Crime of highest order - Page 7

Originally posted by: muskiii

I admit maya has done a lot of terrible things and she deserves to be punished for that and the points you mentioned above do make her a criminal but what about saanjh, she killed an unborn baby by manhandling a pregnant women( it is still not shown that it was fake or not )you will say it was just an accident and stopping (requesting) an eye witness from coming to court being a lawyer is a CRIME
Vandana: did she not mentally torture maya by throwing garbage at her slapping her(by mistake), telling to go back to her paagal khana. This is also a criminal offence

Originally posted by: anshvi

Yes Vandana was wrong - Agree

Saanjh deliberately killed the child - Disagree

How can u be sure that that it was deliberate.Of course i will say that it was an accident coz that is the logical explanation

Saanjh asking Samay not to come to court was wrong - Agree

But whether it will be termed as a criminal offense or not I can't comment coz I don't have complete knowledge about this specific law.

Here one also has to consider that She had 'asked" and not 'forced' or 'obstructed' Samay not to appear...It was Samay's free will too to not appear in court as well.

Here both were at fault

Originally posted by: muskiii

I didn't say it was deliberate. We all saw it wasn't deliberate, my apologies for not writing it correctly.
Here both were at fault- totally agree

Originally posted by: anshvi

Pl correct me if i am wrong but Saanjh can't be termed as a criminal for Maya's miscarriage coz it was an accident, unintentional and in no case deliberate

Originally posted by: Y12345

No one is above the law. Even if according to you, Maya is a psycho, cheater, killer etc - she does not deserved to be raped. No one can take law in his or her own hands so Ayaan attempt to rape cannot be justified at all even if Maya drugged Arjun( that's another crime )

If I follow your logic, people who rape girls sometimes do it because for example they wore short clothes ( which is a crime for them) and so they want to punish that girl and rape her. However bad a girl is in your opinion. you don't have the right to rape her.

Originally posted by: muskiii

what she did was extremely wrong and as far as her being criminal is conserned just becoz Arya hasn't filed anycomplaint against her she isn't less

And i found this- Whoever causes death by doing any rash or negligent act shall be punished with imprisonment, which may extend to two years, or fine, or with both

Originally posted by: muskiii

what she did was extremely wrong and as far as her being criminal is conserned just becoz Arya hasn't filed anycomplaint against her she isn't less

And i found this- Whoever causes death by doing any rash or negligent act shall be punished with imprisonment, which may extend to two years, or fine, or with both

Originally posted by: ---Khushi---

Correct...So who has raped whom in Beyhadh ???

Everyone here knows it was physical assault n not rape...What's the point of writing big theses on rape when no rape has taken place...

N when it's proven that it was a fake rape accusation by Maaya, I hope all members ripping Ayan apart come forth n admit their folly...