehek - she was the only one who cared for gautam . gave him blankets food kept talkin to him so he doesn't fall asleep , didn't listen to ali and went on supporting gautam, when she went in to sleep gauti felt she too left leaving ali to target him and when she told him so he understood and said sorry.
upen - being sanchalak its his job to ensure provoking is done but doesn't get personal but he let ali cross the line..would have ali ali or anyone say anything if it had been tanna in the cage?. he was busy flirting with tanna in corner and smiling ,gautam was looking around and he felt upen was laughing at ali's crass comments but maybe upen was laughing due to his flirting with tanna thing all tht lovey-dovey crap. good thing the confusion got cleared between him and gautam . but y the hell is upen still in the house? i m starting to think he's bb ka jamai !
dimpy - i wudn't blame her being a girl standing for good 24 hrs and then getting pizza by bb was disappointing and bad joke by bb. but she was drained and needed well deserved rest. however she was the only one who pointed out tht it was disgusting of ali to pass such comments and had he said same to a girl hell wud have been raised so y such gender biasedness. she was geniunely upset and concerned seeing gautam cry.though she had a fall apart from gautam due to pritam i feel deep down she truely cares for gautam like a sister and her anger towards him initially was because he chose pritam over her. plus before she cud take a stand for gautam, rahul took her away.
karishma - the only girl who told ali to shut it on his face in loud and clear voice and gautam acknowledged it too tht she was the only one who stood for him. but she could have provoked pritam and didn't so i feel her support was just to look gud on camera and avoid grilling on weekend
pritam- telling ali say on camera its fake and then u have freedom to do anything . allow ali to pass such crass remarks to gautam ( the guy u call ur younger brother) wow aisa bhai naho toh better hai. when ali was saying such disgusting things pritam cud have said once ali! stop below belt matt kar. aisi jeet mujhe nai chahiye jo isiski izzat uchhal ke mili ho...he would come out looking like a true hero and i bet gautam wud have left the button for him to win too but pritam did no such thing to top it he started trying to defend ali and himself hitting a new low altogether.
it was obvious that non of the hms provoked pritam and in name of task were insulting/targetting gautam. he too knew that non of his so called friends even made an attempt to provoke pritam or truely supported gautam and it was just gonna get more dirty. as he rightly said its obvious that for money they'll stoop to any level so he stepped out when all were gone in a hero style. he cud have stayed much longer as ali's provocation didn't work . plus saying he wanted to go to loo so he came out was bs..as camera showed he went into bathroom but didn't go into the loo . he was taking out his clothes towel etc and avoided talking to ppl ...it was only when dimpy said it was disgusting what ali said that the dam broke - as after all he's human and one can take only so much.
edit to add this
what hurt gautam most was ali said !!if for money then perform in the house !!basically saying if u want money then strip for us in the house we will give u money!!! and no one said say thing to stop ali!! its shameful and highly degrading to anyone and totally not acceptable be it task or to otherwise