What is Mangala so scared of? DTN pg 27 - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

255

Views

10.9k

Users

18

Likes

676

Frequent Posters

Shinya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#41
Dr. anant is available to anandi whenever she needs help. Even when her daughter is upset, he takes her to his house.

Jagya drives her when her daughter runs away. Jagya was the one who found her daughter.
What has anandi done so far ? The real weakling is anandi who does nothing on her own other than shedding tears.
Shinya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#42
Yes, agree that the Dr. Smita, or whatever her name, did tell anandi to not tell the truth to Nimboli.

But who told her not to tell the truth to Shivam?

Why is she playing with his psyche ? I am sure it is not shivam's good but her own.
fast trak thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#43
Mangala hasn't used Devi avatar just to protect herself from Akhiraj. She also used it for her own pleasures. That means she was always a manipulator but she was able to use her full colours only now. Akhiraj being the more dominant one suppressed her and only when he left she was able to express much better
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: aparnauma

M only told her doubts about Akheraj's involvement in her husband's murder which the lady didn't believe.

But she never told about Akheraj's behaviour towards to her to anyone.It started from the time she entered the house as a newly wed.She didn't tell her husband also.

Because she never told him off in no uncertain terms he was emboldened and his ignorance and belief in Devi act was a temporary deterrent and he just took her silence as acceptance of his feelings for her and fear of society from accepting his advances.


@bold - it was in 9th May episode - M told Chagni that she told everything to her MIL who scolded her and asked her to agree to Akheraj. It was before she faked devi. Even on the night she faked devi first time - it was in distress.
Stephi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: Missesha


Well but it has been proven that Anandi cares for her image and fear of rejection through many scenes in the show. That is a FACT and not assumptions, similar to those highlighted in bold 😛



If Anandi doesn't care for image , then what is it exactly that stops her to tell the truth? What exactly is she waiting for?
Amol's parents lost their son. They were searching for him for so many years. They too must have feared of their son's rejaction if and when they find him ( something that happend by the way.)
Yet they had enough courage . determination and most important the need and desire to make understand their son that he wasn't abandoned,thrown in the garbage, that it was just an unfortunate set of circumstances. Even if the child's decision afterwards is to stay with his adoptive parents,somewhere in child's mind comes a relief due to the fact that he was not unwanted. Although heartbroken because they once again lost their child, this time by his own choice,Amol's parent complied with his decision for the sake of his happiness.( same as Bhago did for Anandi's happiness- although the case was different but purpose was the same, a child'shappiness) Amol's parents were heartbroken but to their son they gave a heartsease because he finally found out , no matter how and why but he wasn't abandoned.

So no doctors , no Mangalas,no one in this world could stop me to tell the truth to my child. Even if my child will hate me for ever. Even if my child rejects me. Even if my child chose a person who cared for him/her for so many years . I would like my child to know that he/she wasn't abandoned, that I loved and did all possible to find him/her. But maybe Anandi can not tell all this. Because it would not be true. First , she has not lost her child accidentally, she was aware of the danger. Even if she wasn't experienced , she was warned by the police to put her child in a safe. And then according to what was shown and what we saw, she did almost nothing to find her daughter. So the conclusion is that she cares very much for image .In the meantime, her daughter can continue to live with belief that her own mother didn't want her. And this is not Mangala's fault. It is Anandi's own fear and inability to face neither the truth of her own mistakes nor the consequences.
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#46
Amol's parents' example is so apt. They told the truth - faced their child's rejection gracefully, considered his attachment for the adoptive parents and retreated voluntarily. And this when Amol's association with his adoptive parents was for a few years only (may be one or two - BV timeline is never clear) - and here the girl has been brought up and has known only Jhalra people all her life. Creatives think making Mangala bad will automatically make Anandi right - it is not so - people will judge Anandi for her actions no matter what other character are doing.
fast trak thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#47
It was because Amol got s lot after living with Anandi. Not just luxury. When I say got a lot means s good life and lot of love. He got cured. Proper education and a great childhood .
Can't compare Anandi's upbringing to Mangala's. Oiling hair and singing lullabies is not just what kids need. I'm not saying anything about luxury here.

