Clouds are gathering - Page 9

Created

Last reply

Replies

113

Views

5.2k

Users

13

Likes

214

Frequent Posters

731627 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#81
Hope this assumption clear in today episode or tomorrow episode
Sup123 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#82

Originally posted by: surabhi01

pooja should have gone to gynae instead of waiting for mannu calls .she could have go with friend bindiya or pooja did not know whom to consult when there is pregnancy related problems or due to tension she forget to consult gynae[?]I don't know how moral support will help in healing pregnancy related problems


Her last call to mannu was shown to make her a victim of mannu. In fact the whole mannu ignoring pooja thing was shown only to make her victim otherwise miscarriage could have even happened without mannu ignoring her but then how cvs would justify pooja as victim and slapping Mannu as you know Colors(Rangeela channel) is a Sanskaari channel of India and they can't show women as culprit in such cases 😳
731627 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#83
if cvs show only mannu is at fault in whole case and there is no fault of pooja then. it will be wrong part of cvs to show that like jagya show manu that he is wrong in same way Sarita should make pooja realize she is also wrong
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#84

Originally posted by: umam

For all the slapfest that is happening in BV and is going to happen, there is one very crucial thing that I want the writers to show. Until now, they have not shown Mannu and Pooja even for a second looking back on what they did, how they lied to their parents, their behaviour reeked of arrogance, emotional threats and blackmail 😡. M-P must introspect..

Am wondering about the reason that writers did not want the knowledge of MP's baby to become public -- was expecting writers to explore how it will impact the personal and public lives of Ganga, Jagya and Anandi.. Did MP track become a hot potato to them too hot/uncomfortable to handle?

I think miscarriage is a safer way out of it to avoid the debate on right and wrong in going for abortion.
Debate between what is right and wrong between people who support the rights to abort an unwanted baby an people who are anti abortionists and have a pro life stand.

Miscarriage and subsequent sterility equally effective and taking the story forward as far as Mannu and Pooja are concerned.Instead of being reluctant parents to an unwanted baby and facing consequences of it for the rest of their lives they will end up facing the repercussions of this for the rest of their lives.
731627 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#85
and I don't care whether pooja truly love manu or it is fake love because I think this age is for study instead of falling in love

Sarita could have make realize pooja ki is umr mein pyaar shadi ke chakkoron mein na pad ke if u have pay attention to ur study then this bad thing would have not happen to u
731627 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#86
no it is only mannu fault for ignoring calls which leads to miscarriage .ultimately treatment of pregnancy related problem that u should attend call .only moral support and atending call can treat gynae problems for that no need to go to gynae just keep waiting for husband to pick up calls for treatment of gynae problems
731627 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#87
pooja remember very well what mannu said to her .he ask her to abort baby she happily follow this .he say v will not abort baby she again happily accepted

but pooja cannot follow firmly anandi guidance that there is proper time for everything


Edited by surabhi01 - 10 years ago
Sup123 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#88
Supreme Court: A 24-week pregnant teen can abort if doctors permit The minor became pregnant after being allegedly raped by her doctor Jatin Bhai K Mehta when she had visited him after suffering from typhoid in February.
The Supreme Court Tuesday opened a window of hope for a 14-year-old rape victim, who sought its permission for termination of her pregnancy after 24 weeks. Currently, the law allows abortion only up to 20 weeks. Issuing a "flexible" order, the court left it for a team of doctors and a psychologist to take a call on whether termination of pregnancy was in the interest of the girl's life. The court said if they found that to be the case, she could go ahead with the abortion.
"We have the interest of the girl in our
mind. But we also know there is a life
inside her. We want to do something for
her and that is why we are
contemplating a way out. There is a
reason why we have included a clinical
psychologist in the panel. The girl's
mental health will also be considered,"
said a bench of Justices Anil R Dave
and Kurian Joseph.
It added that a doctor, who opined on
July 25 that the pregnancy can cause
severe medical complications for the
girl, will also be included in the panel of
medical experts, besides three senior
gynecologists of the civil hospital in
Ahmedabad.
Advocate Kamini Jaiswal, who argued
the petition moved by the girl's father,
said the teenager would go to the
hospital on Wednesday for the medical
check-up since her "trauma" has been
increasing with each passing day.
Last week, the Gujarat High Court had
turned down a petition by the girl's
father, citing the Medical Termination of
Pregnancy Act.
The Class X student was allegedly
raped by a doctor whom she had gone
to see while she was suffering from
typhoid. The doctor allegedly gave
sedatives to the girl and warned her not
to tell her parents.
The family got to know about the
pregnancy when she complained of a
severe stomach ache and was taken to
a doctor.
Referring to the law, the Supreme Court
bench said it cannot issue an order
allowing her to terminate the pregnancy
since that would be in breach of the Act.
"We understand her life has been ruined
and there will be social stigma. We can
acknowledge her pain and agony and
we want to help her. But we cannot do
it in violation of the law," it said.
The bench also took note of the fact
that the foetus has a life now and
questioned if "killing the child will solve
everything". It also asked Jaiswal if the
girl should give birth to the child, who
can be given up for adoption. But the
counsel said a 14-year-old girl cannot
be asked to bear a child and such a
situation will not only lead to immense
physical and mental agony, but may
also compel her to take an "extreme
step".
First Published on: July 29, 2015 12:00 am

indianexpress.com/article/india/india-others/sc-quashes-hc-order-allows-minor-rape-victim-to-abort-foetus-after-medical-permissions/#

