My Mummy vs CVs of Balika - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

64

Views

6.1k

Users

18

Likes

380

Frequent Posters

sunflower52 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#51

Originally posted by: rohini55

@sunflower

So true. From Tulsi to Anandi with hundreds in between, all female leads lie and hide. The story moves forward on the strength of the lie/hiding.

If Anandi had not hidden Jagya's deception, the story would not have got as big as it did. If Anandi did not hide Saanch's pujari truth, saJa engagement would not have happened. If she did not hide Saurabh's visits to Saanchi, the rape would not have happened.

In short there is no story without the female lead hiding. It is the catalyst for moving the story. That she
ends up looking stupid rather than virtuous adds to the story and viewer interest.


The only saving grace in BV is Ansh are an ideal couple who are transparent with each other and allow no MU to develop. But A did try to hide the terrace incident. But Shiv drew it out of her.


That is why I have never end up supporting any lead heroines, accept 2 that was Ragini & Pia.

@bold, +1 I agree. I support Anandi to an extent.
sunflower52 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#52

Originally posted by: Picasso9


I agree to an extent here. The thing is that this time iminent catastrophic physical harm could be perpetrated as a result of this continued secrecy. This is not just a case of hiding a little secret. This is akin to seeing a snake in the house and not alerting anyone in case they are heartbroken, without considering the fact that the snake could bite a child or any other member of the household. So withholding this truth is like being an accomplice.

If cvs are using this tactic to prolong the storyline then it's a very irresponsible of them based on the message they're sending out.


@bold, I agree then. cv's will be irresponsible.
rohini55 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#53

Originally posted by: Picasso9



I agree to an extent here. The thing is that this time iminent catastrophic physical harm could be perpetrated as a result of this continued secrecy. This is not just a case of hiding a little secret. This is akin to seeing a snake in the house and not alerting anyone in case they are heartbroken, without considering the fact that the snake could bite a child or any other member of the household. So withholding this truth is like being an accomplice.

If cvs are using this tactic to prolong the storyline then it's a very irresponsible of them based on the message they're sending out.



----

👏 agree totally. This is by far the worst and most dangerous case of hiding. It is being argued again and again that if action is taken against DB or she is thrown out, she will get more vengeful.

But does the remedy lie in keeping her inside and putting a lid on her deeds? Wouldn't she get vengeful already for being found out? What if she pushed amol down the stairs? DB is a psychopath and needs treatment. This is like keeping a serial killer at home.

And it is indeed shameful that CVs are propagating the message that possession of drugs is not a serious crime and it must be hidden in the larger family interest.

If DB is not caught and exposed, we must seriously think of petitioning the CVs and alerting the narcotics bureau for the awful message that is being spread to gullible masses.
Picasso9 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#54

Originally posted by: rohini55



----

👏 agree totally. This is by far the worst and most dangerous case of hiding. It is being argued again and again that if action is taken against DB or she is thrown out, she will get more vengeful.

But does the remedy lie in keeping her inside and putting a lid on her deeds? Wouldn't she get vengeful already for being found out? What if she pushed amol down the stairs? DB is a psychopath and needs treatment. This is like keeping a serial killer at home.

And it is indeed shameful that CVs are propagating the message that possession of drugs is not a serious crime and it must be hidden in the larger family interest.

If DB is not caught and exposed, we must seriously think of petitioning the CVs and alerting the narcotics bureau for the awful message that is being spread to gullible masses.


Indeed! What could be more heinous? Ratan Singh was jailed for his heinous crimes. It's besides the point that he was redeemed. People fail to realise, he redeemed after punishment, during his stint in jail, introspecting his deeds and his role, not blaming others of his sorry state. It's not a case of ' of a rattan can be redeemed, why not DB'. It's a case of punishment befitting crime. It's a case of redemption coming after punishment.
Edited by Picasso9 - 11 years ago
sunflower52 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#55
DB still does not have any iota of guilt even after being caught. These people never learn and she should be punished on accounts of possession of drugs and intention of causing harm.

Drugs like cocaine should not be taken lightly. The cv's are giving a wrong message.

