Nikkah pe Nikkah?

Page

Next Last

HeavenlyBliss

@heavenlybliss

Viewbie

+ 71

Posted: 11 years ago

Not that I am complaining about ZaYa's Nikkah scene, because I loved it but...

A second Nikkah is not allowed!!!

Even though they used different names, they still did the Nikkah infront of witnesses when they are already married. According to Islam, a second Nikkah over a first of the same couple is strictly forbidden as it makes the Nikkah invalid.😕

Quote

Frequent Posters

raisa ahmed

@Raisa-

Inactive

+ 5

Posted: 11 years ago

Really?? Never hard of that before and I am
A Muslim.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Emaani.95

@Emaani.95

Dazzler

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

I am a muslim but I never heard of any such thing!

Are you sure?

Quote

Nayab

@luv_virman

Dazzler

+ 6

Posted: 11 years ago

Yes you're right dear.

Indeed it is true

Quote

SyedaFaiza

@SyedaFaiza

Voyager

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

As a muslim i believe i can't trust anything like this

Unless u gv ma a hadees or ayat complete reference.

Nikah pe nikah nhi ho saktaa...

Ager aurat kisi aur shaka se shadi kre.

Jb k wo already married ho.

Esa army jihad ya plane crash incidents me hoaa he

K husb ka ptaa na lg saka

Aur aurat ne iddat poorii ker k nikah ker liyaa dosra.

Mgr is pe bhi kuch controversies hain.

So i don't believe k nikah fasiq / khatam ho jata he.

As koi vald hadees ya ayat nhi prhii mene.

Quote

SyedaFaiza

@SyedaFaiza

Voyager

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

Is there anyone who read Peer-E-Kamil ( A Pakistani Urdu Novel )??

Its written by a well known Muslim Novel Writer

In that novel in d end

That man married d same girl Amnaa

As he cm to know that his wife is dead.

Plus d girl married d same boy

As her father in law told her that her husband is dead.

Both of them got married to each other

Without knowing d fact that they r marrying d same one again.

Moral of d story it does happen

& i nvr heard about nikah fasiq etc.

Give me hadees or ayat references please

Quote

balismis

@balismis

Beginner

Posted: 11 years ago

Is there anyone who read Peer-E-Kamil ( A Pakistani Urdu Novel )??

Its written by a well known Muslim Novel Writer

In that novel in d end

That man married d same girl Amnaa

As he cm to know that his wife is dead.

Plus d girl married d same boy

As her father in law told her that her husband is dead.

Both of them got married to each other

Without knowing d fact that they r marrying d same one again.

Moral of d story it does happen

& i nvr heard about nikah fasiq etc.

Give me hadees or ayat references please]

i have read the novel😊,you are right they get married again at the end,i dont think there was any controversy regarding their remarriage.also i havent heard of any hadith or ayat about this matter so i dont think its forbidden.just my thought 😊

Edited by balismis - 11 years ago

Quote

HeavenlyBliss

@heavenlybliss

Viewbie

+ 71

Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: SyedaFaiza
Is there anyone who read Peer-E-Kamil ( A Pakistani Urdu Novel )??
Its written by a well known Muslim Novel Writer

In that novel in d end
That man married d same girl Amnaa
As he cm to know that his wife is dead.

Plus d girl married d same boy
As her father in law told her that her husband is dead.

Both of them got married to each other
Without knowing d fact that they r marrying d same one again.

Moral of d story it does happen

& i nvr heard about nikah fasiq etc.

Give me hadees or ayat references please

I have read that novel, in that case it was allowed because she thought her husband was dead and he didn't know that its the same girl who he married before.

But a Nikkah done twice intentionally with the same person is not allowed. I have heard this from many scholars and searched about it too when I read this novel

but let me see if I can find a source relating to it.

Quote

Sunshine

@SunShine_A

Trailblazer

+ 6

Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: HeavenlyBliss.

I have read that novel, in that case it was allowed because she thought her husband was dead and he didn't know that its the same girl who he married before.
But a Nikkah done twice intentionally with the same person is not allowed. I have heard this from many scholars and searched about it too when I read this novel
but let me see if I can find a source relating to it.

But this wasn't intentional, was it? Circumstances made them remardy otherwise they had not gone with intention of getting married but to remain in place and find Barkat they had to don themselves as bride and groom and ultimately get married

Quote

..Razia..

@..Razia..

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#10

I actually never heard that !

But my mom actually told me the opposite one day
She was talking and was like whenever a girl goes to her mom house
For a few days when they come back like its
Good if they like do a Nikaah again , I don't know
She said it a different away and I kinda forgot !
But yeah it's not against Islam to get married to the same
Person twice 😳

Quote

1 2

Nikkah pe Nikkah?

Related Topics

Explore Topics