What is the difference between fiance Ajay and Shaurya?

Vedika211 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
Yes, yes I'm going there.
Ajay had an affair with Nehal and wanted to marry Mehak only for her money. But Mehak didn't know any of those things. So what were the things that Ajay did that made her feel that he is not the one for her?

1. He pressed the bangle on her hand in the name of 'chedkhani' and it broke and her wrist bled. Shaurya asked her why she did not slap Ajay in return.
2. He tried to get intimate with her in a nightclub when they were dancing. NB: her family was not around.

Here, I'm not talking about the Ajay who abducted her and tried to rape her. But I do not want to think of Shaurya as good only because he at least is not that. During their engagement, Ajay's behaviour made Mehak uncomfortable. As is Shaurya's behaviour now.

The difference is the narrative of love. Because she loves him and he loves her. And so even if the behaviour is similar it is not presented similarly. I'm sure Ajay had a bad past too. He had a terrible person for a mother who taught him that only money matters, that as the boy he has right to do whatever he pleases and will not be held responsible for his actions. A bad past cannot justify continued bad behaviour in the present, otherwise every criminal would get off through such a justification.

Coming back to Shaurya and Mehak, this is a show and as someone correctly said, they will move on to something else soon once the track is done. But in the real world, love is an action, a verb rather than a noun. When you marry someone, you do not make the commitment to love only once. You have to love them over and over again, even on the bad days. You have to find a way to keep the essence of what you once had even as the manifestations of that change. Every bit of unkindness chips away at love, and every bit of care and thoughtfulness adds to it.

As you can guess, I'm pretty upset by the episode. I'm not saying that Shaurya cannot be possessive or he has to be only what I imagine. It is just that the version of Shaurya I liked best was the initial version: while arrogant and hotheaded, he also came across as someone who was sorted and mature in his take on things, who was very affectionate to the people he loved, who didn't care for social convention and who said things that weren't exactly feminist but were quite liberal. Yes, he was jealous at some level but his dislike of Ajay was also founded on Ajay's behaviour. He should at least be true to what he used to represent at one point of time. In the name of love, he has actually become the sort of man he used to detest.
Edited by Vedika211 - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.5k

Users

6

Likes

41

Frequent Posters

Harmony10 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: Vedika211

In the name of love, he has actually become the sort of man he used to detest.


@bold- Any doubt..matter of fact his behavior looks worse than Ajay and his father Sr. Khanna.

Thank god it's not only me who is comparing Shaurya with Ajay. Actually, I've been doing it since the air of hut scene followed by creepy balcony scene and as well today's dance. Remember the conversation between Sonal and Mehak regarding the disco incident. Mehak expressed how just because Ajay engaged her doesn't give him the right to do anything against her will. She is also a human being. Ask for her consent before doing anything. Shaurya's has been behaving like Ajay since last week. Mehak clearly stated how uncomfortable she felt during the dance yet he kept going why? Just to show the world she is only his and later their room scene. What was that? Meri Mehak Meri Mehak..He should just make a sign board and attach it to his shirt instead of repeating it over and over. It doesn't sound romantic at all.

Edited by Harmony10 - 8 years ago
Vedika211 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: Harmony10


@bold- Any doubt..matter of fact his behavior looks worse than Ajay and his father Sr. Khanna.

Thank god it's not only me who is comparing Shaurya with Ajay. Actually, I've been doing it since the air of hut scene followed by creepy balcony scene and as well today's dance. Remember the conversation between Sonal and Mehak regarding the disco incident. Mehak expressed how just because Ajay engaged her doesn't give him the right to do anything against her will. She is also a human being. Ask for her consent before doing anything. Shaurya's has been behaving like Ajay since last week. Mehak clearly stated how uncomfortable she felt during the dance yet he kept going why? Just to show the world she is only his and later their room scene. What was that? Meri Mehak Meri Mehak..He should just make a sign board and attach it to his shirt instead of repeating it over and over. It doesn't sound romantic at all.


Actually I didn't mind the hut scene and the balcony scene as much. They were both alone and I saw the first one as natural and the second one as creepy but their idea of intense.

I've been trying very hard to pinpoint exactly what it was that made yesterday's episode different. And the one thing that stood out was this memory: Ajay pawing her and this man, who stood there just looking at them, and conveyed in the very way he was standing what he thought of Ajay's behaviour. I think I felt the loss of that Shaurya the most keenly.

Swasa thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Nice post dear, very well pointed out the recent SK behaviour. If a person love someone but keep hurting her based on past, he need a psychiatrist not marriage with a girl. He is a mentally disoriented with this behaviour he will make MS also like him.

In the restaurant when Svetlana insulted Magek he said sorry. But in private when he made a scar on neck and hurt on the hand , he didn't say sorry but kiss her and get physical touchy touchy. So for Shourya sorry means touching and kissing Mahek. All I was expecting was SK would love Mahek to the core and would guard her in every possible way. Help her in achieving her dreams and romance her with love not forcedly.