@Aparna
there was no issue of right and wrong as law permits termination of pregnancy of less than 20 weeks. Even anti abortionists support teen abortion. It was couple's stupidity that they decided to keep the child in MP case.
anshurg5 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#89

Originally posted by: umam

For all the slapfest that is happening in BV and is going to happen, there is one very crucial thing that I want the writers to show. Until now, they have not shown Mannu and Pooja even for a second looking back on what they did, how they lied to their parents, their behaviour reeked of arrogance, emotional threats and blackmail 😡. M-P must introspect..

Am wondering about the reason that writers did not want the knowledge of MP's baby to become public -- was expecting writers to explore how it will impact the personal and public lives of Ganga, Jagya and Anandi.. Did MP track become a hot potato to them too hot/uncomfortable to handle?


Exactly my thoughts.

Before concluding this track by permanent damage coming to Pooja, they should have show what happened when PooJa realized Mannu has changed his mind and left her to deal with her reputation and pregnancy alone? Where their parents and Anandi stood when they became aware of her pregnancy? Who supported whom and how other school girls and villagers reacted to it?
In the end what solution they all thought best for this situation?

But they avoided to give these answers and curtailed the track by showing a miscarriage instead of a well thought abortion which might have saved Pooja from life long complications.
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#90

Originally posted by: Sup123

Supreme Court: A 24-week pregnant teen can abort if doctors permit The minor became pregnant after being allegedly raped by her doctor Jatin Bhai K Mehta when she had visited him after suffering from typhoid in February.
The Supreme Court Tuesday opened a window of hope for a 14-year-old rape victim, who sought its permission for termination of her pregnancy after 24 weeks. Currently, the law allows abortion only up to 20 weeks. Issuing a "flexible" order, the court left it for a team of doctors and a psychologist to take a call on whether termination of pregnancy was in the interest of the girl's life. The court said if they found that to be the case, she could go ahead with the abortion.
"We have the interest of the girl in our
mind. But we also know there is a life
inside her. We want to do something for
her and that is why we are
contemplating a way out. There is a
reason why we have included a clinical
psychologist in the panel. The girl's
mental health will also be considered,"
said a bench of Justices Anil R Dave
and Kurian Joseph.
It added that a doctor, who opined on
July 25 that the pregnancy can cause
severe medical complications for the
girl, will also be included in the panel of
medical experts, besides three senior
gynecologists of the civil hospital in
Ahmedabad.
Advocate Kamini Jaiswal, who argued
the petition moved by the girl's father,
said the teenager would go to the
hospital on Wednesday for the medical
check-up since her "trauma" has been
increasing with each passing day.
Last week, the Gujarat High Court had
turned down a petition by the girl's
father, citing the Medical Termination of
Pregnancy Act.
The Class X student was allegedly
raped by a doctor whom she had gone
to see while she was suffering from
typhoid. The doctor allegedly gave
sedatives to the girl and warned her not
to tell her parents.
The family got to know about the
pregnancy when she complained of a
severe stomach ache and was taken to
a doctor.
Referring to the law, the Supreme Court
bench said it cannot issue an order
allowing her to terminate the pregnancy
since that would be in breach of the Act.
"We understand her life has been ruined
and there will be social stigma. We can
acknowledge her pain and agony and
we want to help her. But we cannot do
it in violation of the law," it said.
The bench also took note of the fact
that the foetus has a life now and
questioned if "killing the child will solve
everything". It also asked Jaiswal if the
girl should give birth to the child, who
can be given up for adoption. But the
counsel said a 14-year-old girl cannot
be asked to bear a child and such a
situation will not only lead to immense
physical and mental agony, but may
also compel her to take an "extreme
step".
First Published on: July 29, 2015 12:00 am

indianexpress.com/article/india/india-others/sc-quashes-hc-order-allows-minor-rape-victim-to-abort-foetus-after-medical-permissions/#

@Aparna
there was no issue of right and wrong as law permits termination of pregnancy of less than 20 weeks. Even anti abortionists support teen abortion. It was couple's stupidity that they decided to keep the child in MP case.

Thanks for the information.
But all the same I am very well aware of the laws pertaining to abortion and under what circumstances MTP can be done according to the law and medical science.
The case that has been quoted here is a rape case as opposed to Mannu and Pooja's case where an under aged teen conceived after being in a relationship and the conception was a result of consensual sex.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".