Originally posted by: Laila2009
WOW!!!!!!!! A whole thread dedicated to me😃....I feel so priveleged!!
Well let me roll up my sleeves and get started!!!!!!
1) She came in between Nakul when he tried to kill Abhi
An isolated event and she put him in that predicament by failing to take a stand and telling everyone she was married to him in the first place.
2) She never backed down from getting intimate w/Abhi but luck was not on their side
She never initiated it either; meaning until Abhi brought up the fact they had not been together, it was only then the light blub went off. Abhi went to a lot of trouble for them to be together and she walked out on him to see her father and what was going on with him.
3) The time when she cuddled with him...She is not going to do that just for the heck of it....
Fair enough, I will give you that one. However, she spent the whole time before than crying for her mother.
4) The next day when she went to the Gurudwara for her mom she left a little Kheer for Abhi...She didn't have to if she didn't love him
They could have gone together.
5) When Abhi had arranged a romantic night she was intrested but unfortunately she had family troubles...not agreeing with her but she was intrested in wanting to be with Abhi
She didn't look the least bit interested to me. She ran off leaving him.
6) When her father was sick and Abhi showed up at the hospital she was very glad to see him and she thanked him and said sorry to him in her own way.....She always was by his side the whole time....
She might have been glad to see him but she didn't give a toss when it came to leaving him or going after him. Her husband could have walked out of her life that night but it was more important for her to know what was going on with dad. She even told Abhi she wanted to go home - back to KB - not the dhabba where the two of them lived together.
7) The time after RS came home and Simi tried to go see him and Manju wouldn't let her and Manju asked why she betrayed her sister and Simi said "meine kisko dhoka nahi diya....meine sirf Abhi se pyar kiya".....Obviously she said that for a reason....
Her saying she loved Abhi is not enough for me; my question is what has she done to show she loves him.
8) The second trial of SR she was all ready and she never shied away from being intimate with Abhi...but that night Milli had troubles and it was SimBhi to the rescue because Milli called them!!!
The point is she never initiated the desire to be with him - ever; meaning we never saw any desire in her for Abhi until Abhi said to her let us get together. This is the point I am trying to make.
9) She was trying hard herself to be with Abhi and vice versa before the actual SR....She never stopped Abhi from coming close...
That is the point I am making. It only AFTER they get the house back that she shows ANY really desire for Abhi. Until then she doesn't even look at Abhi after she is married. He might as well be chump change. She is so preoccupied with pleasing her family that she doesn't notice he exists. And it is only after he saves the house does he become important.
10) She dressed up for Abhi on the night of the SR...Why?....Because she wanted to look nice for Abhi and what he thought of her mattered to her.......
Again after the house was saved. Until the house was saved we saw nothing.
11) She hid the truth from Abhi because she did not want Abhi to do anything to Bhalla and end up in jail....If she didn't care she would not be in such a bind of what to do and not to do!!!!
Interesting. You're defending the very actions that everyone is speaking out against. Why doesn't she tell Abhi. Abhi has never done anything to warrant poor anger skills. We know that about Abhi, why doesn't she? It is a pretty insulting thing to do - keep such a secret and then call him bachcha in front of everyone. It's also more insulting when you practically spend the whole time complaining about trust but fail to trust your spouse.
Lailla...........this are the points that I felt that Simi showed her wanting Abhi...I am not asking you to agree with me.....just respect the differences of your opinion and mine! You may not agree to any or all of these reasons but they are mine....we could argue till we are blue in the face but at the end of the day you will still have your opinion and I will have mine....that is the wonderful thing about democracy😃 No hard feelings just answering what you asked!
See Daboo, these scenes worked for you, for me they didn't work. I would have liked to have seen lines like this from Simi:
"Abhi, I am so sorry I put you through so much. You have done so much for me. If it was not for you I would be married to someone like RB or Nakul, but you risked your life for me time and time again. I never asked anything of you but you gave without my asking."
"Abhi, you have stood by me and my family and I have never stood by you. Sometimes I wonder if you question my feelings for you, I never want you to doubt me or my love for you."
On the SR before they go in the room, "I never thought in my life I would be with someone like you. For years I would spend my life being rejected time and time again. I never thought I would have someone, most of all, some like you. I think I'm the luckiest girl in the world to have you."