leavesandwaves thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Nimboli's ignorance and Pooja's awareness.

They both present contrasts.

Nimboli may belong to certain females who are somewhat frigid. And they are not dumb just because they are not interested. Many girls get so immersed in studies that they dont have time for these thoughts at all. And then careers. I see many women not married because they are interested in other things like education, careers, social activism, taking care of old parents etc.
So I dont find Nimboli as anything dumb or too childish.

As for Pooja, she is a contrast. She fell in love and forgot her other responsibilities.Like education, career and her own mother. But basically she is a nice girl and that quality will help her in getting back to her education and career. And Mannu also is a good guy at heart.

In future I would like to see a strong bond between Nimboli, mannu and Pooja.

They are the future. They may commit mistakes but they wont commit crimes.
Edited by leavesandwaves - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

21

Views

1.7k

Users

7

Likes

45

Frequent Posters

GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Children develop curiosity about opposite gender etc when they are about Nandini's age and they may start getting attracted to them.
Lot of children do have means to satisfy their curiosity. Pooja goes to school and girls of that age in school if they are not talking about studies and school activities it will be about boys.

Then there is media which provides a lot of material like in case of Urmi.

But in case of Nandini where will it come from? Kamili was there earlier but she was too wrapped up in her own world to bother what 's happening.Only when that little got beaten up or starved or punished she would come to her help stealthily then Mangala she is more into satisfying her maternal urges rather than preparing her for life. Don't think there is TV at Akheraj's home
Nandini doesn't seem to have many friends too. Even if there are they are just like her who are trapped in this situation and their conscious mind is pre occupied by how to get through the day without scoldings. I don't know how many girls or for that matter boys whose mind is pre occupied with thoughts about how to see the end of the day will have time to experience attraction or have time to think about opposite sex.

It is not about childishness but more about disinterest. Nndini started thinking about these things only in context of her life. Kundan's touch makes her uncomfortable probably because she doesn't like him.She knows enough through what she has seen of Kamili and Gopal it needn't be like her and Kundan but beyond that does she have time to explore all these?Now she is seeing Urmi and Kundan who are husband and wife just like she and Kundan are she noticed that things are different with them.


Not every girl thinks about or gives into thinking about opposite gender when she reaches puberty. There may be a lot of girl who thinks lot of other things interesting rather than satisfying their curiosity.Some girls like Nandini don't have time or means and they only think of it when it come so close or close and bites their nose.

When a girl's life is how to make it though the day without getting into trouble boys will be far away from her mind.

Same thing goes about women who have responsibilities liking take care of chldren but with no means to support themselves or their dependents hardly be thinking about men and their feelings for men.They will be too pre occupied with securing their life rather than thinking about some man and falling in love with him.

-----------------
Pooja knows what is right and what is wrong unlike Nandini. But that is not enough to keep somebody from doing what is wrong. Strong will and determination or needed not to give in to temptation.

Nandini may not what is right and wrong she may not think twice about lying when it comes to saving others or stealing to satisfy her hunger or playing pranks on other who are behaving nastily towards people who are weaker than them.
But she does stand up for people who cannot stand up for themselves and face troubles for that.When she realises that others who are innocent may get into trouble because of what she has done she doesn't hesitate to own up for wrong deeds.

Pooja needs a strong will and Nandini is strongly in need of wisdom to show her the right way of doing things


The little girl needs some one like Anandi in her life even if she is not Anandi's estranged daughter
Edited by aparnauma - 10 years ago
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Nimboli's nature in itself is in contrast with her own behaviour. She talks sometimes as if she is 5 years old and at another time as if she is a grandmother already. I don't think Nimboli can be termed as frigid. Creatives just want to portray her as innocence. She is not immersed in studies - she is very well aware of the family dynamics - her own home - then her married friend, the ladies of the village she interact with routinely. Here I'm not even talking about her attraction towards opposite sex. It is about awareness about what marriage is all about (I so wish they do not make her wonder next how children are born - at least a few children may have born in the last few years). Girls in village society are generally more aware in these things because they have fewer opportunities such as studies, games etc. Their entertainment is more about interaction with fellow girls/ladies. Nimboli seems very artificial to me (not about actor - she is cute and is doing what she is asked to do).
Urmila to me seems to be more dumb than Nimboli. She is older - and it is funny how she knows about ritual not because she has seen it in her home/neighbourhood but because of TV 😆. Girls see these rituals whenever a new bride comes - but they don't announce it to her in-laws like Urmi was doing - her behaviour is like a foolish girl. And in her interaction with Nimboli (and once with Harki) is like a wicked girl.

Pooja is better than both Nimboli and Urmila. She behaves like her age in most things, knows about what is wrong and what is right. But her crush on Mannu and her behaviour like yesteryear's Hindi movie hero - who will follow the heroine till she says love you" was not good. Then this elopement - Mannu did not EB her - he asked her to come and when she raised her objections - he turned and was going alone. Similarly - she knows her own history - how she was once saved from bal-vivah, so her agreeing to elopement and bal-vivah seems very wrong. It is very different when a person do something without knowing it is wrong, or do something because he/she is of negative personality - but when a person who is not bad by nature and who is aware that something is wrong and still does it - he/she deserves more punishment. No sympathy should be shown towards Pooja for this elopement and marriage.
leavesandwaves thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
About how children are born. Most children are made not to ask such a question. and sometimes they are told the stork left them or some such things. Parents are too uncomfortable to answer such questions. Children are also told that they will come to know when the right time comes and now concentrate on studies.
As for Nimboli, she is a village girl but she is not mingling with girls who can tell her these things. I wish her friend atleast discussed these things with her.
Pooja may get punishment or not I dont know. Dadisa who committed far greater crimes was never punished.
leavesandwaves thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
If Nimboli meets a person like Gopal, she may fall in love.

leavesandwaves thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
Many married women in India just are passive and they keep their husbands away on some pretext after their children are grown up.

This maybe due to the fact that sexual behaviour is suppressed and viewed as something dirty and necessary evil.


SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
Nimboli is free to go any where - she interacts with other girls/ladies whenever she goes out. She can even ''punish her friend's mother-in-law. How can we say that Nimboli does not have anyone to discuss?
As for her falling in love - I would love to see for if they could show Nimboli getting free of this child marriage, leading a normal life and then marrying of her own will, not necessarily love marriage - but marriage without pressure from anyone. Falling in love and marriage is also good provided it is not laced with undue drama of opposition from family or a triangle (favorite of BV creatives).
leavesandwaves thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
Nimboli has only one friend of her age we have seen. That friend is worried about her torture. Where is the time to discuss these things? Now she wants to discuss these things with Mangala. Let us see if Mangala tells her something.
leavesandwaves thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
And how far anyone go in explaining these things without awakening unnecessary curiosity?


SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
Don't think Mangala will discuss such things - even mothers don't discuss in village society. One of the village ladies may discuss - Nimboli is too friendly with all of them - or was these scenes inserted to show how cute she is? Had she been confined to her home only - then we could say that she has no one to discuss. Creatives always show contradicting things.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".