myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
I have a few clarificatons if anyone can answer
1) Where did Akbar meet Meera Bai in chittorgarh fort or Dwaraka? I had read somewhere dwaraka city(Krishna's place) went into sea and is currently found near dubai in arabian sea. Another important point Akbar won Gujarat in 1570 and Mewar never owned Guajarat-Dwaraka. so how come both are going to Dwaraka an enemy state?
Rated as one of the seven most ancient cities in the country, the legendary city of Dvaraka was the dwelling place of Lord Krishna. It is believed that due to damage and destruction by the sea, Dwaraka has submerged six times and modern day Dwarka is the 7th such city to be built in the area. Dwarka is on the Arabian sea coast, and Bet Dwarka is in the Gulf of Kutch.
2) Did Pratap really go to call Meera Bai? (I have never read anything like this anywhere in history)
3) Meera is daughter in law of Karnavati and Rana Sangha. If that is case how Karnavati can be shown alive in serial?
Because Udai Singh himself said that because Humayun did not come on time to save Karnavati she did jauhar. There is a famousd Raksha Bhandan story behind this that she sent rakhi to humayun calling him brother to come and help. But Humayun was in war in some deccan region and came late and so she did jauhar. Then Humayun arrived and defeated Bahadur Shah and gave the kingdom back to Vikramaditya. Here they show her as alive and suhagan both when Vikramaditya is king.
4) Why Akbar said he promised Humayun to defeat Mewar?
As far as i know Humayun never had any enemity with Mewar. He considered Karnavati as sister and even when Babar had defeated Rana Sangha he helped Karnavati by saving her life from the cruel Afghan soldiers. He saved another Queen and her family too hence he got Kohinoor as gift from them. So suddenly how Akbar saying Humayun told him to defeat Mewar? Humayun was friendly with Mewar and it was he would made Vikramaditya and Udai Singh kings by returning their kingdom from Bahadur Shah
5) This Rao Surtan is another mystery. Rao Surtan married Rana Sangha daughter as per history. So Udai Singh is his brother-in-law. So how come they are enemies? Secondly Rao Surtan was dethrone in 1544 and how Bairam Khan and he become friends when Humayun alive and not in India also then?
6) This Dheerbai ji is one more mystery. Some say she is wife some say cocubbine(not legfal wife).
Please can someone clarify?
Edited by myviewprem - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

2

Views

1.4k

Users

2

Likes

6

Frequent Posters

bitblue thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: myviewprem

I have a few clarificatons if anyone can answer

1) Where did Akbar meet Meera Bai in chittorgarh fort or Dwaraka? I had read somewhere dwaraka city(Krishna's place) went into sea and is currently found near dubai in arabian sea. Another important point Akbar won Gujarat in 1570 and Mewar never owned Guajarat-Dwaraka. so how come both are going to Dwaraka an enemy state?

its hard to match up all historical facts i have stop comparing 😆
but in 1546 US do send message with few brahmins to meera and reluctant meera do come back home but stays in krishna's temple. Akbar comes to chittor temple (that is what i can get from net) once rana knows this news ask meera to do jal samdhi.
Rated as one of the seven most ancient cities in the country, the legendary city of Dvaraka was the dwelling place of Lord Krishna. It is believed that due to damage and destruction by the sea, Dwaraka has submerged six times and modern day Dwarka is the 7th such city to be built in the area. Dwarka is on the Arabian sea coast, and Bet Dwarka is in the Gulf of Kutch.
2) Did Pratap really go to call Meera Bai? (I have never read anything like this anywhere in history)
3) Meera is daughter in law of Karnavati and Rana Sangha. If that is case how Karnavati can be shown alive in serial?
Because Udai Singh himself said that because Humayun did not come on time to save Karnavati she did jauhar. There is a famousd Raksha Bhandan story behind this that she sent rakhi to humayun calling him brother to come and help. But Humayun was in war in some deccan region and came late and so she did jauhar. Then Humayun arrived and defeated Bahadur Shah and gave the kingdom back to Vikramaditya. Here they show her as alive and suhagan both when Vikramaditya is king.
4) Why Akbar said he promised Humayun to defeat Mewar?


yes but humayu wanted to rule complete India it was her dream
As far as i know Humayun never had any enemity with Mewar. He considered Karnavati as sister and even when Babar had defeated Rana Sangha he helped Karnavati by saving her life from the cruel Afghan soldiers. He saved another Queen and her family too hence he got Kohinoor as gift from them. So suddenly how Akbar saying Humayun told him to defeat Mewar? Humayun was friendly with Mewar and it was he would made Vikramaditya and Udai Singh kings by returning their kingdom from Bahadur Shah
5) This Rao Surtan is another mystery. Rao Surtan married Rana Sangha daughter as per history. So Udai Singh is his brother-in-law. So how come they are enemies? Secondly Rao Surtan was dethrone in 1544 and how Bairam Khan and he become friends when Humayun alive and not in India also then?
yes i wonder that too.

6) This Dheerbai ji is one more mystery. Some say she is wife some say cocubbine(not legfal wife).
Please can someone clarify?

myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Thanks
Edited by myviewprem - 11 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".