Originally posted by: Hiral_Halwa
GM AT😊
agree with all the posts...PY😡😡
Well Yeah, T is capable of some really really good shots in the emotional scenes with Singhs...ahh the walking away in the khoon bhari maang and the phone call with BhaironðŸ˜ðŸ˜
it seems CVs only wanted to get the A-Singhs bonding right
+++++++++++
The only reason I feel that A is not comforting S physically still is because, at this moment, S is again on a one-track mind - he isnt ready to think about his unconditional bonding with Shekhars, whereby A has both S and Shekhars in mind😕
Mayb, just mayb, when the situation and S gets around to accepting whatever happened and that time when S is ready to move on to just being Shekhar's son, no matter what, and at that time, when he is on the verge of recovering but is forced to leave the house because of Sa's torture...that time the pain of S will be mutliple folds more...thats when A might comfort him the way we want😊
____________________
GA girls...😊
Hiral...
Even I was saying and samjhoing myself, all the while ( when the AT was grumbling about lack of physical comfort / jestures from A ), that it will happen when the time is right...when S is completely broken for whatever reason...
BUT, y/day's SUV scene...HE is broken...He is crying...
As a viewer, if we can feel for S so much, at such a moment..how can a loving and caring wife like Anandi sitting beside him cannot offer him more than a bottle of water...?
I would not have expected a hug or anything of sorts...( I know., its a bit impractical...sitting in a car, on a busy road side and all...)...but atleast a simple jesture of wiping tears ...?
How difficult it can be ...?...concept wise and picturisation wise...?
The whole scene was very very insensitively potrayed...
It just felt like it was to 'highlight' someone's acting capabilities...a forced attempt...!!!
It would have looked better...he went and cried in a secluded place away from his wife...!!!...that would have been more meaningful...
A/ways...will still try and be optimistic and look forward for a more sensitive potrayal, in a bigger event of Sjee's life / or a bigger aspect of Sjee's turmoil...
-------------------------------
JMHO...I understand, everyones's yardstick of judging a performance is different...I personally feel, the new A isn't anywhere lagging w.r.t Old A in terms of emotional scenes...
She HAS performed in the appropriately...
Just wanted to put in this...at this opportunity...