Stigma against divorcees - Is it justified? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

39

Views

3.5k

Users

23

Likes

171

Frequent Posters

angelic8219 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: lovesunshine

I want to share a story from one of my husbands relatives. this boy was working out of India. He came back for holidays and as per parents wishes started looking for arranged marriage matches for himself. He liked a simple Indian girl and because he wanted to take her away with her to his country of residence they quickly went for registry marriage. then he went off to his country.

the realtionship was going good, both side parents and families were very happy...suddenly in our local community magazine my Mother in law found an 'looking for bride' add with this guy's photo !

after further inquiries we found out that the boy's parents were not happy with the girl anymore and asked him divorce/breakoff! the reason given by the boy's mother /father to us was they had to take the girl for one family function (pooja) and they asked her to wear a saree for the ocassion and she denied because she said she is uncomfortable in a saree. and then they started disliking her!

Then they got him married second time again arranged marriage and he gave up his job and settled in India,this girl was an MBA and was working on a very high position in a company, the father of the boy asked her to come home early to cook even though he knew she had work related commitments and due to her position in the company has to attend them. Then the in laws denied her to watch tv and asked her only to do bhajans of god instead..for an educated lady it started getting highly intolerable.


So the couple started staying separately. even then they had issues ..the boy was earning quite a decnet salary himself. The girl had only her father in her maayka and wanted to give her entire salary to her father to which the boy opposed. then they both divorced...

Now this boy has met someone new via online chatting and has recently married this girl - third time!


I hope everything falls in place for him this time and they live happily ever after😉


The parents are so picky and was it really wrong for the girl to give salary to her father if the guy is earning good anyway?
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#22
@Sectoreight

This topic wasn't triggered by Shekhars' reaction to Sanchi's love for Jagya alone. But due to UD & Ira's reactions to Anandi, Sumitra's reactions on divorced women and Anandi's constant hesitation to speak in her in-laws' family due to this divorcee tag. Even Ganga is dissed for her broken marriage.

Plus there's a general keenness to discuss this due to things I've seen happening with others in real life.
lovesunshine thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: angelic8219


The parents are so picky and was it really wrong for the girl to give salary to her father if the guy is earning good anyway?

i agree with you angelic...the parents once chided me as well when they came at our house..they just have the mentality bahu means a slave...the father of this boy had said to me..you are worth nothing.. and told my in laws that your bahu is not good for anything just because he did not like the tea i made 😡...imagine the plea of his own bahu then..

about the salary issue i think its just the male ego..the guy i feel must be money centric..n the MBA girl is the only daughter of her ageing father...so whats wrong in giving salary to him for his old age? besides did her husband pay for her upbringing and education? no na then why unnecessarily complain about it? besides this girl had brought enough jewellery and cash to her sasuraal when they had married...

but we only know one side of the story..

also the first girl whom he had married and divorced is still single and no one in the community is ready to marry her..😕
lishu_ thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#24
Thanks for this post TM..
It's a sensitive topic..
Your post is very well-written..You have raised the points that one needs to think over..
-Why the society has to bark? I love this point..
but It's a saddening reality that people preassume that a divorcee has some issues and speculate things as if they know him/her personally and can tell what would have gone wrong and that it could be handled by making a compromise only...!
Divorce is a sort of shame in indian society..
And ppl prefer to compromise even in some drastic situations such as abusive relationships!
A saddening truth..
Though things are changing with time..
-As for having an initial bias...That's a natural human reaction..since one tries to 'judge' another person on the basis of his/her past..what has he/she done in life..His/her achievements in career..and so whether the person ever had a failed relationship?
That's wot humans tend to do..
But if the person has a clarity of thoughts...
He/she should not be ashamed for having a divorcee spouse/friend/relative after knowing that fault is not on his/her part..
It's wrong on society's part to say disgraceful things and speculate things abt a divorcee or his/her spouse..
And interfere in their life..
I hated that shitty dialogue for shiv "isme koi kami thi kya"! 😡
But what bv portrayed was close to reality!
-As for shiv staying in the relationship with anandi inspite of the so called 'confused signals' during the crappy J's amnesia track..
Then he was sure that his partener didn't had feelings for her ex before that jagya tried to trap him..
Just because he and anandi had talked time to time (lake scene)and they both had clarity of thoughts..
And had trust and respect for each other..
I feel that crappy track was just to show the strength of bonding b/w them..
And he backed off eventually when he had thought that anandi may still have feelings when jagya tried to convince him by showin that old baksa..
But anandi straightened him ! 😆
so there may be some clashes..but the ultimate responsibility lies with the parteners to have trust and faith in each other and be open with each other..
Life is too precious and one has the full right to live their life fully..
Edited by Jaishreeka - 12 years ago
uniquebluerose thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#25
Divorce is sensitive issue in India...even abroad i guess people need to know the reason...

