Fundamentally wrong - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

73

Views

4.4k

Users

14

Likes

192

Frequent Posters

hisusmita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#51
Enough has been said but I know one thing for sure. Had Anandi did exactly the same thing what everyone is saying. Had she said no to Sarita and went back home to leave her kid, Pooja would have ended up as Kundan's beendni and would have undergone everything what N went through.

They would have fled seeing the police , just the way Sarita's in laws were not tracable

One thing would have happened then also, Anandi bashing would have continued the way it is going on.

We have seen in news papers also, Child marriage in maximum cases have to be stopped when it is happening., otherwise it becomes difficult later on o prove. Whole village lies as if nothing happened. Had Sarita taken her later on they would have proved her mentally ill or something just to prove nothing happened or fled away.

It was easy in Urmi's case as there was proof of the marriage. If she knew about Urmi's marriage at the time when it was happening she would have gone there to stop it.

No mothers harms her kid intentionally
leavesandwaves thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#52
Now we need an exclusive anandi bashing thread very urgently! Instead of every thread turning into one.
saba113 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#53
Wow what logical criticism of Jagya
Since Anandi was and is criticized for being careless with Nandini , Unwisely handling Pooja's child marriage issue , her daughter paid the heavy price of it but since Anandi is criticized for her mistake so Jagya should be criticized too .even though he made no mistake like Anandi nor him taking Nandini with him right now is comparable to Anandi taking Nandini with her during Pooja's child marriage but since Anandi is criticized Jagya should be criticized too Thats it No other logic , sense or reason just because Anandi was /is criticized for her that mistake that automatically makes Jagya culprit without any mistake like that 😆😆Impressive logics 🤣
leavesandwaves thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#54
Why Jagya cant be criticised when he is committing some mistakes? There is logic in my argument and many tried to break that logic but failed.

His taking Nimboli, a minor with him to a dangerous place is illegal. As an MLA, he should take legal means.
ButterflyOnRose thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#55
Lols how Anandi 's stand during Pooja's child marriage is as same as Jagya's stand now ?

Anandi had no reason to take her infant daughter there . Anandi had better options for her to stop the child marriage and keep her daughter safe too Anandi was not in so much tight situation like Jagya is now that she had to take Nandini with her She could send Nandini back with the driver when she had reached the marriage location , she could leave Nandini in the car or even when the gun battle started she could run away with the baby instead of hiding behind the pillar and watching the scene in front of her but she acted complete foolishly , no proper planning even with so much of experience of facing troubles in stopping child marriages , she was reminded by ira and the police cop she has a baby with her but she listened to none and she jumped in the well with her daughter ,she got saved but her baby daughter got drowned in miseries

Here Jagya is not responsible for Ganga's kidnap Badri and Akhiraj played their cards well and kidnapped Ganga . Jagya is trying to save her He tried other methods to save Ganga but it did not work so he is left with last way to give Akhiraj the bait which he demanded from him to catch Akhiraj and save Ganga He has not taken Nimboli with him insisting himself In fact its Nimboli herself wants to go . Nimboli's mother herself wants to help in this and Jagya has a full plan with him He is just throwing a bait towards Akhiraj to catch him and free his wife from his clutches For Jagya protection of everyone Ganga , Mangala , Anandi , Nimboli all are important and as per the segment he will save all because he has a plan but Anandi ?did she even for once think about her daughter's safety during Pooja's child marriage? No

Anandi gets the blame for acting so wrongly Jagya is not doing same so he cannot be blamed same way
Edited by BeatifulSoul_ - 9 years ago
saba113 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#56

Originally posted by: leavesandwaves

Why Jagya cant be criticised when he is committing some mistakes? There is logic in my argument and many tried to break that logic but failed.

His taking Nimboli, a minor with him to a dangerous place is illegal. As an MLA, he should take legal means.

Lols when i said Jagya cannot be criticized if he does same mistake but you are here forcefully putting mistakes on his head to give clean chit to Anandi for taking Nandini with her in pooja's child marriage This you openly admitted in this thread yourself
i ask you Why Anandi cannot be criticized if she does some mistake ? why Jagya has to be criticized forcefully putting mistakes on his head just because Anandi was criticized ?han?

where is logic in your post that you are claiming here many tried to break your great logic but failed ? Your logic is failed from very the start because there is no logic

now you want Jagya to take legal means ? Aren't you the one who had problems with him reporting Ganga's kidnap At that time you were criticizing him why he reported it himself He is an MLA he should just sit and send others to do work on his behalf ? Great logic was that 🥱

and Jagya is taking legal means where he is out of legal means ? In this situation now even police would be doing same They are throwing a bait towards Akhiraj to catch him and free Ganga and Jagya is not himself taking Nimboli with him Nimboli's mother herself is taking her daughter with her along with Jagya so why not question Nimboli's mother on it instead of blaming Jagya for it ?
Edited by saba113 - 9 years ago
ButterflyOnRose thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#57
Had Jagya taken abhi , Mannu ,shivam with him too then he gets the blame but Nimboli is demanded by Akhiraj This is the last option Jagya has , He has no other option left , Nimboli herself wants to go , Nimboli's mother is going with him with her free will and taking her daughter too and Jagya has a full plan to protect everyone He did not leave without proper planning so i wonder why we should blame Jagya ,criticize him ?


Edited by BeatifulSoul_ - 9 years ago
Stephi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#58
@ One's child is one's property and no mother does anything intentionally to harm her own baby. If something happens to the baby, it is due to unavoidable circumstances. Nobody has any business to poke their noses between such a personal matter.

Mannu is Ganga's son and she did nothing intentionally to harm her own kid. As a matter of fact everything she did was to protect him.(Ratan's story) So what was Anandi's business to poke her nose between such a personal matter?As far as I remember Ganga was crucified for a simple question: with what right you made a decision regarding my child.
''One's child is one's property ''-I will not even comment on.

@His taking Nimboli, a minor with him to a dangerous place is illegal.

So Anandi's taking Nimboli ,a six-month old baby to a dangerous place is legal ?

Criminal negligence is the failure to use reasonable care to avoid consequences that threaten or harm the safety - in this case of her own baby. But I see, it cannot be applied to Anandi firstly because she is flawless,secondly Nimboli is her property . Only, what if six month-old Nimboli was killed by a stray bullet , then what ?Wouldn't she be liable for her child's death?



Stephi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#59
@ Anandi called up police before she reached there.
So it is not like she went there without taking precautions.
She did tell Ira that she feels it will not be dangerous because police would be there

So what was so urgent and necessary for her to stand there that too with the sick child in her arms? I mean, the police would be there doing its job.
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#60
Back to the topic
Jagya was wrong when he tried to use Kundan to put pressure on Akheraj.
If Mangala used that tactic it is understandable because she has no other means to fight someone like Akheraj
But Jagya is a representative people and he is answerable to people and the power he has today came from peoples' support. Akheraj may be a criminal and Kundan may be a kid with a perverted mind but still detaining Kundan by using his power is wrong.since the boy has no connections with this particular case except that he happened to be the son of the kidnapper


But here he is using people whom this forum considers as random people but he considers as his family and he has not asked them but they are doing it for him and Ganga out of their own free will.
This is not correct but here he is not using his power but only taking what has been offered to him.

What ever said and done exchange of people is fundamentally wrong.






Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".