swapnil999 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
Sorry if I offend anybody,but now I really can't stand the drama and fake things in this show.
First of all,I will introduce myself.I'm a historian and have interest mainly in the study of materials related to the Moghul empire and 15th-17th Century.I have read Akbarnama and other books,even many of Rajputs and visited places like Agra,Udaipur,Chittorgarh and many others to know more info from local people.
I understand that a historical show does show some fictional things but this show is crossing the limits.Even Jodha Akbar has many fake stuff but NOT to this extent .So let me start-

1.Pratap and Akbar never had a teen rivalry.And it might shock some of you but the truth is that THEY NEVER MET EACH OTHER IN THEIR ENTIRE LIFE.

2.Akbar's main target was Udai Singh and he did not give a damn about pratap. Whereas in the show Akbar keeps thinking about Pratap and does not even think about Udai Singh who is the king of Mewar.

3.What the heck?Akbar keeps roaming in in enemy's territories and moreover nobody even knows!!!You does not have to be a historian to see how stupidly fake it is.

4.Akbar goes all the way to his enemy's territory to propose Phool Kunwar?SO FAKE MY HEAD IS ACHING

5.At this stage of life,Akbar didn't even thought about Mewar..!He was busy reconquering all the territories lost from his empire because of his father's death.The frustration of doing this was the main reason Akbar was cruel in the early stages of his reign.

6.Right now Akbar is taking all the decisions and he is always rejecting Bairam Khan's advice.The truth is that Bairam Khan was responsible for almost all the decisions made in the early stages of Akbar's reign.When Akbar grew older,he thought that Bairam Khan is having too much power and that was the reason he dismissed him from his court.

7.A few weeks back,Pratap's Guru and 10-15 of his students defended the main gate against opponent's army which comprised about 1500 soldiers.When all of them died and Pratap entered,there were still about 1000 people left.So Pratap and an injured guru killed all those people!!!This is just plain stupid and fake.

8.too many fictional characters like BURGA KHAN,GAUHAR JAAN, etc etc.I think its just too much

9.Akbar enters Marwar's army and nobody notices?JUST STOP

10.Nothing like that duel happened to decide a war.And in those times,in midst of all the tension,it was just impossible to give a king his kingdom back after defeating them AND that too the king allows the prince to take the final decision??That was just plain stupid.

11.Pratap was 2 years older than Akbar.In this show,it is just the opposite.

12.However brave and strong Pratap might be,currently he is just about 17 years old and he is defeating an impossible number of soldiers who got years and decades of training.
If he was that strong,why did Mewar even need an army?

13.Where are the other members of Akbar's inner circle?Like his milk brother Adham Khan and Ruqiya Begam(he married her at the age of 9)?

14.Pratap's younger brother Sagar Singh is missing.He plays an important role in the battle of Haldighati.

15.Udai Singh was a cruel ruler completely different of what he is shown as in this show.
16.In the recent episode,Jaiwanta Bai and the other queens found Veerbhai in the area where the Marwar queens were.Really they travelled this much distance on foot?And how the hell were they allowed inside that Marwar area?And even that when these two states are on war?Sorry,but the logic is completely flawed.
More points upcoming in the future.

Seriously,this show is taking the height of stupidity to a whole new level.

Edited by swapnil999 - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

4.5k

Users

14

Likes

34

Frequent Posters

cherrycola thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
I dun know abt most of the points bt the fact that Pratap is only 14-15 now is wrong .. he is 17 and at this age he married Ajabdeh . And it's taking height of stupidity to new level in ur language , so pls I request you nt to watch and if u want to present ur views, mind ur wrds pls.
Edited by shanz_sejal - 11 years ago
MaxMayfield thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Hehe its alright, no need to say sorry for offending, nobody would be, unless CVs are bhatakti aatma's here😆
yeah the CVs have gone nuts🤪, most of us on the forum know most of the points above...but thanks for putting it in one place😊
its just that Vishal and Faisal are popular as Jalal and Pratap - so CVs are cashing in on their popularity...so till they dont have a point to take leap...we will have to bear bland khichdi with mindless twists and turns
I guess the factual accuracy will only be shown after leap...but till then enjoy the kids while they are here - coz they are a talented bunch - and I havent seen such good actors in a long long time! all are rockstars - Faisal, Roshni, Vishal, Jannat👏👏😛 CVs ko aur history ko maro goli...coz uska kucch nahi ho sakta😆
PS - and please no need to bring in JA show...we dono what happens there and we dont care...if this post was intended to put JA in a better light than MP...then lets not even compare...MP has impeccable production values and overall styling, editing, direction, acting is solid and class apart...!
Edited by Hiral_Halwa - 11 years ago
MaxMayfield thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: shanz_sejal

I dun know abt most of the points bt the fact that Pratap is only 14-15 now is wrong .. he is 17 and at this age he married Ajabdeh . And it's taking height of stupidity to new level so pls I request you nt to watch and if u want to present ur views, mind ur wrds pls.

oh yeah, he most likely is 17 on the show right now😳
Jyotimena thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
All the so called 'Historic' shows are like this only. So chill and Watch it for entertainment:)
for history , you can watch documentaries
-Magnanimous- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
Chill! i guess you need to meet CVs in person 😳
swapnil999 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
sorry for that age mistake,I will edit it.
Just think,if a new show begins on the life of Mahatma Gandhi and the show shows incorrect things like he was secretly planning an attack on the british,what would happen?There would be protests all over the country and it would not be allowed to air on tv because it gives incorrect information about his life.Why not the same for this show and other historial shows?Not everybody knows the truth and most people believe that the things shown in the show are correct.This would only lead to ignorance in the future generations.

