why DIL should tell all to MIL - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

28

Views

2.7k

Users

15

Likes

151

Frequent Posters

Chahat_A_Doshi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#21

She need not ell them everything

Anandi should have told the Shekhar's but kaise batati wo toh socho?

Agar wo inko batati toh would she not be going against Shiv; ek baar Shiv ne use kaha I will handle it toh usne phir socha hi nahi;

Shiv also did not take the matter seriously arre like wo dono sochte bhi kaise ki kabhi aise kuch hoga adn sab kuch bahar aayega

She told Shiv everything and that showed the trust and strength of their relationship

She should have told them about Shiv knowing because ab Shiv chahe jitna bole I knew it Ira ne soch liya hai ki it is A's fault and Shiv is taking her side

Then again Shiv gave the justification for her keeping her mouth shut about him

You know ye BV wale humein bhi pendu bana rahe hain; Dono taraf se soch rahe hain hum and dono taraf apni jagah sahi hai like Mahi said

Dono jab sahi hote hain toh ye tay kanra mushkil hai ki kaun zyaada sahi hai

LOOKING ON THE BRIGHT SIDE

Ira ko negative nahi bana rahe hain na hi use butcher kar rahe hain; thoda lapse in judgement dikha rahe hain;

this Saachi ka kiya hua kaand will somehow strengthen Ira Anandi relationship. Meenu use beti maanti hai but Ira use bahu maanti hai; this is the third time use lag raha hai ki Shiv Anandi ke kareeb aur uss se door ja raha hai

DHEERE DHEERE IT WILL BE OK ANANDI KO BHI SHEKHAR BAHU BANNE KA MAUKA MIL RAHA HAI AB TAK SINGH'S KI BETI BANKAR HI RAHI HAI



753037 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: Suchi-Virmanian

true samvi.. I do agree that if Anandi told Ira that shiv knew that would have solved the situation.

Its sad that the situation just got worse and Ira's Ego got hurt!



Yes her ego got hurt the moment Shiv entered and jumped onto his wife's side making his mom the culprit! this whole issue changed from defamation issue to Saas bahu issue where the mother thinks she has lost her son forever😳!! Shiv also did a BAD job in handling this situation. He shouldn't have jumped to sides...but should have been the calm and composed guy he always was. As mahi said each one is right from their end...it is just a misunderstanding. The Shekars are cool people...they will sort things out. Mainly because Ira doesn't hate Anandi inherently like Sanchi does.In fact she loves her. .She(ira) just gets carried away..and there are good people around her to bring her back to normalcy.
poorvab thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: Suchi-Virmanian

I still do not understand how Anandi has done anything to make shekars look bad?


Even lets say she earns the trust of shekars.. what after that?

If this issue were to come out even after years of marriage... Ira willstill feel bad and blame Anandi. Cause even when shiv would support her after 10+ years she would feel bad. Its just a mother in law syndrome. Normal and irritating but thats how it is.

Anandi told Shiv and thats that. Shiv is at fault here if anything not Anandi.

ANd Shiv did not think it was important to tell the family at that time.. and he didnt

==
This issue of trust would raise only if Anandi did wrong to the shekars. She has never said anything wrong about SHiv and his family. She has always supported him and what else should be expected of a wife. That she takes care of the husband and his family to the best of her abilities. WHich Anandi is doing.

I do not understand why people are saying that Anandi has to earn their trust. I mean ... she is doing what a DIL does.

. Take care of her husband
. Take care of the family by cooking cleaning making sure that they are fed and taking responsibility of what ever chores she can
. Making sure she does not bad mouth about her inlaws to her mayka wala peeps
. Making sure that she does not bad mouth about her in laws to her husband.


I mean from where i see... any good mother would want her son's wife to do what Anandi is doing.

I am not sure what else she needs to do.. press Ira's legs? hmm

I am sure she will do that too

perhaps clean their toilets .. that she probably does too..

May be become a slave..

isnt that she was doing for her dadisa for 26 years of her life?

--

What has the Shekars done for Anandi

Given her love? Yes
Did Anandi give them love Yes

Did she bear Sanchi's nonsense.. yes
Did sanchi bear Anandi NO

Did she disrespect Ira No
Did Ira disrespect Anandi Yes (twice) Annadi does not know that her mother in law already inquired if she had sex with her son or not.

SO ... My question is what should a daughter in law do to gain respect of her in laws besides taking the responsibility of her home and her husband?

====


very well said!
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#24
I agree with you. I think people want anandi to forget about singhs which is her maayka completely.
When shiv does not have a problem with jagya then shekhars should have anything to do with that.
Anandi trusted shiv in the railway fraud case and took all the insult from Heth Singh.
Regarding not saving physical relationship with shiv for 3 months then its between ansh and shekhars don't have a right to talk about it. Shiv always knew before marriage that why anandi agreed to get married and it will take time to make her love him. If people want anandi to be human than what she told to shiv about DS lie was apt and why would she inform shekhars when she confronted shiv about the incident. Here it's all MU btw ansh and Ira. The only person taking advantage is saanchi.
While I agree that in this track, the guilty are DS and then Shiv. @ bold above, I still cannot get this mayka concept. Singhs were her in-laws (now ex-in-laws), Bhairo, Sumitra treated her as their daughter but still she was daughter-in-law. Her father is still alive. How it is badi haveli is her mayka and she does not ever remember her father who is all alone? Why she cares for only Singhs and not for her father?
Chytra thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#25
Well no need for DIL to tell anything to MIL and then DIL shouldn't expect love and care from MIL as well. I don't know how it works outside India but In India, family will poke into your personal space as well. Even relatives will pressurize the couple to have baby soon.

