Child labour - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

52

Views

3.9k

Users

11

Likes

142

Frequent Posters

ButterflyOnRose thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#41
How exactly people are comparing J and DB and declaring DB is less than him ? Amazing🥱 J has dumped Anandi but did not try to kill her He did not ask her to keep crying in the corner and never move on She could gather herself from that and move on and she did He did a lot of good of her too In fact saved her life too therefore she does not hold grudges against him and still is friends with him forgetting whatever bitter happened between them She did not sue him for bigamy because first of all no one know when that crime bal vivah became legal not even she and before suing him she had to sue her father Dsa , Bhairon Sumi a lot many for first committing a crime of Bal Vivah She let this suing go because she always hold Bal Vivah the root cause of whatever happened between her and J. First crime done to them was Bal Vivah which was later mess of everything For that Bal Vivah J is not responsible

but coming to comparing him to a potential murderer DB and decarling she did less harm to Anandi than J or even DS pretty disappointed that people can go this far too J and DS no one i have ever seen deliberately trying to take her life the way DB did . if that would not caught Anandi could lose herself forever it was luck only luck she is protected but amazing so even J was worst than DB too next from whom people are comparing him and calling him worst Ratan Singh, LPS , Saurabh These were also less than him if DB is Right?


leavesandwaves thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#42
Jagya had a love and hate relationship with anandi. while DB has only hate relationship with anandi.
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#43

The issues here are about Anandi's ways of dealing with family members and it is raised by people here.

What Dsa did to Anandi was violating the rights of a child in the name of tradition and yet she doesn't hold a grudge against her what Jagya did amounts to criminal offence against her and she could have filed a law suit but she didn't and that is a fact. Jagya didn't drug her but he constantly told her how she is not good enough to be his wife and the way he used to behave with her is very much there in the episodes.How Jagya's actions affected Anandi;s life was shown in great detail for almost 500 + episodes.The lady has forgotten to smile believing that there is something lacking in her and may be what she has done is not good enough and she spent so many years punishing herself believing that she was not good enough wife for Jagya Lawyer did inform that their marriage is legal and she can sue him for bigamy and she said no Bhairon Singh did want her to go and sue him.
DB was clear in her intentions too she wanted to show Anandi as someone useless and not fit enough to be part of Shekhar family.No where did she say she wanted to kill Anandi.
If Dsa and J damaged her emotionally DB tortured her physically.If she has chosen to forgive the people who have violated her rights why can't she forgive DB?I'm not saying that DB should be allowed to get away with it.
The fact is that be it Dsa J did a lot of damage and she did let them get away with it So did DB who caused damage to her health.The fact is she allowed to them to get away with what they have done to her.
---------------------------
The damage done by Dsa during childhood and the damage done on her by Jagya when they were young adults changed her entire life and did leave it's after affects on her and all those after affects on her just like DB's drugs did.
Drugs do get out of the system after a few hours and but damage done to young mind will leave it's lasting impact.
Yes she had Bhairon Singh and Sumi as a supporting system and she becomes the supporting system to all the Jyothis of the world.
The discussion was about what DB did is punishable by law or not What DB did cannot be punished by law. Whether Anandi did enough to contain her or not ,
Dsa put her down in the name of traditions J put her down in order to justify his adult choice DB trying to show her up to prove that she is not good enough to be part of the family.The damage they did is different.
I thought this thread is about discussing the current child labour track and not about Anandi or her marriage with Jagya and life in BH
But I guess the people are only interested in dissecting the past tracks and they who brought this topic about Anandi letting her family members getting away with offences.Dsa and J were brought up along with them Basant was also brought in to illustrate she didn't take action against people who have wronged her for XYZ reasons but always stood up for people who cannot defend themselves and she stood up against her own family members.It was just told in her defence that it was her choice not to take action against people who wronged her and it was not to be seen as sign of weakness but her way of handling things and her personal preferences and rights as to whether she wanted to punish them or forgive them.
She was not right when she let Jagya get away with bigamy because she didn't want Singhs to suffer and she was not right in forgiving Dsa for intimidating her during her childhood and nor is she right in giving DB a second chance because of Daddu.
All this was brought up because people keep saying that she forgives family members and jumps on strangers.It was just to show that she only discriminates based on who is at the receving end and not who is the offender.
If anyone of her friends also ended up having a souten just like she did she would have made sure that her friend got justice and made sure that her friend' husband and her friend's souten are locked away and that is the truth when it comes to Anandi's character.If she thinks the victim is helpless she goes all out and makes sure the victim gets justice regardless who the offender is.It has been that way right from the show started.
She didn't tell police that her parents did bal vivah but when Phooli was being married off during their child hood she landed there with police and that time she was only a child.
--------------
Anyways people seem to be only interested in discussing Anandi and not the current track and issues about child labour.This definitely defeats the purpose with which the CVs made this track🤢
Edited by aparnauma - 11 years ago
Missesha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: aparnauma

The issues here are about Anandi's ways of dealing with family members and it is raised by people here

The discussion was about what DB did is punishable by law or not What DB did cannot be punished by law. Whether Anandi did enough to contain her or not ,

But I guess the people are only interested in dissecting the past tracks and they who brought this topic about Anandi letting her family members getting away with offences.

