Thank you CVs for presenting the ''NEW YAMINI'' - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

55

Views

2.9k

Users

4

Likes

64

Frequent Posters

LoveToLaugh thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: shreya_rc

Now the ''After Yamini'' as fas a I can see inspite of my miopic vision, she has evolved into a refined version of her daddydearest.


There! I have nothing to add. Perfectly put!

LoveToLaugh thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: AreYaar

Waise I want to know why Nikumb agreed to do the play😕...he changed his mind simply cuz Yamini took care of him during his fever?


I had the exact same question! WHat the hell? Are they now hell bent on making a mockery of Nikumbh's character too?
milinda.shreyz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: LoveToLaugh


I had the exact same question! WHat the hell? Are they now hell bent on making a mockery of Nikumbh's character too?

i hav written a reply to this question on the 1st page. baaki posts I am replying dheere dheere...and yep! back to kolkata !!🤗
milinda.shreyz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#14
Shalini, now your post 😃 :
yamini has not got an inch of character growth, I am absolutely sure of...if she really had gained confidence and power to speak up, to form opinions and to take correct decisions during crisis through all the experiences she had with nikumbh, then
firstly she wouldnot hav thought on show's final day that it was her last day to live as shakuntala, from the nxt day she would be the old yamini again.
2ndly she would not hav allowed the media to behave so obnoxiously throwing impertinent questions at nikumbh . one scolding from her could hav changed the situation.
3rdly she would hav thought deeply if she really had done wrong in changing tthe climax and allthough it was more audience-friendly if it really matched with Nikumbh's vision and may hav approached nikumbh differently for his forgivness.
4thly if she has any kind of cha growth now, it is totally negetiv and in favour of her daddy's direction instead of Nikumbh and much to our chagrin 😡
I think there is nothing about character growth and more about comfortability she shows in front of nikumbh in facade of confidence and all jazz !! itz more like she plays the role of a playful child but all scared in front of papa dear...the world still scares her to the core, difficult situation still unnerves her and she is still now the same clueless, opinion less, stuttering yamini to the world, only with nikumbh she has gained enough confidence to play the role of spoilt child. thatz all !! and that is why it is all much more distasteful to me...because she knows that ikumbh is really gem of a person who would never appear scary, menacing like her daddy she is behaving all thoughtless and tantrum throwing child to him hurting him thoroughly !
Edited by shreya_rc - 11 years ago
LoveToLaugh thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: CyberOstrich

Shreya- just saw the episode and I am still shaking my head! Kya bolun ab?

I dont know whats going on- but I think its all the 'tussle' inside Yamini- the yearning inside her for some how making Nikumb listen to her, understand her and forgive her - that is what is coming out in anger- if I try to give some benefit of doubt to her. Maybe?

Haha... Shalini, you are too optimistic! It would have made sense had she shown even an iota of remorse. But nahi! Ab tak she was chup because she was not being "Shakuntala" enough! Now that she is the "new" Yamini, it's all coming out! Nonsense of the first grade! 🤢

But this total disconnect about what she has actually done and what has actually hurt Nikumb the most and how far off the mark she is of her understanding of nikumb as a person- this - I think maybe its only us that are taking this path of thinking- maybe the writers never intended that to be an issue- very disappointing if that is the case and I really expected better!

Exactly. I think hum hi fools the who were expecting this track. But what were the writers intending? Is this how they wanted to show Yamini's evolution? That she has finally picked up the courage to stand up to Nikumbh? Or they wanted to justify Yamini's thought process? That she is the better person because she believes in love? Or was this just to create a contrived misunderstanding? I don't know.

And I've said this earlier also- whatever she learnt from nikumb during the tasks- all that himmat she got- all that only comes out in front of Nikumb only- that too in form of tantrums?? Whats happens exactly to those guts when her dear father is spouting utter crap about 'chote log hain' abi matlab hai toh use them otherwise just discard them? She is not that innocent or dumb that she cannot understand the insinuations? And if she does understand but let them go just because she knows her father says all those things and doesnt want to take any hassles - then what exactly has been her growth so far?? How can she be shown so olivious to her dad's kaarnaame- i dont understand that!

