MP forum is silent again :( - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

1.5k

Users

13

Likes

33

Frequent Posters

Serena.V thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#11
I am a silent reader but this post maks me speak up. I have stopped watchimg MP because the childeren are not screenig together. Because of the kids they charmed me to watch MP and now not anymore. I am not interested in a track with war, so i keep away from MP. 😊
_aashi_ thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#12
Actually the show for most fans got its charm with PrAja. Now we don't even get to see Ajabde, that's why the forum is silent and also because the cvs have dragged the story from Monday. Only few people watch the war with heart. Maharana pratap' s life was dedicated to motherland so the viewers have many wars to go thru...so this can be ultimate reason.
One more reason is war is 100 percent a fake one. Akbar got ajmer in 1559 but the current time period is 1557 or so. Akbar has already got it. But PrAja fans like some of us are still here. Hope we get to see the marriage too.
If this happens the show will earn its lost charm from fans. But for me, even wars are interesting.
Penkie06 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#13
I m really sorry if i m d only one who thinks so... bt i don't really get why do we expect a PrAja scene to happen each an every day???? Yes I agree tht a luv story always garner attention bt tht doesn't mean tht d lyf story of MP will b d love story of MP only... Fights n battles r wht made him d maharana n not his love story... Of course his grand wedding will b shown...bt why not take interest in d war tracks? After all we use 2 luv MP even before ajabdeh's entry... Right?
Joyness thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#14
I do know that Pratap life is known for his warrior skills then love life but nonetheless the cvs by giving importance to phool and making ajab cold to pratap have butchered what could have been a soulful love story...they can show war ..the cvs are showing a phool who is so deeply in love with pratap and a ajab who is so cold that she has forgotten to cry and emote..fans are not liking cvs distorting history initially the distortion were far and few but now its completely new MR which is not historically correct and with so much..info on net fans know the history...
And most important. ..MRP forum has most school going students and or college students with schools and colleges reopening ..naturally there is less activity .but may be praja romance can increase activities. .it is human nature to love romance generally. ..but those of us who are still remaining lets keep the forum BUZZZING...
Edited by jyotic74 - 11 years ago
_aashi_ thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: jyotic74

I do know that Pratap life is known for his warrior skills then love life but nonetheless the cvs by giving importance to phool and making ajab cold to pratap have butchered what could have been a soulful love story...they can show war ..the cvs are showing a phool who is so deeply in love with pratap and a ajab who is so cold that she has forgotten to cry and emote..fans are not liking cvs distorting history initially the distortion were far and few but now its completely new MR which is not historically correct and with so much..info on net fans know the history...

And most important. ..MRP forum has most school going students and or college students with schools and colleges reopening ..naturally there is less activity .but may be praja romance can increase activities. .it is human nature to love romance generally. ..but those of us who are still remaining lets keep the forum BUZZZING...


right said, i myself am a school student . like others i too want the PrAja marriage soon. i know this can increase the activity on the forum
Deepika.31 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Kaushitaki

I m really sorry if i m d only one who thinks so... bt i don't really get why do we expect a PrAja scene to happen each an every day???? Yes I agree tht a luv story always garner attention bt tht doesn't mean tht d lyf story of MP will b d love story of MP only... Fights n battles r wht made him d maharana n not his love story... Of course his grand wedding will b shown...bt why not take interest in d war tracks? After all we use 2 luv MP even before ajabdeh's entry... Right?


I completely agree with that!!! We were fans of the Maharana Pratap himself, in fact most of us may not have even known the full history of the love that blossomed between Ajabde and Pratap before the track was introduced in the serial. I feel like every serial nowadays needs some sort of romantic affiliation in order for the discussion to be booming, but we have to remember that it is a historically based serial and it is set up in a way that cannot focus entirely on romance.
_aashi_ thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: Deepika.31



<font color="#ff6666">I completely agree with that!!! We were fans of the Maharana Pratap himself, in fact most of us may not have even known the full history of the love that blossomed between Ajabde and Pratap before the track was introduced in the serial. I feel like every serial nowadays needs some sort of romantic affiliation in order for the discussion to be booming, but we have to remember that it is a historically based serial and it is set up in a way that cannot focus entirely on romance.</font>


I completely agree. I even love the wars and the romance too. Actually the cvs have done so many twists that no one now has keen interest as before. Too many twists spoil a show. They should know. Some people just miss PrAja! That's it. The life of his wasn't a love life, this is something we all should know. Actually we usually never get personal life of any warrior that's why people get so much...u know mad over it when the track comes to that part .
mukta08 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#18
Hey Janvi...sorry but i completely disagree as lots of changes hve taken place that is no where mentioned in the history for eg.
1. Phool entering pratap life so soon
2. The war btw mewar n marwar hppnd after praja marriage
3. Akbar entering the scene n people already calling him akbar though he was named it later n Jalal was his real name

There are many other flaws too but i dnt wish to go deep iylts jus my opinion i did mean to hurt nyone's feeling...thogh i am loving the fightet and stategist pratap but would hve njoyed more without that phool drama no offence to anyone guys...
Penkie06 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: aashna_siddy


I completely agree. I even love the wars and the romance too. Actually the cvs have done so many twists that no one now has keen interest as before. Too many twists spoil a show. They should know. Some people just miss PrAja! That's it. The life of his wasn't a love life, this is something we all should know. Actually we usually never get personal life of any warrior that's why people get so much...u know mad over it when the track comes to that part .

thank god! At least some ppl think like me...
Deepika.31 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: mukta08

Hey Janvi...sorry but i completely disagree as lots of changes hve taken place that is no where mentioned in the history for eg.

1. Phool entering pratap life so soon
2. The war btw mewar n marwar hppnd after praja marriage
3. Akbar entering the scene n people already calling him akbar though he was named it later n Jalal was his real name

There are many other flaws too but i dnt wish to go deep iylts jus my opinion i did mean to hurt nyone's feeling...thogh i am loving the fightet and stategist pratap but would hve njoyed more without that phool drama no offence to anyone guys...


I understand that completely. I can point out many flaws in the storyline, myself.

1. Rao Surtan Singh, (we still remember him, right?) ruled Boondi from 1531-1544. Pratap was born in 1540. How then could he be fighting Rao Surtan Singh in his early teens?
2. Phool Kunwar being best friends with Ajabde, when Ajabe is in Bijolia which is roughly near Bundi and Phool is from Marwar. That distance is roughly 300 km. And Rao Maldev really let his beloved granddaughter spend such an extended period of time at a Mewadi Samant's house? Come on.
3. If the timeline of the story is correct, then Ruqaiy Begum should be introduced in Jalal's life already because they were married in 1551 and our storyline is somewhere in the late 1550s area.

But there are historical accuracies in the plot as well:
1. Ajabde Bai was the daughter of Ram Rakh Panwar, the Panwar at the end of their surname indicates that they are from the Agnivanshi clan of rulers, which typically did not have superior positions in the government. Hence her father in the serial is a, although I hate to say it, mere " Samant of Ranaji.
2. Although it was not nearly as soon as the serial portrays it, the reasoning behind Phool and Pratap's marriage is accurate. When Pratap did bring home his 6th wife, Phool Bai Rathore, it was for political alliance only.

There are historical inaccuracies with the serial, but let's be honest. Who, other than a few loyal fans, would watch a TV serial that religiously followed the historical storyline. It is history after all and not everyone enjoys it. In addition to that a lot of things in history are not recorded, so the CVs get the chance to experiment with possible fillers to the track.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".