Originally posted by: Silveraliax
If you think Jasmine would have attacked him without the barriers, then even hypothetically we can say rahul may have attacked them with knives without gauhar. Both are assumptions.
Jasmine was wrong full stop but rahul is not completely innocent either.
In the matter of the task itself rahul is innocent, he did the task as it was set. There are no ifs and buts IMO, she is whiny loser.
For the knives thing yes he is wrong no doubt.
As you yourself said, the assumption she is making about him, it applies to her as well as she too was actually physically aggressive and violent in a non task environment and could have potentially even launched at him.