Forget the schooling, Nimboli went through a torturous life when she was living with Mangala. Mangala wasn't responsible for all of the torture but she could do little to avert it.

She couldn't fight and give Nimboli even a decent life and yet Anandi is blamed for losing her child amongst flying bullets.

Mangala had no bullets to fight yet she failed terribly then what for is she claiming rights on the child? Was the child living there to cook and clean for them? What has Akhiraj family given Mangala's so called daughter that she is still considering them as her family? What is Mangala giving Nimboli other than lies that she is claiming to be her mother?

She thinks she has won by taking her to Jhalra. But has she? Nimboli was a baby and didn't know much so she went through the pains of the torture but she's not such a baby anymore and can't be easily fooled by fairy tales that Mangala is going to narrate every single day.
Edited by fast trak - 9 years ago
fast trak thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: Shinya

Dr. anant is available to anandi whenever she needs help. Even when her daughter is upset, he takes her to his house.

Jagya drives her when her daughter runs away. Jagya was the one who found her daughter.
What has anandi done so far ? The real weakling is anandi who does nothing on her own other than shedding tears.


If she was so weak she would've revealed the truth by now to Nimboli and relieved her pain. It needs a lot of strength to see your daughter call someone else maa and even more strength to be able to let go of your child along with that maa. Weaklings can only run away from strong people because they can't fight.

Mangala is a weakling she can't fight Anandi and hence she ran away from there😆

Mangala goes crazy every time Anandi is around Nimboli because she can see Anandi and her magnetic power around Nimboli. 😆
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#49
Mangala and Anandi are not comparable in terms of what they could give to their adoptive child. Their circumstances were entirely opposite and the way the child came to their life also was so different. Amol was like a social service project for Anandi - while M risked her own life to save Nimboli. I already mentioned in many posts that comparing what the child had in Jhalra with what she could get with Anandi is like comparing what a child gets in Indian home to some developed countries. Many Indian parents have to loss their children to State Authority and put in foster care because Indian and western standard/idea of nurturing a child is so different. It cannot be said that Indian parents do not love their children - mothers make their girl child help in household work, help in raising younger siblings and even work in fields - girls as young as 9 years old - work as maid while living with their parents - no one says that the mother is not doing anything. The child will get what the parents can provide.
fast trak thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: SPuja

Mangala and Anandi are not comparable in terms of what they could give to their adoptive child. Their circumstances were entirely opposite and the way the child came to their life also was so different. Amol was like a social service project for Anandi - while M risked her own life to save Nimboli. I already mentioned in many posts that comparing what the child had in Jhalra with what she could get with Anandi is like comparing what a child gets in Indian home to some developed countries. Many Indian parents have to loss their children to State Authority and put in foster care because Indian and western standard/idea of nurturing a child is so different. It cannot be said that Indian parents do not love their children - mothers make their girl child help in household work, help in raising younger siblings and even work in fields - girls as young as 9 years old - work as maid while living with their parents - no one says that the mother is not doing anything. The child will get what the parents can provide.


I'm not talking or comparing Anandi providing Amol agains Mangala's ability to provide. I only compared in context to the earlier post.


I agree mothers who work as maids carry their children along and make them help. But still they strive to provide the best and try not to make their children become maids like themselves.
We have seen Nimboli cooking and cleaning the house for the entire family. We have seen her fetch water and shop for grocery for the entire household. Mangala could've taken the load off her and shouldered her work but she didn't. Nimboli made food and tea etc and served her Teesa while her Teesa sat and ate it while narrating her stories. After a tired day of work when she came back Teesa oiled her head for relaxing. Can you see the difference that I'm talking about?


There is child labour still existing in the country but that's where there is a need to earn daily bread. Totally different from Nimboli story. For Harki Nimboli was brought in as a maid and she utilised her fully to that extent. Mangala did nothing much to prevent that. Either she should've totally protested it or stopped it from happening or tried to get in touch with someone who would've redeemed that child from her misery. Any of these acts would've made me respect her and made me say yes today Mangala has s valid point and stands s chance to claim her right over the child.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".