Edited by uniquebluerose - 12 years ago
shalluuu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#26
yes many couples are happy after second marriage..i am not against divorcee but being a educated girl i would prefer to marry unmarried man...but if someone marry to person like anandi i dont have any problem
but when comes to jagat😡😡...
Anurulz thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#27
it wud depend on the reason for the divorce..if its incompatibility, why hold it against the couple in the first place..i appreciate the honesty is divorce and making a clean slate rather than pushing an incompatible marriage, or worse, cheating on ur spouse citing " incompatibility" vis-a-vis jagya.. everyone deserves a second chance, if they deserve it..
libsrocks thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: lovesunshine

I want to share a story from one of my husbands relatives. this boy was working out of India. He came back for holidays and as per parents wishes started looking for arranged marriage matches for himself. He liked a simple Indian girl and because he wanted to take her away with her to his country of residence they quickly went for registry marriage. then he went off to his country.

the realtionship was going good, both side parents and families were very happy...suddenly in our local community magazine my Mother in law found an 'looking for bride' add with this guy's photo !

after further inquiries we found out that the boy's parents were not happy with the girl anymore and asked him divorce/breakoff! the reason given by the boy's mother /father to us was they had to take the girl for one family function (pooja) and they asked her to wear a saree for the ocassion and she denied because she said she is uncomfortable in a saree. and then they started disliking her!

Then they got him married second time again arranged marriage and he gave up his job and settled in India,this girl was an MBA and was working on a very high position in a company, the father of the boy asked her to come home early to cook even though he knew she had work related commitments and due to her position in the company has to attend them. Then the in laws denied her to watch tv and asked her only to do bhajans of god instead..for an educated lady it started getting highly intolerable.


So the couple started staying separately. even then they had issues ..the boy was earning quite a decnet salary himself. The girl had only her father in her maayka and wanted to give her entire salary to her father to which the boy opposed. then they both divorced...

Now this boy has met someone new via online chatting and has recently married this girl - third time!


I hope everything falls in place for him this time and they live happily ever after😉

i think this is because of their so nosy and naggy parents...seriously what i don't get in india is when you have trusted your child to be mature enough to get married then why not trust him/her to take his/her own life decisions...30 saal ke baad bhi haye mera baccha thing looks irritating to me
753037 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: ilove..sidyusha

I have a Friend

the boys have refused to marry her because her parents are divorced.😡
there is no fault of the girl but people don't accept her...


Lol true! my friends parents refused to marry her to a guy because the guys parents are divorced. This guy was extremely brilliant in studies and is from a good background, Both his parents were doctors! The reasons her parents gave was..if parents didn't know the value of marriage what would they teach their son?

And my parents refused a proposal just because that guy had loved a girl when he was in college😆. his love story was not successful though and he finally decided to go for an arranged marriage!

That is how parents think. they are probably not completely wrong. They would want to see the best one for their children. If one has a past, that past tends to affect them in some way or the other. So they pick the safest option which is okay. But again, this is in case of arranged marriages. Love marriage cases like AnSh are different though.

But what i don't support is the parents of a divorcee looking for first timer. That is hypocrisy. When their son/daughter has a past and is ready to move on they should be able to accept someone who has a past too. Being a divorcee is perfectly normal. Nothing to be ashamed about. It is always better if two people separate instead of compromising reluctantly and living together just for the heck of it!

People accuse one person of trapping the other when they think the two of them are not equals. It need not necessarily be a divorce story. It could be differences in financial status, beauty, backgrounds or even this divorcee vs first timer case. I wouldn't conclude that one person trapped the other unless and until the whole case is opened and put in front of me.


Shinya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#30

t

Originally posted by: Skepblun

I've witnessed it in real life and also seen many discussions on it online.

Is it fair to have suspicions and stigma against a male or female who's been divorced?

What if people don't get along or marriage doesn't work out for some reason? Don't they have right to move on?
And if the law itself gives them full right to nullify their marriage and move on, then why does society still stigmatise divorcees?

(Same for widows and widowers. If law gives them right to remarry then why society has to bark? What's one's fault if their spouse has expired?)

Is it fair to doubt a person's character if he or she had a failed marriage?

Many couples find happiness in second marriage. They are happy but society or family still barks about them and reminds them of their previously failed relationship.
There are accusations of lack of mental stability, bad fortune or lack of sense, bad character etc. and accusations of trapping some new spouse or marrying out of desperation (likes of Shiv get taunts "ismein koi kami thi kya jo aisi ladki se shaadi kar li"/ or are thought to be fooled and seduced by a divorcee).

Is it fair? Is it justified?

Do you in real life, get repulsed by divorcee tag? Would you reject someone if you knew he or she was a divorcee? Would you feel a sense of "shame" if you or your family member got a divorce?

I'd request members to share their POV on divorce and divorcees and sense of "shame"/"honour" associated with it, here.

I dont know about how divorcees feel or how they are treated by the society ..

But such topics should certainly not be discussed on this forum. This is not the place to discuss it, there may be few divorcess amongst the members who might feel offended.

You must stick to the discussion on BV only.


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".