Difference of Mahi and Zoya - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

2.7k

Users

17

Likes

98

Frequent Posters

Prriyam thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: enlightenme

I don't agree with you. Zoya protecting Mahi just proves that a woman's fake virtue is of more worth than the truth of two innocent. Here I used the word fake because whatever Aditya wanted to say was the truth and not some false accusation against Mahi. Maybe that's her problem, just don't co- operate in the case and put evrything on Aditya and the Gods up there sitting in the sky. Do emotional blackmail by saying hume aap pe pura bharosa hai. Like seriously u don't support my truth in the court and here I'm ready to accept death sentence for you.



This has got me thinking! (Am very confused). Yes, she wasnt ready to say the truth, at the cost of creating issues for those who trust her and support her. Shd it be a case of remove a thorn with a thorn, give more pain to correct the pain etc.,

I am also wondering, will this back and forth mus-slinging just complicate and not help with matters? (To start with, am still finding the premises of the arguments faulty and not sustainable for muder!)
DivI10 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#12
As usual your post made the episode better for me when I was thinking that something is missing and the most waiting Promo scene was too short

and Zoya got me pissed off like girl don't be this good I know she is Zoya not Maya but still.. anyways end of the day everyone loves Zoya so okay..
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#13
Thanks Meera
@Priyam that's how Zoya is build. You cant change her principles.

@Nerdgal Zoya's stand might not win Mahi. But if she can take Madhu Mahi is weakened.

@Happy hippy and maryam Zoya was not asked to talk about the insurance. Both Adi and Mr Hooda asked her to tell Mahi had proposed Adi, he has rejected it and she is taking revenge. One thing you need to know here. Yes she agreed to Adi. Told Adi had rejected Mahi. Public prosecutor will argue the whole proposal was fake. Because apart from Zoya on whom the accusation is put there is no other witness for that proposal. Public prosecutor can easily argue that Mahi proposing Adi is a made up story by Zoya as vendetta. I was surprised how the so famous lawyer Mr Hooda even agreed to put Zoya on the stand and make that claim. If I was defense lawyer, I would have put Mahi on the stand and cross examined her and took that proposal out from her mouth along with Aditya's rejection and then defended my client a personal vendetta is happening.😆😆

@geet you can bring revolution through love, and it will give much peace.

@Miksi yes I was happy she stood by her principles.

@zooni blue her parents themselves have given her that nurture to stay by her principles

@enlightenme I have put the logical flaw in putting Zoya and getting the statement from her. You cant have the aggreived part throw mud at the accuser without having a neutral witness. It will bounce back badly in a court of law. It was good Zoya listened to her heart.

@joy, priyam, divya I have how things have bounced if Zoya tried to attack Mahi.
Life_Is_Dutiful thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#14
Shruti, I respect ur pov but I still feel Zoya was wrong today. First of all, Mahi betrayed her on their fake marriage itself by bringing Madhu there and making her believe in AdiYa affair.

Secondly, today Mahi was proving in the court that Zoya is a characterless woman. If Zoya had let Adi say that Mahi loved him and he rejected her so she is doing all these, frankly speaking, there wouldn't have been much damage to Mahi's reputation except for the fact that she is a lier. But Mahi calling Zoya characterless is the biggest ever accusation on a woman's dignity.

Madhu also knows her daughter is a lier yet she still supports her so it's not like Mahi-Madhu relationship would have been broken.

What if Madhu had not overheard the conversation and would have said that Zoya was indeed having an affair with Aditya and both of them killed Poosh? Then both of them would have got punishment for the crime they didn't commit. Then Zoya also would have been blamed for not defending herself. After all, she wouldn't have lied like Mahi. Whatever she would have said would have been complete truth.

I feel one shouldn't be too seedha. Zoya got lucky that the woman who slapped her in front of the media and called her characterless said in the court that she is not a murderer.


shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#15
When I was analyzing Ek Hasina Thi there were many who told why Durga was planning and plotting. She should have reopened the case and fought again. But I had mentioned then that Payal had changed her statement that Shaurya didnt rape her. So to get a conviction it was imperative for Durga to get that confession of rape from Shaurya's mouth itself. Her whole game was to reach him and make him confess that crime.
if the confession didnt come from Shaurya his defense lawyer will make use of the loophole of change of statement by Payal and somehow bring him out.

Same is Zoya's case in second thought. There is no neutral witness to Mahi's proposal to Aditya. A good lawyer will negate that theory itself in the absence of a neutral witness. You will say injustice , but sadly that's how the court functions.

And it was good Zoya listened to her heart. Else it would have backfired and Madhu also would have told whatever Mahi has taught her.
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#16
@Tulips " what if " part. This is where I say it is a philosophy which I believe and it has delivered to me umpteen times. But I wont tell someone need to believe in those " What if's". Because it cannot be explained, it can only be experienced.
Nerdgal thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#17
I know that that Mahi will never be won. She is a crack pot like that. She is not a woman who sees the nice in anyone.
manny136 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#18
good post
also adiya r the only witnesses to mahis love confession n them being the defendants does not make them reliable witnesses so even saying this in court would be hearsay while mahi has pictures to prove her claim. This was mostly to make madhu change her mind anyway.

I never expected zoya to use this against mahi so wasnt shocked she said what she said and adi i think 50% chance he would lol ppl dont get so upset.
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#19
Yes manny there is no neutral witness and hence zoya testimony won't stand the scruitny of cross examination. Zoya wouldn't have thought all this when she decided to listen to her heart. But that listening did give her a favourable testimony from madhu.
Edited by shruthiravi - 7 years ago
rs-shailu29 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#20
shruti ur analysis was right ...
i read ur analysis i get the different angle ..
i was angry with zoya but never realized her real intentions ..


ur right zoya has a strong personality which many won't agree but end of the day they will eventually

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".