Last week SK was a hero, this week vamphire and next week what it will be.
DiyaKash thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
Yeah Vedika, Showrya then and now are poles apart!! What I had liked during the whole first Ajay and fake wedding prep saga was that he empowered her to handle a situation. And he stepped in when the situation went beyond control.

Since the wedding we have seen a continuous decline in his character, most redeemable. But, if they continue the path they are on, it is beyond redemption. And I agree with all you girls, who have said in various posts, that they will brush this under the carpet, explain it away and Mehak will still be unexplainably in love. How disfunctional is that!

Like you said, every bit of unkind action chips away at the love. And it is not a love that will withstand over time. But, that is reality and this is show. I don't think the show was ever headed towards showing the deep mature love. But, to me the disheartening thing is this butchering of a character that we have all come to love. Every degradation in Showrya's character is chipping away the magic of Mehrya for us! 😕
Edited by DiyaKash - 8 years ago
Vedika211 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Swasa

Nice post dear, very well pointed out the recent SK behaviour. If a person love someone but keep hurting her based on past, he need a psychiatrist not marriage with a girl. He is a mentally disoriented with this behaviour he will make MS also like him.

In the restaurant when Svetlana insulted Magek he said sorry. But in private when he made a scar on neck and hurt on the hand , he didn't say sorry but kiss her and get physical touchy touchy. So for Shourya sorry means touching and kissing Mahek. All I was expecting was SK would love Mahek to the core and would guard her in every possible way. Help her in achieving her dreams and romance her with love not forcedly.

Last week SK was a hero, this week vamphire and next week what it will be.


Thank you!

Yes we're getting very different things from what we expected.
Vedika211 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: DiyaKash

Yeah Vedika, Showrya then and now are poles apart!! What I had liked during the whole first Ajay and fake wedding prep saga was that he empowered her to handle a situation. And he stepped in when the situation went beyond control.


Since the wedding we have seen a continuous decline in his character, most redeemable. But, if they continue the path they are on, it is beyond redemption. And I agree with all you girls, who have said in various posts, that they will brush this under the carpet, explain it away and Mehak will still be unexplainably in love. How disfunctional is that!

Like you said, every bit of unkind action chips away at the love. And it is not a love that will withstand over time. But, that is reality and this is show. I don't think the show was ever headed towards showing the deep mature love. But, to me the disheartening thing is this butchering of a character that we have all come to love. Every degradation in Showrya's character is chipping away the magic of Mehrya for us! 😕


Exactly. Even I liked how he always tried to empower her first, getting her to resist rather than doing her resisting for her.

@Italics: yes, there are other couples of tv who can push and pull each other, mouth romantic lines and give shirtless scenes and so on. The magic of these two had been not only the actors but the characters. Sometimes the actors could not deliver - for e.g. we sometimes found Karan Vohra awkward in some romantic scenes - but we still went on watching and appreciating because the larger narrative worked for us, and we could feel for Shaurya and Mehak as characters beyond these momentary lapses. When we stop feeling for the characters, the magic is going to suffer too.
ms.nitya12 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
There is a huge difference between respecting boundaries & fencing or being territorial, control is never security or being possessive in love, obsession is not care or deep love and as you've pointed out the underlying difference is when the person in question in a relationship feels cherished, empowered & appreciated it's love but if the feelings turn into fear & suffocating, then somewhere the lines are getting blurred, Mehak was going through an ache of exhaustion, the ache inside her intensified as the unwelcomed answers to the questions presented itself,her fears unfortunately will turn into a terrible reality in tonight's episode. Mehak's look in the precap was one of agnoy of shock & disbelief, Shaurya's parties are turning into tamashas, Mehak is facing constant humiliation in front of both the families, everything around is changing, shifting, veering dangerously out of control!
Why are the CVs butchering their own solid characters, Kanta barely managed to return back from slaughterhouse, Shaurya was to be redeemed in love, the shade of greys were supposed to turn lighter brighter but unfortunately he is now turning darkest of dark, why?
Musharat1 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
Major difference shaurya had dreadful past not ajay. Ajay was behind mahek money not shaurya. Ajay didnt loved mahek while shaurya does. Rest I agree with u.
Vedika211 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Musharat1

Major difference shaurya had dreadful past not ajay. Ajay was behind mahek money not shaurya. Ajay didnt loved mahek while shaurya does. Rest I agree with u.


I see what you mean.
But can I play devil's advocate for some time?

Ajay may have had a bad past or a bad childhood too. We just never got to see it because he is not the hero of this story. Shaurya is not after Mehak's money because he does not need to be. Now I'm not saying that if he were poor Shaurya would love Mehak for money, just saying that it is easier to be unconcerned about money when you have a lot of it.

And yes, I also agree with you that Shaurya loves Mehak, and that is why I know that the situations are not exactly the same. But I do miss the Shaurya of that time who was very clear about how he felt Mehak ought to be treated.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".