If these BV cv's do not give punishment to DB, I am going to give them a lashing on twitter.
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#56
Whether it was philandering Jagya or people like DB, Anandi should have exposed them and sent them to jail.
No excuse for so called parivaar ki khushi.
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#57
Actually Indians at large have this mentality of hiding things, forgiving, giving a chance etc., as hallmark of virtue. They endorse bearing, tolerating anything, standing by others etc as love, compassion. 🤢
It is fed to female minds that they have to understand, they have to maintain peace.

Often men are conditioned in a similar way if they are given responsibility of family. There are films like Main Tulsi tere Aangan ki where male lead, the virtuous one, is tolerant, covers up even crimes of brother, protects younger brother from wrath of family and village, keeps hoping young brother would change someday. He suffers throughout his childhood and youth for his younger brother.

It is shocking how people believe one should do anything for peace in family. Or feels wrong in speaking the truth, taking a stand when matter involves family.

Things will correct themselves, whatever is destined will happen, kill them with kindness, be so good that goodness haunts the other etc, are stupid and illogical notions that sadly many have in real life. And serials like BV endorse them.

I didn't like Shiv hiding about Jagya's railway ghotala or amnesia. Nor Jagya's hiding stuff about Sanchi later.

What is wrong, must be brought to light. Do it politely but firmly. No need to shout or abuse.

Only in serials people reform. In real life, hiding does more harm than good. This is why families suffer in silence.

Coming to serials I get amused. On an other forum people want rapists and murderers forgiven and want female lead to marry the guy who raped her sister and killed her parents. They time to time protest against her drive to get justice. Whereas if female keeps forgiving, giving chances etc, she is still bashed. No respite in any position!
Awfulggt thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#58

Originally posted by: meditation

Hi friends.

My mom has been watching Balika Vadhu for years now and she is very disappointed with what the cvs have been doing with Anandi's character.Anandi cannot conceal such a grave truth about Dadi bua from her family just becoz its her family.I am sure the cvs are just trying to project Anandi holier than thou and eventually the family will get to know about the evil deeds of Dadi Bua and will place Anandi on a higher pedestal that she tried to shelter her family especially Daddu from the misdeeds of his sister.
What if Dadi bua had tried to mix drugs in Amol's food and it had had critical effect on his health ? would she be still sheltering Dadi Bua from her family or act as she had exposed others and send them to jail without caring for the sentiments of the family concerned ?
pls comment. my intention is not to demeen the character but the flaw in the character created by the cvs.
Thank you


Agree with you that Anandi is doing the wrong thing in hiding the truth. But then I feel Anandi always has these double standards. This track is not being any different. She has diffrent sets of rules for family and outsiders. She behaves like as if the criminals who are not related to her have no families and could never change to good beings like the ones related to her. So I wasn't surprised when she did this.


Talking just about this track -- I initially gave a benefit of doubt to Anandi as she does not know the complete truth about DB yet and thought maybe she couldn't sense the malice in DB because of the extreme ideal brain cells she(Anandi) is gifted with. Still, Iike some members here said, I don't find it fair on her part to take unilateral decisions. She should let others(Alok/Ira if not Daddu) know exactly what she knows including DB's defending statements and let the elders take a decision as this is a family matter. This is important as every person's life could be at risk. Even if we assume dB did this out of good intentions(I know not) , she committed a grave mistake and anyone could be in Anandi's place. So yes Annadi is cent percent wrong in hiding the truth.


goofyCat thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#59
The way Anandi's double standards are decided based on family members and likes of Saurabh, Ratan Singh etc etc amazes me.
The only wrong thing that Anandi did in the entire drug story was currently hiding DB's involvement in it. (She clearly said - Shiv abhi nahi batate hai sabko). That too, not because the culprit DB is a family member, but the truth coming out at this point will affect family members including daddu.
She didn't forgive DB, she never expressed any will to let DB escape without punishment. She didn't stop Shiv from tracing and finding the drug seller.
Awfulggt thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#60
Anandi's double standards are not just just measured on Suarabh's case and Rat's case. Her double standards started with J's case where she left him freely. Then it continued. She is hiding DB's mistakes now cause she apparently cares for Daddu. Saurabh and Rat too had family members who loved them. Saurabh's mum;s heart shattered when she came to know about. But still Anandi didn't care about her. Why? That's what I call is a double standard. In this case I don't understand why she thinks Ira/Alok also shouldn't know about DB. Does she think she's the only sane one livng on the planet who could manage everyone single handedly?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".