Just to clear,I really like this show and the amazing acting of the kids.Don't think I am against it.
And Jodha Akbar is like a completely different show and I like it equally,maybe more but i am in no way biased towards any of the shows.

cherrycola thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: swapnil999

sorry for that age mistake,I will edit it.

Just think,if a new show begins on the life of Mahatma Gandhi and the show shows incorrect things like he was secretly planning an attack on the british,what would happen?There would be protests all over the country and it would not be allowed to air on tv because it gives incorrect information about his life.Why not the same for this show and other historial shows?Not everybody knows the truth and most people believe that the things shown in the show are correct.This would only lead to ignorance in the future generations.

Just to clear,I really like this show and the amazing acting of the kids.Don't think I am against it.
And Jodha Akbar is like a completely different show and I like it equally,maybe more but i am in no way biased towards any of the shows.


this is 400 year old show and Mg's show will be 100 year [roughly] from now and we have clear evidences abt this in diff. forms of media so there wud be no mistakes in that and as fr Mp .. we need to make assumptions sometimes
bitblue thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
i have also read somewhere akabar never fight (and no one let him to do too) with pratap in any war because his life was more precious.
now to portrait character all this masala needed. they way jalal character is going sure CV will show how chittor was badly destroyed by akbar. akbar is know as the akabr but not in young age.

if they will show straight from book no one will understand this show and no one will watch.

i dont want to talk about JA either as i did honestly try to watch that show so many times as i like jodha she is beautiful but always fail to digest rest of it.

shrinath thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: swapnil999

Sorry if I offend anybody,but now I really can't stand the drama and fake things in this show.

First of all,I will introduce myself.I'm a historian and have interest mainly in the study of materials related to the Moghul empire and 15th-17th Century.I have read Akbarnama and other books,even many of Rajputs and visited places like Agra,Udaipur,Chittorgarh and many others to know more info from local people.
I understand that a historical show does show some fictional things but this show is crossing the limits.Even Jodha Akbar has many fake stuff but NOT to this extent .So let me start-

1.Pratap and Akbar never had a teen rivalry.And it might shock some of you but the truth is that THEY NEVER MET EACH OTHER IN THEIR ENTIRE LIFE.

2.Akbar's main target was Udai Singh and he did not give a damn about pratap. Whereas in the show Akbar keeps thinking about Pratap and does not even think about Udai Singh who is the king of Mewar.

3.What the heck?Akbar keeps roaming in in enemy's territories and moreover nobody even knows!!!You does not have to be a historian to see how stupidly fake it is.

4.Akbar goes all the way to his enemy's territory to propose Phool Kunwar?SO FAKE MY HEAD IS ACHING

5.At this stage of life,Akbar didn't even thought about Mewar..!He was busy reconquering all the territories lost from his empire because of his father's death.The frustration of doing this was the main reason Akbar was cruel in the early stages of his reign.

6.Right now Akbar is taking all the decisions and he is always rejecting Bairam Khan's advice.The truth is that Bairam Khan was responsible for almost all the decisions made in the early stages of Akbar's reign.When Akbar grew older,he thought that Bairam Khan is having too much power and that was the reason he dismissed him from his court.

7.A few weeks back,Pratap's Guru and 10-15 of his students defended the main gate against opponent's army which comprised about 1500 soldiers.When all of them died and Pratap entered,there were still about 1000 people left.So Pratap and an injured guru killed all those people!!!This is just plain stupid and fake.

8.too many fictional characters like BURGA KHAN,GAUHAR JAAN, etc etc.I think its just too much

9.Akbar enters Marwar's army and nobody notices?JUST STOP

10.Nothing like that duel happened to decide a war.And in those times,in midst of all the tension,it was just impossible to give a king his kingdom back after defeating them AND that too the king allows the prince to take the final decision??That was just plain stupid.

11.Pratap was 2 years older than Akbar.In this show,it is just the opposite.

12.However brave and strong Pratap might be,currently he is just about 17 years old and he is defeating an impossible number of soldiers who got years and decades of training.
If he was that strong,why did Mewar even need an army?

More points upcoming in the future.

Seriously,this show is taking the height of stupidity to a whole new level.


You are right. Many incidents shown in this show did happen but they have been misinterpreted by the makers of the show.

First they showed that after the second battle of Panipat was one by mughals Hemu is being brought in front of Akbar & Akbar in anger beheads Hemu. But in reality Akbar was just 11 or 12 years when Humayun dies, & yes Mughals win the battel but Akbar wont kill hemu himself. Akbar was a kid then Bairam Khan insist him to kill but Akbar wont give in & finally Bairam himsielf kills Hemu in front of Akbar.

They show Akbar ordering Bairam khan what to do, but according to History till he crosses 18 or 19 Akbar donsenot even involves in any of the problems related to empair. He never steps of the well protected Agra fort till then. You are right Akbar never meets Pratap personly even ones. In this they show Akbar meets rPratap they both become thick friends. Yes Akbar dose comes to meet Meera Bai thats historic fact.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".