AnSh AT 201 | Saathiya Sang Sach ka Samnaa (notice pg 53) - Page 19

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

57.8k

Users

34

Likes

3.7k

Frequent Posters

Chahat_A_Doshi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago

In Ira's confrontation of Alok I want her to mention that she was not even given the chance to mourn the death of her daughter

It is her right to do so

Ira and Shiv should come closer Give ST to Meenu n Alok

+++++

But I don't get it what heavy price the family will pay if he is Meenu n Anup ka beta

Alok ka duty with beauty ho toh samjha

+++++

They need to bring out Shiv's insecurities about being an orphan/adopted child; Now he knows Alok knows but not Ira; he should be shown feeling that she will not love him or will she as he is paraya khoon etc

This should be exploited to the fullest then play quiz contest mummy pappa kaun

Yes Shiv needs to find his parents; his roots But hum audience ke saath they are playing Kaun hai mummy pappa?

maahi11 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: aparnauma

We have a quite lot of evidence to say that they visited this thread.Most of the things we said in the forum/AT this week would be there on the screen in the following week.They use quite a lot of discussion material for their dialogues.😆

oh hopefully dey better listn dis also
hisusmita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
I want let the vagabond be Sjee's father but they should not end up showing him as Alok. Let Alok rest in peace. And Sjee should come to know about this much later. They should not be in a hurry to disclose who his real parents are . hat will be too filmy
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
After Pooja at the temple Alok mentioned that they will have to pack for their trip to Kashmir.
Who will go to Kashmir?Will the elder Shekhars go or will they send the boy and his babe?
I stiil have not given up on Kashmir trip
Stranger in Jaitser seem to have come from Kashmir too.I wonder what the connection is all about😕

I think if they want the audience to see the emotions of an orphan who has been adopted they should show only that and reveal his parentage much later.


adi2512 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Hiral_Halwa

GM AT😊
agree with all the posts...PY😡😡
Well Yeah, T is capable of some really really good shots in the emotional scenes with Singhs...ahh the walking away in the khoon bhari maang and the phone call with Bhairon😭😭
it seems CVs only wanted to get the A-Singhs bonding right
+++++++++++
The only reason I feel that A is not comforting S physically still is because, at this moment, S is again on a one-track mind - he isnt ready to think about his unconditional bonding with Shekhars, whereby A has both S and Shekhars in mind😕
Mayb, just mayb, when the situation and S gets around to accepting whatever happened and that time when S is ready to move on to just being Shekhar's son, no matter what, and at that time, when he is on the verge of recovering but is forced to leave the house because of Sa's torture...that time the pain of S will be mutliple folds more...thats when A might comfort him the way we want😊

____________________
GA girls...😊
Hiral...
Even I was saying and samjhoing myself, all the while ( when the AT was grumbling about lack of physical comfort / jestures from A ), that it will happen when the time is right...when S is completely broken for whatever reason...
BUT, y/day's SUV scene...HE is broken...He is crying...
As a viewer, if we can feel for S so much, at such a moment..how can a loving and caring wife like Anandi sitting beside him cannot offer him more than a bottle of water...?
I would not have expected a hug or anything of sorts...( I know., its a bit impractical...sitting in a car, on a busy road side and all...)...but atleast a simple jesture of wiping tears ...?
How difficult it can be ...?...concept wise and picturisation wise...?
The whole scene was very very insensitively potrayed...
It just felt like it was to 'highlight' someone's acting capabilities...a forced attempt...!!!
It would have looked better...he went and cried in a secluded place away from his wife...!!!...that would have been more meaningful...
A/ways...will still try and be optimistic and look forward for a more sensitive potrayal, in a bigger event of Sjee's life / or a bigger aspect of Sjee's turmoil...
-------------------------------
JMHO...I understand, everyones's yardstick of judging a performance is different...I personally feel, the new A isn't anywhere lagging w.r.t Old A in terms of emotional scenes...
She HAS performed in the appropriately...
Just wanted to put in this...at this opportunity...
731627 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
it is good shiv going to know about his parents now.he will feel somewhat relax .it does not matter whose son shiv is just ansh should always support each other in trouble time
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
Adi - I don't know what it is that was missing in that scene
If they want to high light someone's performances no problem but they have to make the scene work too.If the scene doesn't work performance goes waste.

Looking back even if she did not wipe his tears it is still okay considering he may not like it.Anandi also is not the type who would let someone do that.

The care,concern and pain at seeing him was missing from her side. He would not have liked overt expression of those feelings from her but at least show that she is hiding those emotions.


hisusmita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
The gesture which she showed in the temple, the way she hold his hand and make him do the ritual is very nice and touchy. We too dont want any hug in the jeep, that she could have given him the other day when he was seen lost with the lappy. The way shiv hugged her when she was so anxious for Singhs during Haveli burning track .
But yday something was missing and becoz of which the scene didnt have the desired impact.

As if do alag alag acting kar reh the. Didnt look like hubby was going thru such emotional trauma and wify trying hard to give him all the support and make him strong in that situation. Some thing was lacking
Edited by hisusmita - 11 years ago
adi2512 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: aparnauma

Adi - I don't know what it is that was missing in that scene

If they want to high light someone's performances no problem but they have to make the scene work too.If the scene doesn't work performance goes waste.

Looking back even if she did not wipe his tears it is still okay considering he may not like it.Anandi also is not the type who would let someone do that.

The care,concern and pain at seeing him was missing from her side. He would not have liked overt expression of those feelings from her but at least show that she is hiding those emotions.


Aparna...
How much did they show of her...to show her emotions in that scene...all that they have given her is the same ghisa pita dialogue - I u/stand you...I'am with you...
Leave even wiping the tears...a comforting hand on his shoulder...?...would he feel delicate for that too..?
I was watching the scene recently...after J's maang bharo incident...when he was driving and in pain...
Anandi sensed it, and just put her hand on his hand with which he was holding the gear...
How meaningful it looked...
It said all w/o showing her face., nor she even uttering a single word...
All that is needed in that scene...was such simple jesture...
I cannot blame both the actors...
He performed exceptionally good...and she was not given a chance to potray a caring wife..
That's why ...I was / am so disturbed...
A/ways...to each their own...😆
Script / Direction...😡😡
adi2512 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: hisusmita

The gesture which she showed in the temple, the way she hold her hand and make him do the ritual is very nice and touchy. We too dont want any hug in the jeep, that she could have given him the other day when he was seen lost with the lappy. The way shiv hugged her when she was so anxious for Singhs during Haveli burning track .

But yday something was missing and becoz of which the scene didnt have the desired impact.

As if do alag alag acting kar reh the. Didnt look like hubby was going thru such emotional trauma and wify trying hard to give him all the support and make him strong in that situation. Some thing was lacking

@ bold - That was so very sensitively done...!!!...though it was edited out in the blink of an eye...!!!
See, we are happy even with such small yet mwaningful jestures...
b'coz.. that's the beauty of AnSh...!!!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".