How long is the viewer supposed to make a case for Yamini because she is innocent? What makes her shut her eyes to what is SO OBVIOUSLY wrong!

For Yamini - this has become all about how Nikumb is being unreasonable, how he is throwing tantrums and how unapproachable he is being- so its not her fault at all- it was anyways never her fault as such in her mind!

And today- just for once i had a tiny issue with Nikumb also- I understand his flying off the handle as soon as he sees her or she is involved in his business in some manner- but i hope for once he hears her out especially if she says how he should not be angry with her as the audience loved the play! I want Nikumb to hear that and say THANKS but NO THANKS - you have never understood what I am and where i come from and it seems you never will- so GOODBYE Yamini- go back to your Dad!

Absolutely. And the fact that he is not telling her that she made a total mockerry of his vision and thought process, proves that the writers never intended to go that way! And that is sheer disrespect to a character like Nikumbh!

But My Azam- man- someone perk him asap! Nikumb i expected more from you there- and not just walk out like that. I didnt like that a bit!

Yeah... What the hell was that walking away bit? I expected so much more!


milinda.shreyz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#16
and a separate post for Azam .
what is this Nikumbh !! stop wallowing in your own well of misery and look at your best buddy, your soul-bro !! he is suffering so much and how can u be so insensitive to walk away ...oh i fest so sad for azam today. he is like an eternal sunny sky and today's dark clouds and threatening rainfall made my already down mood more sullen. he looks heartbroken and is unable to take any simgle blow and was to wishing for nikumbh's strength and his wise words...where r u Nikumbh when ur friend desperately needs u !! He was always with u , like a faithful shadow, like a solid wall, like a cushion to lean back enduring ur mood swings with equal patience and ready smile and filmy dialogues...
Now he has fallen...and it is friend's duly to offer his shoulder and pull him out ...istead he just mumbled a sorry and walked away taking his belongings ?? How can he ??😭
**feeling more upset with the story's weird turning**
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: LoveToLaugh


Yeah... What the hell was that walking away bit? I expected so much more!




More than the walking away, it was the way she FLUNG the papers into the air and walked off that pissed me off...talk about being the very tantrum throwing DIVA that Nikumb often accuses her of being...looks like she wants to fit into any vision that Nikumb comes up with for her...be it Shakuntala or this arrogant diva version of her.
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: shreya_rc

and a separate post for Azam .

what is this Nikumbh !! stop wallowing in your own well of misery and look at your best buddy, your soul-bro !! he is suffering so much and how can u be so insensitive to walk away ...oh i fest so sad for azam today. he is like an eternal sunny sky and today's dark clouds and threatening rainfall made my already down mood more sullen. he looks heartbroken and is unable to take any simgle blow and was to wishing for nikumbh's strength and his wise words...where r u Nikumbh when ur friend desperately needs u !! He was always with u , like a faithful shadow, like a solid wall, like a cushion to lean back enduring ur mood swings with equal patience and ready smile and filmy dialogues...
Now he has fallen...and it is friend's duly to offer his shoulder and pull him out ...istead he just mumbled a sorry and walked away taking his belongings ?? How can he ??😭
**feeling more upset with the story's weird turning**



I really didn't think Nikumb would actually be all whatever and just walk away when Azam was clearly so upset...and later on when that convo with Azam also turned out to be a dream, I was more disappointed...I had hoped that Nikumb came back later on atleast but he didn't...chalo I guess he had a fever so that much can be excused.

Lekin pehle...when he saw again how hurt Azam was, then how could he just leave him...

The characters, the show have both become very frustrating at this point *sigh* I think I need a break.
milinda.shreyz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: LoveToLaugh

LOL... This had me laughing so hard. But in a really, really sad way!

Aap waapis aa gayi waise? Yay! 🤗



Agree with u line to line, tanisha !
waise feeling so blessed we r criticizing the FL to our heart's content without having the fear of getting a mods waring or turning the thread to a fan-war zone !! RR hote toh ab tab thread lock ho chuke hote...what say anu, shalini ??

***Shreya shakes her head and lols***

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".