All this was brought up because people keep saying that she forgives family members and jumps on strangers.It was just to show that she only discriminates based on who is at the receving end and not who is the offender.

Anyways people seem to be only interested in discussing Anandi and not the current track and issues about child labour.

Hi Aparna,
Sorry but I was quite surprised with your above comments and wondering as to why you would have any objection on what people are interested in discussing. After all, Anandi is a central character and is bound to be appreciated or criticized.

Again the topic in concern (child labour) is in association with the central character Anandi, whose behavioural pattern while dealing with criminals / wrong doers is being discussed.

Of course one point leads to another. But I don't see how it should end on "what people are interested in discussing"

I am the one who started the topic as I strongly felt that Anandi is easy on her family members and biased in dealing with wrong doers who are not family.

This is my opinion and POV, which may not be agreeable to others (and that is fine). But I do not think my opinion or my interest of discussion should be matter of objection to other members. Not particularly, after they have equally engaged themselves in the discussion.


-----------

The current was well executed and we all had already agreed to that. We had also discussed the potential of that track moving forward. And from there I moved to state my disappointment with Anandi's ability to handle criminals. For which I received a strong defense for Anandi, and finally the defender ends on a note "what people are interested in discussing". How is it fair?


Thanks.
Edited by Missesha - 11 years ago
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#45

Esha - You're right. Let's agree to disagree.

441597 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#46
Aparna: I don't think you or anybody else can control which way the discussions head to. Btw you haven't answered my question-- How could Anandi be sure that DB won't hurt her/her dear ones in some OTHER way?
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: krystal_watz

Aparna: I don't think you or anybody else can control which way the discussions head to. Btw you haven't answered my question-- How could Anandi be sure that DB won't hurt her/her dear ones in some OTHER way?

Did DB exhibit any animosity towards anyone else in the family other than Anandi and Amol?
Amol they have taken care of and taught him to how to handle the lady and Anandi and Shiv did keep her in check.
Has she shown any hatred or resentment towars the bahus or even Alok for that matter till now? Who started the fights in the family? Was it Anop or DB? Is DB responsible for the current situation or the Shekhars themselves responsible?
Till today in what way has she shown any hatred or intention to harm anyone other than Anandi?
Her actions are motivated only by her hatred towards Anandi. Just because the lady hates her and doesn't have any problems with anyone else in the family why should she come in between her relationships with others in the family?
Yes she has views about what woman's place should be at home and society and she has exhibited thoughts which are very traditional and rigid does that make her unfit to live with the rest of the family?
-------------------------
Yes I cannot control the discussion but if I feel like it is not my liking I can quit or choose not to answer
441597 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#48
Anandi didn't know that DB was feeding her drugs. What if she tried to do something similar to Amol? Would Amol be able to refuse if DB nicely and "lovingly" asks him to eat something?

And secondly, fine, DB does not wanna harm anybody else other than Anandi. What if she tried another way to harm her? A way whereby Anandi could be harmed gravely without DB being suspected? Here she was openly feeding Anandi laddoos-- what if she did something covertly next time?
leavesandwaves thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#49
I think DB exhibited animosity even for Sanchi and to some exent towards Shiv during Rasika episode.

She was plain nasty to her grandson's wife.

Hurting anandi means hurting anyone connected to anandi as anandi does not exist alone without connections.

Ira should have taken action against DB or even Meenu. that would have been better and anandi allowing Ira and Meenu to deal with would have been better


Edited by leavesandwaves - 11 years ago
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#50
What DB does next? Who knows what she will do or won't do?
I never said that forgiving DB is right or wrong all I said was it was choice that Anandi made and it is not because the offender is family because even if a stranger had fed her poison she would have let go of him after she gave him a piece of her mind like the time when she was kidnapped by Heth Singh's men she made sure she found out who was behind this act she gave him a piece of her mind and she didn't press kidnap charges on him.It is her way of dealing things
My entire replies are to the question whether Anandi is biased towards the family members.
All I have been trying to say is that whether it Dsa DB or J whoever it she decided to let go of them for what ever reasons is not because she can't stand up for herself or because those members happened to be her family.
Anandi is only biased towards victims whom she considers as underdogs
Edited by aparnauma - 11 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".