It is ok that Ira is hurt now. Anyone in that situation will. She is not acting mahaan and i am ok with it. I didn't forget how she is ok with shiv's choice of bride and she completely supported him and accepted Anandi with open embrace. She didn't said anything wrong.

Being a balika vadhu and then a divorcee Anandi , will look like a culprit here. I wish shiv has handled it with more caution rather than back lashing at his mother with his choti soch dialogue. He has driven a stake into Ira's heart. I guess it will take even more time. As no mother will accept her son to insult her in front of the family.

Sometimes, the girl has to bear with the burnt of what her family did. It is not entirely out from the blues. It happens in real life too.
libsrocks thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: mukta13

confidence and trust is something which has to be earned and not demanded.It is Anandi here who has to earn it.she has done nothing for her in laws,she has made only shiv happy except for wearing saree,comming for makar sankrati and making food.which any DIL but on the other hand shekhars had to suffer for her,before marraige a lot of jagia drama in which she equally participated,returning to Jaitser on third day bcoz she was not comfortable and missed her family,celebrating all festivals at BH,she went to udaipur only when she knew Ira really felt bad,not having a husband wife relationship till four months and the whole familay knew about it and above all giving more importance to singhs over shekhar when she knew saachi is making a big issue about it.And about Shiv he is just joru ka ghulam,why a mother will not feel bad.U need not say everything to ur MIL but then u have to face the consequences when a third person comes and gives u the detail.Shiv did not sayall this to keep peace and save insult of DS but look what happened ,DS has fallen down in the eyes of sekhars but he himself along with Anandi has fallen down in the eyes of Ira.U can never be happy If your mother is sad atleast for me.

Anandi has never said lie,she told ample of times about jagia as singhs would be hurt but might be her marraige could be saved If she told the truth in time.

Shiv and anandi r repeating the past which has started showing its effect.

mukta13 if we look from the POV that Anandi was more inclined to Singhs than Shekhars than i would say that what she was doing was a pain in our neck not Shekhars...Shekhars did not once showed their discomfort about Anandi helping Singhs...did they?
it's we who were bothered with all this not Shekhars...if they were they could have once discussed it with Anandi but they did not and from what we saw in BV non of the Shekhars felt uncomfortable with Jagya's presence...Anandi did not hide any truth...it was Shiv who stopped her from saying anything to Shekhars...and becoz Anandi was new she thought that maybe Shiv is stopping her for some reason and it's better if he handles his family becoz he knows them the best so nowhere is it Anandi's fault and now Ira is making an issue that SShiv is siding with Anandi...but that's because Anandi is innocent and she is getting blamed unnecessarily for all this issue...and isn't it Ira's faults that she bashed Anandi so much in front of a stranger which encouraged the stranger to bash her more...Shiv is not being joru ka ghulam...we need to understand that Anandi is new in this family and if, just for Ira's sake, Shiv would have went against Anandi, Anandi would have lost the confidence to ever confide anything to her in-laws because no one is with her even when she is innocent
libsrocks thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#27
I agree with you. I think people want anandi to forget about singhs which is her maayka completely.
When shiv does not have a problem with jagya then shekhars should have anything to do with that.
Anandi trusted shiv in the railway fraud case and took all the insult from Heth Singh.
Regarding not saving physical relationship with shiv for 3 months then its between ansh and shekhars don't have a right to talk about it. Shiv always knew before marriage that why anandi agreed to get married and it will take time to make her love him. If people want anandi to be human than what she told to shiv about DS lie was apt and why would she inform shekhars when she confronted shiv about the incident. Here it's all MU btw ansh and Ira. The only person taking advantage is saanchi.
While I agree that in this track, the guilty are DS and then Shiv. @ bold above, I still cannot get this mayka concept. Singhs were her in-laws (now ex-in-laws), Bhairo, Sumitra treated her as their daughter but still she was daughter-in-law. Her father is still alive. How it is badi haveli is her mayka and she does not ever remember her father who is all alone? Why she cares for only Singhs and not for her father?
it's a completely different issue that anandi does not remember her own father but singhs are her maika...they adopted her like a daughter and gave up their own son for her
Chytra thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#28
wow! choti soch dialogue should be given from shiv to DS. He is so mahaan that he can leave anandi when DS asked. That is love and when Ira was concerned that they are being played , It is choti soch? and that is not love?. It is pure hatred? what happened when Ira was so open minded accepting Anandi? If at all Ira has small thoughts she would have never opened her heart to a already married and divorced woman.
mukta13 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#29
wow! choti soch dialogue should be given from shiv to DS. He is so mahaan that he can leave anandi when DS asked. That is love and when Ira was concerned that they are being played , It is choti soch? and that is not love?. It is pure hatred? what happened when Ira was so open minded accepting Anandi? If at all Ira has small thoughts she would have never opened her heart to a already married and divorced woman.
I completely agree with u,if she and the family would have chotti socch,anandi could never become their bahu.Ira was rude but when some one is very hurt and angry they might speak rashly.But it should be shiv and then anandi who should have handled the situation properly.U can't insult ur mother.I think Ira does not believe that Shiv was knowing the truth,he is saving her.she said the same to Saachi that he has taken the whole blame on him.From her POV,she is correct because Again maight be Shiv never lied them,so she can't believe that he did not inform them about the whole blunder after knowing how angry the whole family was.Anandi is not at all at fault but she has to pay and hear for the deeds of her loved one i.e., DS and Shiv.If Shiv make Ira understand the situation also i don't think Ira can believe Shiv or Anandi so soon.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".