Shame Shame - Page 14

Created

Last reply

Replies

180

Views

8.8k

Users

28

Likes

576

Frequent Posters

731627 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
mannu is naturally felt bad because jagya and ganga telling truth to mannu about ratan being real father just before when ratan body soon turn to be ashes , it is hurting to mannu that jagya ganga tell truth to mannu at that time when they were asking to lit pyre .it is very disturbing for mannu when suddenly mannu come to know ratan was his bilogical father and at same time he has to lit pyre of his father and then seeing his father body turn to ashes
731627 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
most people even adult faint when they seen their own one dead body turning into ashes at cremation ground
leavesandwaves thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
People go to any lengths to know their roots good or bad. Read Alex Haley's Roots.
jayshree1942 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
How can we forget that Mannu has chosen gun when he was small and Bimla came to meet him in bh.😉
731627 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
and how easily and suddeny ganga asking mannu to lit pyre .do ganga think is it very easy for son to lit pyre of his father that too suddenly ??
rohini55 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago


Some people (I'm using "some people" because that's seems standard reference for people not liked on the forum) will justify anything CVs do with respect to Anandi.

If CVs had shown a scene where Anandi talks about Shiv and his paternal family to Shivam, that would have been held up as a fantastic tribute to a heroic father by a mother and her way of instilling high values in her child.

Had the child said he wanted to be like his father, he would have been celebrated as the true son of a brave, honest father.

Because CVs haven't done this, they must be commended for not doing so and showing A and her son as moving on.

So from the certificate on the wall we must deduce that the child knows everything. If so isn't it surprising that there is never a reference to the father in any conversation?

Is talking about your brave, martyred father equivalent to building a Taj Mahal and pining for the dead and gone?

How awfully inconsiderate and insensitive this sounds.

Is it normal for all families never to talk of the most important member of the family even if he has been gone? I lost my father very early, but me and my siblings talk of him often. Are we all relics? Worse did we all grow up unhealthy?

Does talking about your father occasionally means you are unhealthily pining for him?. Nowhere except "some people" on the forum can say this.

Even assuming the certificate is enough for Shiv, where is any mention of the paternal family?

Is growing up without knowing your paternal family or hearing anything about them, the new definition of healthiness.


Well, I moved on and commended the cast, direction and execution of BV 2. That also is not acceptable to "some people".

It is impossible to please "some people":))))


Edited by rohini55 - 10 years ago
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
Anandi who is doing the kind of work she had been doing all her life irrespective of the status of her life the work which is in fact her identity she life gives her husband's name to it. She could have very well called Bhaili the way she wanted to be identified when she started Bhaili with her husband's help.
But she does her work under her husband's name.

If that is not love for her husband then what is it?

Is Shiv Niketan not a tribute to her husband? Then what is it?

Her identity her work and everything that she stands for now go by the name Shiv Niketan in fact her identity her home everything goes by the name Shiv Niketan . What does that mean?

I guess this is not a tribut, this is not her way of keeping her husband with her and his memories with her

Muktchand thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
Well agree CV never show Anandi telling Shivam about Shiv ... Only Shiv pic his certificate seen after moving in in SN
well If CV stop showing Kamli her detail story or her action then we can expect Anandi Shivam bond ...
lets see nobody justify CV ... No fan of Anandi accept Shiv's death either ...but what to do ... Move on is only option
Just like in initial days Anandi never express her feeling for Shiv openly ... CV took their time to show this thorugh Drug drama later on Palash track ...
so noone justify CV their antics ...but same time we can't say Anandi forgot Shiv through her CV too...
Shiv Niketan won't seen ... Neither his pic & certificate
Edited by blushing - 10 years ago
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: leavesandwaves

If Shivam comes to know how Jagya treated his mother in the wake of his affair with Gauri, shivam should hate Jagya too. So anandi should start injecting poison in the mind of Shivam against Jagya.
Unlike ratan, Jagya is not shivam's biological father but tormentor of his mother. His nanima died because of that ill treatment meted out to anandi.

I would love to see this
I am sure Shivam will park himself at the entrance and makes sure no one from BH will enter their home😛😆
Awfulggt thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
I won't say mannu is right. But a reaction is a reaction and that's a feeling. He felt betrayed seeing the sudden turn of events and this reaction is expected. Let his mom deal with it. I am just glad Cv's are not showing like mannu is right or his mother is right Like they did in some tracks earlier. Ganga took some decisions on mannu 's behalf so she will have to deal with the result.
I don't understand why J and ds are interfering now in trying to bring mom and son together. Firstly they were not allowed to interfere between mom and son just a few days ago when Ganga was stern about hiding truth. They left things to her saying it's her wish as he is her son. Why are they interfering now? Don't they know that it's only between mom and son now as well? Secondly Jagya and dadisa themselves are ex criminals who were not only forgiven by their abused but who are gifted with great careers , families and treated like God's of jester. At least for basic humanity sake they could understand ratan a little better... as he too redeemed just like them. They seemed to have forgotten their past completely. They are all set to tell half truth to a son about his own father. Forget about Ganga. She had always been selfish. Shame shame on ds and jagya.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".